Paranormal & Supernatural :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions of everything that might be classed as ‘paranormal‘ - i.e. not currently accepted by our modern scientific paradigm. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
How can someone plagiarise something that doesn't exist.
You realise of course that sitchin has now moved on from sumeria and babylon and is now "having a pop at the ancient greeks". I'm sure everyone's seen Troy by now starring brad pitt and eric bana, and that elf from lord of the rings heh heh (didn't you notice how he only became an affective soldier when he was using his bow). But according to stitchin it didn't happen quite like that cos they missed out the spaceships.

"It was only thus, I explained, that all the texts and depictions from antiquity showing men and gods can be explained and understood. The visit to Troy and its tale was affirmation of the actual presence of those whom the Sumerians called Anunnaki: “Those who from Heaven to Earth came.”
The visit to Troy, described in the first chapter of my new book, was thus my Trojan Horse for that logical conclusion."

Bet you're not so convinced sitchin has a valid point now. Wait for his next book which will claim that the ancient gods of egypt are from betelgeuse.
And thor and odin are from sirius. etc etc

From the fall of troy we get the phrase"beware of greeks bearing gifts"
from sitchins version I get "watch out this guy's a nutter"

If I really need to prove my point i'll do cuneiform 101 for you all so that you can see how the language evolved slowly over 4000 years.
But I hope it isn't Necesary

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 452 Levitating Cat 29-Oct-04 12:29
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 203 marduk 29-Oct-04 14:04
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 94 marduk 29-Oct-04 17:17
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 151 Nejc 29-Oct-04 17:05
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 186 Sterling 29-Oct-04 19:02
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 197 marduk 29-Oct-04 20:47
Sitchin is a looney 168 marduk 29-Oct-04 19:36
Sitchin not here to defend himself 178 Richard Fusniak 29-Oct-04 21:01
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 186 marduk 29-Oct-04 21:34
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 166 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 00:00
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 161 marduk 30-Oct-04 01:45
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 194 Hoppy 30-Oct-04 02:43
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 183 Joyeuse 30-Oct-04 02:47
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 225 marduk 30-Oct-04 03:10
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 188 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 12:50
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 199 Joyeuse 01-Nov-04 00:31
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 202 marduk 01-Nov-04 01:57
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 129 music 01-Nov-04 14:41
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 162 Mercury Rapids 01-Nov-04 14:53
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 190 marduk 01-Nov-04 14:59
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 196 Mercury Rapids 01-Nov-04 15:11
Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 128 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 11:43
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 70 marduk 30-Oct-04 13:22
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 188 Essan 30-Oct-04 13:29
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 147 marduk 30-Oct-04 14:06
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 184 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 14:19
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 125 marduk 30-Oct-04 14:30
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 186 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 14:43
....... ?? 170 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 14:48
Re: ....... ?? 126 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 14:51
fooled 101 marduk 30-Oct-04 14:55
Re: ....... ?? 92 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 15:23
Re: ....... ?? 139 Essan 30-Oct-04 15:54
Re: ....... ?? 188 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 15:58
Re: ....... ?? 109 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 16:01
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 177 Essan 30-Oct-04 14:56
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 173 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 15:07
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 190 Essan 30-Oct-04 15:14
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 209 marduk 30-Oct-04 15:16
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 115 marduk 30-Oct-04 15:24
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 107 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 15:54
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 175 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 15:58
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 170 Nejc 30-Oct-04 23:20
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 102 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 23:31
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 169 Nejc 30-Oct-04 23:42
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 154 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 23:46
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 157 Nejc 30-Oct-04 23:57
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 147 marduk 31-Oct-04 00:01
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 180 Nejc 31-Oct-04 00:10
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 194 Mercury Rapids 31-Oct-04 00:11
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 187 Nejc 31-Oct-04 00:15
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 160 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 15:25
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 178 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 15:29
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 191 marduk 30-Oct-04 15:31
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 150 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 18:54
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 182 marduk 30-Oct-04 19:03
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 191 Cesar 30-Oct-04 17:35
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 181 marduk 30-Oct-04 17:47
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 107 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 17:48
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 185 music 30-Oct-04 18:37
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 179 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 18:44
A Mercury (Rapid) 110 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 19:02
Re: A Mercury (Rapid) 173 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 19:06
p.s. 153 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 19:18
Re: p.s. 199 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 20:28
Re: p.s. 186 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 20:37
Re: A Mercury (Rapid) 188 marduk 30-Oct-04 19:15
Re: A Mercury (Rapid) 111 Richard Fusniak 30-Oct-04 20:56
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 215 music 30-Oct-04 19:04
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 188 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 19:16
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 108 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 21:03
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 97 marduk 30-Oct-04 21:28
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 181 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 21:36
Re: Orbiting bodies obey laws of physics 143 marduk 30-Oct-04 21:41
a question. 127 come on pilgrim 05-Nov-04 00:09
Re: Sitchin not here to defend himself 194 Joyeuse 30-Oct-04 02:44
Re: Sitchin is a looney 177 SphinxGirl 30-Oct-04 05:28
Re: Sitchin is a looney 190 marduk 30-Oct-04 13:31
Re: Sitchin is a looney 186 SphinxGirl 30-Oct-04 19:24
Re: Sitchin is a looney 147 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 19:28
Re: Sitchin is a looney 92 SphinxGirl 30-Oct-04 19:43
Re: Sitchin is a looney 158 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 19:48
Re: Sitchin is a looney 189 music 30-Oct-04 20:09
Re: Sitchin is a looney 195 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 20:28
Re: Sitchin is a looney 157 music 30-Oct-04 21:12
Re: Sitchin is a looney 170 Mercury Rapids 30-Oct-04 21:20
Re: Sitchin is a looney 147 SphinxGirl 31-Oct-04 10:41
Re: Sitchin is a looney 197 music 31-Oct-04 15:45
Re: Sitchin is a looney 151 marduk 31-Oct-04 17:28
Re: Sitchin is a looney 213 music 31-Oct-04 17:48
Re: Sitchin is a looney 114 marduk 31-Oct-04 18:18
Re: Sitchin is a looney 216 music 31-Oct-04 18:24
Re: Sitchin is a looney 129 Mercury Rapids 31-Oct-04 18:59
Re: Sitchin is a looney 184 SphinxGirl 31-Oct-04 10:40
Re: Sitchin is a looney 147 Mercury Rapids 31-Oct-04 14:14
Re: Sitchin is a looney 177 SphinxGirl 31-Oct-04 20:17
Mod remark 193 Kees 31-Oct-04 20:31
Re: Sitchin is a looney 203 Mercury Rapids 31-Oct-04 20:38
Mod request 160 Kees 31-Oct-04 21:01
Re: Mod request 118 Mercury Rapids 31-Oct-04 21:06
Re: Mod request 201 Kees 31-Oct-04 21:20
Re: Mod request 193 marduk 31-Oct-04 22:19
Get healed 166 Raja 31-Oct-04 23:01
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? no n/t 168 marduk 30-Oct-04 21:38
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? no n/t 109 SphinxGirl 31-Oct-04 10:46
What Sitchin said in the interview 126 Richard Fusniak 31-Oct-04 13:18
Re: What Sitchin said in the interview 176 SphinxGirl 31-Oct-04 20:25
Re: What Sitchin said in the interview 128 Hoppy 31-Oct-04 23:07
Inka was worshipped as Enki? 252 Anne-Marie 02-Nov-04 11:26
Re: Inka was worshipped as Enki? 187 marduk 02-Nov-04 12:30
Re: Inka was worshipped as Enki? 203 Raja 02-Nov-04 13:22
Re: Inka was worshipped as Enki? 163 marduk 02-Nov-04 14:12
Re: Inka was worshipped as Enki? 205 Essan 02-Nov-04 16:26
Re: Inka was worshipped as Enki? 144 marduk 02-Nov-04 17:47
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 118 Sterling 02-Nov-04 16:02
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 208 marduk 02-Nov-04 16:08
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 114 Raja 02-Nov-04 19:56
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 203 marduk 03-Nov-04 12:04
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 229 Mercury Rapids 03-Nov-04 12:15
Re: Has Sitchin been acknowledged or plagiarised? 116 marduk 03-Nov-04 12:25


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.