Author of the Month :
The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world.
> SC: Well let us go back a step, shall we. You did not answer my
> question. You answered my initial question stating that the
> geometric relationships exhibited between G1 and G3 was
> probably coincidence and then when I subsequently asked you to
> quantify your probability, you then claimed you had "no idea".
So, I answered your initial question. And then I answered your follow-up question with "I have no idea how probable".
Questions answered.
> How can something, in your opinion, be "probably coincidence"
> when you have "no idea" how that might be so?
That is not what I said. I never commented on "how that might be so". Again, I said that "I have no idea how probable".
Here is a much needed crash course in probabilities for you: For something to be "probable", the probability must be above 50%. To quantify the probability in this particular case is impossible since we do not have all the variables needed to do the calculation.
> MA: You are in no position to demand anything.
> SC: Oh but I am.
No. See above.
> I am the Author of the Month here.. [snip]
Then act like it.
I shall leave it to the readers to decide for themselves if I have answered your question or not.
They might also ponder why you refuse to answer a relevant question concerning your hypothesis.
Morten
> question. You answered my initial question stating that the
> geometric relationships exhibited between G1 and G3 was
> probably coincidence and then when I subsequently asked you to
> quantify your probability, you then claimed you had "no idea".
So, I answered your initial question. And then I answered your follow-up question with "I have no idea how probable".
Questions answered.
> How can something, in your opinion, be "probably coincidence"
> when you have "no idea" how that might be so?
That is not what I said. I never commented on "how that might be so". Again, I said that "I have no idea how probable".
Here is a much needed crash course in probabilities for you: For something to be "probable", the probability must be above 50%. To quantify the probability in this particular case is impossible since we do not have all the variables needed to do the calculation.
> MA: You are in no position to demand anything.
> SC: Oh but I am.
No. See above.
> I am the Author of the Month here.. [snip]
Then act like it.
I shall leave it to the readers to decide for themselves if I have answered your question or not.
They might also ponder why you refuse to answer a relevant question concerning your hypothesis.
Morten
Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.