Paranormal & Supernatural :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions of everything that might be classed as ‘paranormal‘ - i.e. not currently accepted by our modern scientific paradigm. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
thirdpal wrote:

> "You don't need to be in a trance to channel. Mozart wrote his
> first symphony when he was eight years old." David L
>
> This just a matter of semantics, as I don't doubt some people
> channel, but by that definition, Mozart was not a medium - by
> definitions as I understand it, he was either a channel or
> musical shaman ([personally, I'd vote for the last).

Medium, channel...same thing. It's how the results are used. You are splitting hairs.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 538 Richard Fusniak 14-Jan-15 18:38
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 232 David L 14-Jan-15 23:29
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 200 Brian Patterson 14-Jan-15 23:59
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 229 David L 15-Jan-15 01:06
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 195 Richard Fusniak 15-Jan-15 09:47
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 209 thirdpal 27-Jan-15 15:51
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 222 David L 29-Jan-15 16:47
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 217 ray wakila 30-Jan-15 00:04
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 218 thirdpal 30-Jan-15 17:12
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 283 David L 30-Jan-15 22:55
Re: Fate 200 Hummer 15-Jan-15 02:27
Re: Fate 208 David L 15-Jan-15 04:29
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 192 OzzieThinker 15-Jan-15 04:59
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 174 OzzieThinker 15-Jan-15 05:03
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 227 Richard Fusniak 15-Jan-15 09:54
Rosicrucians: Controlling world events via magick 332 David L 15-Jan-15 21:47
Re: Rosicrucians: Controlling world events via magick 289 Richard Fusniak 16-Jan-15 07:30
Re: Rosicrucians: Controlling world events via magick 229 David L 16-Jan-15 12:59
They've been in UK for centuries 213 David L 16-Jan-15 13:13
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 224 eli stills 15-Jan-15 23:24
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 195 Richard Fusniak 16-Jan-15 07:27
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 272 eli stills 16-Jan-15 16:06
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 205 greengirl5 20-Jan-15 11:51
Re: Spiritualism and Reincarnation revisited 240 thirdpal 20-Jan-15 17:50


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.