Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
John,

Scientists are natural sceptics-and we're also sceptical about debunking. Almost all of us on this blog, following Graham and others, believe in some form of catastrophism, but very few were worried on December 12. There are those on this board that are regarded as "truthers (911)," "birthers (Obama's birthplace)," or "deniers (global warming)," and some are all three. You would seem to believe that the first two have been debunked, but global warming denial is correct--with McKibben, Gore, Hansen, and others as doomsdayers or (false) alarmists.

There are also those on this board who believe in spirits, aliens from outer space, and unidentified flying objects. There are many who are discouraged with American political parties and Obama, some believeing that all governments are controlled by a few wealthy kingmakers--and I haven't even yet gotten to Giza and the pyramids. I'd urge a dose of caution in using debunking as an infallible tool for determining the "truth" of such claims.

A scientist looks at these issues from a probabalistic perspective, if studies can be carried out--or as unknowable The more evidence, the more something is true--but we can never say that anything is absolutely true--or false. I might not believe in alien encounters--until a little green man walks through the door. That wouldn't convicne you, tohough, would it? I may not be a truther, but I can still refuse to accept conventional explanations of 911--and see weaknesses in efforts to debunk. The world may not end tomorrow, but there are earthquakes, volcanoes, and weather pattern changes.

Some "doomsdayers" may be trying to sell something. Some may be mentally ill--like Vincent van Gogh.


The Lurker

Quote

Lurker does not participate in normal forum discourse, but he's out there...watching, reading every message. He is usually quite harmless, and more often than not his silence reflects a natural reticence rather than sinister motives. If a fight breaks out he will quietly observe to avoid revealing his position. Occasionally, however, some mysterious impulse drives him to de-lurk and attack. This totally unexpected assault is universally regarded as an ambush, and other Warriors will turn on him savagely. Lurker seldom sticks around to fight it out, however, and after a brief exchange, he once again slips out of sight. . . .


Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 451 Graham Hancock 02-Feb-13 14:57
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 237 hansmittendorf 02-Feb-13 16:46
Re: How many are willing to listen/NT 245 Thunderbird 02-Feb-13 18:02
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 278 endofworldbook 02-Feb-13 23:00
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 290 Sirius7237 02-Feb-13 23:32
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 165 endofworldbook 03-Feb-13 02:58
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 250 Sirius7237 03-Feb-13 17:35
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 206 endofworldbook 04-Feb-13 01:58
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 252 cladking 03-Feb-13 02:01
Re: Welcome to Justin Deering our featured author for February 235 endofworldbook 03-Feb-13 03:14
Re: 5th Sun.....age of the Priest 454 Thunderbird 03-Feb-13 04:06
Re: 5th Sun.....age of the Priest 282 cladking 04-Feb-13 03:56
Science, scepticism, and debunking 240 drrayeye 03-Feb-13 18:17
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 283 carolb 03-Feb-13 19:12
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 318 endofworldbook 04-Feb-13 01:49
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 283 drrayeye 04-Feb-13 05:54
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 257 endofworldbook 04-Feb-13 13:09
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 282 Aine 04-Feb-13 13:46
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 208 endofworldbook 04-Feb-13 14:49
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 284 Aine 04-Feb-13 15:22
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 261 endofworldbook 04-Feb-13 15:48
Re: Science, scepticism, and debunking 199 Aine 04-Feb-13 15:52
Yes, well said! 277 Dr. Lew Graham 03-Feb-13 14:07


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.