Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Jason Jarrell Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> At Aine:
>
> Although archaeologists frequently use the average
> stature range for Adena in Webb and Snow's Adena
> People No. 1, which is 5.51 feet for males 5.20
> for females, the fact is that they based this
> ratio on studies of the bones of a mere 20 males
> and 6 females from Kentucky well enough preserved
> for measurement. Considering that the Adena
> Culture was also in Pennsylvania, Ohio, Indiana,
> and West Virginia in the Ohio Valley, as well as
> in New York State, Southern Ontario, New
> Brunswick, Tennessee, Alabama, and along the Mid
> to North Atlantic Coast, it is my opinion that
> this data may be skewed and not entirely reliable.
>
>
> Of course, this does not mean at all that I am
> suggesting that all Adena people were the "Tall
> Ones", just that we probably don't have a well
> researched average" stature estimate. Most Adena
> were under 6 feet in height.

Hi Jason,

Even today, there are only two peoples that I know of where males average 6 feet: the Dutch and the men of Ethiopia, who average 6'3" if I recall correctly.

My point is this. To a people who average 5'5" (women being considerably shorter), 6 feet is huge--gigantic, in fact. That's above +2 standard deviations. Taking the 7 and 8 footers as outliers which you'd expect in any population, do you think it's possible that the Tall Ones could simply be people much taller than the Adena and Hopewell themselves, say 6 feet or better?

Also, I wonder if the giants served as shamans and spiritual leaders because of their visual anomalies as David pointed out. Perhaps the Adena thought they already had a conduit to the spirit world?

I would like to thank you for not claiming there were 13 or 14 ft. tall giants roaming around!

In the spring, at the end of the day, you should smell like earth. ~ Margaret Atwood

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 2710 Jason Jarrell 05-Mar-18 17:37
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 465 Susan Doris 06-Mar-18 06:01
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 516 drdavidanderson 06-Mar-18 10:15
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 503 Susan Doris 06-Mar-18 12:48
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 465 Aine 07-Mar-18 03:44
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 477 Jason Jarrell 07-Mar-18 04:12
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 473 Aine 07-Mar-18 04:36
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 464 Jason Jarrell 07-Mar-18 05:09
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 450 Aine 07-Mar-18 13:40
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 463 Jason Jarrell 07-Mar-18 18:26
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 451 Aine 07-Mar-18 21:41
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 501 Jason Jarrell 08-Mar-18 00:18
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 470 Aine 08-Mar-18 22:52
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 482 Aine 07-Mar-18 03:46
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 460 Susan Doris 07-Mar-18 05:59
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 476 Jason Jarrell 07-Mar-18 07:55
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 449 Aine 07-Mar-18 13:18
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 455 Susan Doris 07-Mar-18 14:39
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 474 SkinwalkerScrooge 09-Mar-18 19:51
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 459 Susan Doris 10-Mar-18 06:03
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 475 drdavidanderson 10-Mar-18 07:52
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 445 Susan Doris 10-Mar-18 08:40
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 444 SkinwalkerScrooge 10-Mar-18 09:09
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 468 Aine 10-Mar-18 13:49
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 443 Jason Jarrell 10-Mar-18 21:04
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 446 Aine 10-Mar-18 13:31
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 443 Aine 10-Mar-18 13:16
Re: The Socio-Political Structure of Adena Societies 840 SkinwalkerScrooge 11-Mar-18 05:46


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.