Rebecca Bradley Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Hello again, Martin.
> You make a great fuss of the fact that your papers
> are peer-reviewed. Can you comment on the
> following paper, which also appeared in the same
> peer-reviewed journal as your Gobekli Tepe paper?
>
> [maajournal.com]
> 019(1).pdf?fbclid=IwAR304tj6AEs41LfXQjTqz2K57n0f9C
> yNAtmjzMeegCTyNjbtFHQVKkaII1A
>
> Here are my comments on it:
> [www.skepticink.com]
> /michael-jayes-just-so-story/
>
> To my mind, it rather calls into question the
> quality of peer review at that particular journal.
> I would be interested in your take on the matter.


Speaking of which, to where your article appears, I would question a web site that promotes a direct secular-atheist assault on Canadians' freedom of expression.

[www.skepticink.com]

When I see stuff like this, I wonder what really drives a site's other evaluations.

That said, Rebecca, I really don't mean to be unfair. I only mention a possible flag. I enjoyed your piece - what I could understand - but it's well beyond my level of knowledge in the necessary areas. I don't understand enough about GT to comment on your specific differences with Martin.



Edited 4 time(s). Last edit at 08-Aug-19 18:51 by Poster Boy.