Paranormal & Supernatural :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions of everything that might be classed as ‘paranormal‘ - i.e. not currently accepted by our modern scientific paradigm. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
hi Daniel,

as discussed here:
[grahamhancock.com]

some starting assumptions of those "models" need describing
1. life "as we know it" would require liquid water
2. a water world would infer an atmosphere
3, maintaining an atmosphere would seem to require a magnetic field
4. a magnetic field requires a conducting core and planet rotation

but i don't see any mention of these

Quote

However, while powerful computer simulations do utilize hard data to make their predictions, the results are far from guaranteed. Experts advise caution in taking these findings at face value. In a conversation with Gizmodo, astrophysicist Sean Raymond says that Simpson’s paper puzzles him. He goes on to explain that predicting how much water might be on a planet is impossible since we can’t account for how much water is delivered to a given planet. “In the ‘classical model’ of terrestrial planet formation, water delivery to Earth is very [random] so it’s reasonable to imagine alternate Earths with over ten times more water,” he says. “However, in our newer models much less water is delivered but the delivery is more reliable.”

1. water is "delivered" to the planets.. Uber, perhaps?
or dirty snowball comets?
or the "planet" was once a comet, later captured by the sun?
2. it is not how much water the planet received, but how much it retained
3. and in order to retain liquid water, an atmosphere is needed
and in order to retain an atmosphere, a magnetic field is needed
and in order to have a magnetic field, the planet must have sufficient rotation

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 13232 D-Archer 02-Feb-15 13:34
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1289 Brian Patterson 02-Feb-15 15:48
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1207 D-Archer 02-Feb-15 16:13
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1167 Brian Patterson 02-Feb-15 16:23
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1000 D-Archer 02-Feb-15 20:14
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1113 Susan Doris 02-Feb-15 17:43
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1181 loveritas 03-Feb-15 22:01
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 986 D-Archer 04-Feb-15 11:33
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1117 loveritas 05-Feb-15 21:13
GTSM- Phase Transitions of Stars 1140 D-Archer 22-Feb-15 10:31
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1175 Thunderbird 07-Mar-15 16:59
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 992 D-Archer 08-Mar-15 13:19
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1151 brett z 08-Mar-15 18:25
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1017 D-Archer 09-Mar-15 09:13
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1024 brett z 11-Mar-15 03:13
Re: off topic/ 1031 D-Archer 11-Mar-15 11:10
Re: off topic/ 1032 brett z 11-Mar-15 11:35
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 706 jeffreyw 22-Nov-17 23:38
GTSM Animated 1069 D-Archer 12-Mar-16 10:59
Re: GTSM Animated - part 2 1097 D-Archer 16-Apr-16 13:38
Gas giants evolve 1090 D-Archer 05-Jul-16 08:49
Re: Gas giants evolve 904 jeffreyw 11-Jul-17 02:55
'Waterworld’ Earth preceded late rise of continents 1128 D-Archer 01-Jan-17 11:18
Phase Transitions 923 D-Archer 12-Feb-17 12:37
GTSM - Timeline 1041 D-Archer 19-Feb-17 09:08
Research Indicates That Most Habitable Planets Might Be “Water Worlds” 1003 D-Archer 06-May-17 08:57
Re: Research Indicates That Most Habitable Planets Might Be “Water Worlds” 1036 laughin 06-May-17 14:09
Re: Research Indicates That Most Habitable Planets Might Be “Water Worlds” 946 D-Archer 07-May-17 07:01
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 972 D-Archer 09-May-17 08:28
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 857 jeffreyw 10-May-17 19:43
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 853 D-Archer 12-May-17 09:26
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 821 brett z 12-May-17 11:24
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 1022 D-Archer 12-May-17 14:56
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 922 brett z 14-May-17 22:57
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 1020 D-Archer 15-May-17 11:50
Re: extra> Earth was barren, flat and almost entirely under water 4.4 billion years ago 881 jeffreyw 12-May-17 18:47
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 1000 jeffreyw 10-May-17 19:56
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 986 Reagent 12-May-17 08:05
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 919 D-Archer 12-May-17 08:53
Primitive atmosphere discovered around 'Warm Neptune' 824 D-Archer 16-May-17 11:20
Re: Primitive atmosphere discovered around 'Warm Neptune' 826 jeffreyw 17-May-17 14:58
Re: Primitive atmosphere discovered around 'Warm Neptune' 906 brett z 18-May-17 00:38
Surprise! When a brown dwarf is actually a planetary mass object 1049 D-Archer 16-May-17 12:05
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 911 laughin 18-May-17 23:18
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 881 jeffreyw 20-May-17 23:06
Stars can "start" shining at a smaller mass than we thought 913 D-Archer 27-May-17 07:48
Re: Stars can "start" shining at a smaller mass than we thought 972 jeffreyw 28-May-17 13:33
Gas Giant evolution in Mainstream Science 790 D-Archer 10-Jun-17 12:33
Re: Gas Giant evolution in Mainstream Science 815 brett z 10-Jun-17 13:36
Re: Gas Giant evolution in Mainstream Science 1012 jeffreyw 10-Jun-17 14:29
Super Earths and Mini Neptunes 930 D-Archer 02-Jul-17 10:19
Re: Super Earths and Mini Neptunes 927 jeffreyw 03-Jul-17 18:05
Mobility, Volume and Gravity Principles for Forming Life 831 D-Archer 30-Sep-17 11:06
Re: Mobility, Volume and Gravity Principles for Forming Life 716 jeffreyw 23-Oct-17 23:47
Re: Mobility, Volume and Gravity Principles for Forming Life 734 D-Archer 24-Oct-17 08:21
Re: Mobility, Volume and Gravity Principles for Forming Life 849 jeffreyw 24-Oct-17 21:09
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 811 ianw16 27-Oct-17 08:54
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 725 jeffreyw 27-Oct-17 15:17
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 789 ianw16 27-Oct-17 15:27
Hot, rocky exoplanets are the scorched cores of former gas giants 800 D-Archer 01-Nov-17 12:25
Re: Hot, rocky exoplanets are the scorched cores of former gas giants 718 jeffreyw 01-Nov-17 20:28
Re: Hot, rocky exoplanets are the scorched cores of former gas giants 784 ianw16 02-Nov-17 00:28
The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 769 D-Archer 06-Nov-17 11:02
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 770 ianw16 06-Nov-17 13:27
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 710 jeffreyw 07-Nov-17 14:39
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 743 D-Archer 07-Nov-17 18:36
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 729 ianw16 08-Nov-17 00:10
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 739 jeffreyw 15-Nov-17 22:15
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 712 ianw16 16-Nov-17 01:02
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 752 jeffreyw 08-Nov-17 00:53
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 726 D-Archer 08-Nov-17 12:42
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 709 ianw16 08-Nov-17 12:54
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 853 jeffreyw 08-Nov-17 21:56
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 714 D-Archer 12-Nov-17 12:58
Re: The 'Closest' Star to Our Own Solar System 735 jeffreyw 13-Nov-17 16:33
Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 721 D-Archer 14-Nov-17 09:02
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 736 ianw16 15-Nov-17 17:22
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 852 D-Archer 17-Nov-17 09:44
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 742 jeffreyw 17-Nov-17 14:49
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 731 jeffreyw 20-Nov-17 15:24
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 711 D-Archer 22-Nov-17 10:54
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 692 jeffreyw 22-Nov-17 13:32
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 714 D-Archer 23-Nov-17 10:34
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 693 jeffreyw 24-Nov-17 17:47
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) 726 jeffreyw 22-Nov-17 14:52
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) update 664 D-Archer 28-Feb-18 16:01
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) update 649 jeffreyw 01-Mar-18 18:26
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) update 629 D-Archer 02-Mar-18 14:25
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Formation of Rings (Dust Belts) update 658 jeffreyw 02-Mar-18 18:18
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 729 jeffreyw 27-Nov-17 15:01
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 701 jeffreyw 05-Dec-17 21:05
Doing research for Astron Classification paper, found this picture 744 D-Archer 06-Dec-17 15:58
Re: Doing research for Astron Classification paper, found this picture 697 jeffreyw 06-Dec-17 19:25
Re: Doing research for Astron Classification paper, found this picture 721 D-Archer 06-Dec-17 19:45
Re: Doing research for Astron Classification paper, found this picture 789 jeffreyw 06-Dec-17 20:46
Astron Classification Table 681 D-Archer 16-Dec-17 19:21
Re: Astron Classification Table 729 jeffreyw 17-Dec-17 16:47
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 723 jeffreyw 02-Jan-18 17:57
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 732 jeffreyw 06-Jan-18 20:25
From Neptune to Earth - new paper 694 D-Archer 13-Jan-18 20:17
Re: From Neptune to Earth - new paper 695 jeffreyw 15-Jan-18 15:08
Re: From Neptune to Earth - new paper 678 jeffreyw 18-Jan-18 14:53
Re: From Neptune to Earth - new paper 665 D-Archer 19-Jan-18 14:04
Re: From Neptune to Earth - new paper 675 jeffreyw 19-Jan-18 16:07
Total woo 686 ianw16 18-Jan-18 12:24
Locations for the K2-138 Objects and Io on the WT Diagram 751 jeffreyw 22-Jan-18 15:59
Surface Temp/Population of Stars Paper Update 667 jeffreyw 28-Jan-18 23:35
Re: Surface Temp/Population of Stars Paper Update 635 D-Archer 29-Jan-18 13:44
Re: Surface Temp/Population of Stars Paper Update 640 jeffreyw 29-Jan-18 15:27
Conservation of Mass and Stars in the General Theory (new paper) 677 jeffreyw 05-Feb-18 18:53
Re: Conservation of Mass and Stars in the General Theory (new paper) 653 D-Archer 06-Feb-18 14:05
Re: Conservation of Mass and Stars in the General Theory (new paper) 724 jeffreyw 06-Feb-18 16:26
Hubble observes exoplanet atmosphere in more detail than ever before 643 D-Archer 07-Mar-18 13:36
Re: Hubble observes exoplanet atmosphere in more detail than ever before 652 jeffreyw 07-Mar-18 17:16
Re: Hubble observes exoplanet atmosphere in more detail than ever before 650 D-Archer 08-Mar-18 10:41
Re: Hubble observes exoplanet atmosphere in more detail than ever before 637 jeffreyw 08-Mar-18 15:08
Re: Electric Universe Nonsense Debunked clearly here. 696 jamesglory 08-Mar-18 11:03
Re: Electric Universe Nonsense Debunked clearly here. 682 jeffreyw 08-Mar-18 14:33
Re: The Solar Fusion model for the Sun has totally Failed ! 675 Thunderbird 08-Mar-18 19:34
Re: The Solar Fusion model for the Sun has totally Failed ! 661 jeffreyw 12-Mar-18 07:14
The Truth About Exoplanet False Positives 664 jeffreyw 09-Mar-18 20:48
Re: The Truth About Exoplanet False Positives 670 D-Archer 10-Mar-18 12:04
Re: The Truth About Exoplanet False Positives 709 jeffreyw 12-Mar-18 14:22
The Locations of K2-229b and K2-229 on the WT Diagram 677 jeffreyw 01-Apr-18 09:43
The Location of Mars on the Wolynski-Taylor Diagram 658 jeffreyw 03-Apr-18 18:37
Re: The Location of Mars on the Wolynski-Taylor Diagram 660 D-Archer 04-Apr-18 15:51
Re: The Location of Mars on the Wolynski-Taylor Diagram 641 jeffreyw 05-Apr-18 19:12
The Diameter Principle of Stellar Evolution 657 jeffreyw 09-Apr-18 15:52
Connecting the Dots with Mass-Radius Relationship of Stars 632 jeffreyw 15-Apr-18 21:27
Re: Connecting the Dots with Mass-Radius Relationship of Stars 635 D-Archer 16-Apr-18 10:27
Re: Connecting the Dots with Mass-Radius Relationship of Stars 668 jeffreyw 16-Apr-18 11:37
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 660 jeffreyw 01-May-18 09:11
WASP-107b, a Star that Will Never Form Life 645 jeffreyw 14-May-18 19:04
Re: WASP-107b, a Star that Will Never Form Life 619 D-Archer 16-May-18 15:26
Stellar Metamorphosis: Life Paradigm 614 D-Archer 23-May-18 14:38
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Life Paradigm 629 jeffreyw 23-May-18 16:36
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Life Paradigm 667 D-Archer 24-May-18 07:12
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Life Paradigm 581 jeffreyw 21-Aug-18 19:47
Life Paradigm - cool video with great music ! 588 D-Archer 22-Aug-18 10:10
The Cassandra Ratio 620 jeffreyw 03-Jun-18 15:44
Ganymede on WT Diagram 644 jeffreyw 13-Jun-18 13:19
Panspermia Assumption Exposed 604 jeffreyw 21-Jun-18 00:05
Re: Panspermia Assumption Exposed 617 D-Archer 22-Jun-18 15:35
Re: Panspermia Assumption Exposed 566 jeffreyw 25-Jun-18 17:47
Re: Panspermia Assumption Exposed 592 D-Archer 26-Jun-18 14:53
Re: Panspermia Assumption Exposed 599 jeffreyw 27-Jun-18 01:25
J. Scott Armstrong vs. Stellar Metamorphosis, A Author's Formula 593 jeffreyw 25-Jun-18 11:25
Variable Rate of Mass Loss New Paper 595 jeffreyw 29-Jun-18 13:58
Re: Variable Rate of Mass Loss New Paper 566 ianw16 05-Jul-18 09:38
Many asteroids might be remnants of five destroyed worlds 618 D-Archer 06-Jul-18 08:43
Re: Many asteroids might be remnants of five destroyed worlds 557 jeffreyw 06-Jul-18 14:31
PDS 70 Rebuttal and Replacement Paper 556 jeffreyw 09-Jul-18 16:54
Pregeologic Time or Pregeology in Stellar Metamorphosis 569 jeffreyw 17-Jul-18 20:37
Re: Pregeologic Time or Pregeology in Stellar Metamorphosis 566 D-Archer 18-Jul-18 09:02
Re: Pregeologic Time or Pregeology in Stellar Metamorphosis 575 jeffreyw 19-Jul-18 02:35
Convection Principle of Life Formation 576 jeffreyw 24-Jul-18 12:11
Star System Polymorphism 555 jeffreyw 25-Jul-18 15:35
Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 566 jeffreyw 31-Jul-18 12:33
Re: Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 539 D-Archer 02-Aug-18 10:04
Re: Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 575 jeffreyw 02-Aug-18 20:39
Re: Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 550 D-Archer 03-Aug-18 10:19
Re: Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 550 jeffreyw 03-Aug-18 12:46
Re: Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 582 D-Archer 03-Aug-18 13:22
Re: Stages of Iron Absorption and Deposition in a Star 541 jeffreyw 03-Aug-18 16:36
Open Correction to James Hutton's Uniformitarianism 563 jeffreyw 02-Aug-18 00:12
Re: Rogue Planet Discovery 20 Light Years from Sun 565 Thunderbird 04-Aug-18 15:02
Re: Rogue Planet Discovery 20 Light Years from Sun 569 jeffreyw 05-Aug-18 00:53
The Polymorphic System HD 10180 on the WT Diagram 534 jeffreyw 05-Aug-18 15:36
Saturn on the WT Diagram (new paper) 541 jeffreyw 05-Aug-18 15:40
Re: Nursery of Life 555 Thunderbird 06-Aug-18 14:59
Re: Nursery of Life 552 jeffreyw 06-Aug-18 19:24
Re: Nursery of Life 566 Thunderbird 06-Aug-18 21:59
The WASP 12 Polymorphic System (New paper) 579 jeffreyw 07-Aug-18 17:13
Phase Curves (new paper) 563 jeffreyw 28-Aug-18 16:35
Re: Phase Curves (new paper) 590 ianw16 28-Aug-18 17:31
Stars can become water worlds (new paper) 573 jeffreyw 29-Aug-18 08:19
Re: Stars can become water worlds (new paper) 586 ianw16 29-Aug-18 13:27
Iron Core Deposition Rate 572 jeffreyw 29-Aug-18 15:47
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 587 ianw16 29-Aug-18 15:56
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 555 jeffreyw 29-Aug-18 16:04
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 573 ianw16 29-Aug-18 16:22
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 573 jeffreyw 29-Aug-18 16:53
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 575 ianw16 29-Aug-18 17:30
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 754 jeffreyw 29-Aug-18 19:10
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 560 ianw16 30-Aug-18 01:33
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 571 jeffreyw 30-Aug-18 13:17
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 564 ianw16 30-Aug-18 13:22
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 563 jeffreyw 30-Aug-18 22:34
Re: Iron Core Deposition Rate 568 ianw16 30-Aug-18 23:41
Star Count Biases Expanded with Stellar Metamorphosis 511 jeffreyw 31-Aug-18 14:37
Re: Star Count Biases Expanded with Stellar Metamorphosis 542 ianw16 31-Aug-18 16:36
6.4 Trillion water/ocean worlds 541 jeffreyw 02-Sep-18 13:45
Re: 6.4 Trillion water/ocean worlds 541 D-Archer 03-Sep-18 07:54
Re: 6.4 Trillion water/ocean worlds 531 jeffreyw 03-Sep-18 14:51
Re: 6.4 Trillion water/ocean worlds 513 ianw16 03-Sep-18 23:43
The RNA World Hypothesis is Not Needed 550 jeffreyw 04-Sep-18 08:03
Re: The RNA World Hypothesis is Not Needed 535 ianw16 04-Sep-18 14:37
The Evolution of Star Habitable Zones 537 D-Archer 20-Sep-18 07:03
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 536 Lost_In_Place 20-Sep-18 10:49
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 540 D-Archer 20-Sep-18 13:25
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 537 jeffreyw 23-Sep-18 00:02
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 539 Lost_In_Place 25-Sep-18 17:34
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 494 jeffreyw 17-Oct-18 13:09
The Stellar Disintegration Zone, New Paper 533 jeffreyw 01-Oct-18 15:46
Kepler 406 System 518 jeffreyw 08-Oct-18 13:24
972 Stars in Different Stages of Metamorphosis 523 jeffreyw 08-Oct-18 13:28
Dinosaurs in 3 to 5 Atmospheric Pressure 499 jeffreyw 16-Oct-18 17:21
Atmospheric Pressure at the Time of Dinosaurs Octave Levenspiel 496 D-Archer 21-Oct-18 09:48
Re: Atmospheric Pressure at the Time of Dinosaurs Octave Levenspiel 523 jeffreyw 22-Oct-18 13:28
Re: Atmospheric Pressure at the Time of Dinosaurs Octave Levenspiel 500 D-Archer 23-Oct-18 13:17
Re: Atmospheric Pressure at the Time of Dinosaurs Octave Levenspiel 519 jeffreyw 23-Oct-18 17:40
The Polymorphic System HD 87646 496 jeffreyw 29-Oct-18 19:38
Star Densities During Metamorphosis 498 jeffreyw 29-Oct-18 19:47
Re: The Polymorphic System HD 87646 494 D-Archer 02-Nov-18 13:54
Re: The Polymorphic System HD 87646 514 jeffreyw 02-Nov-18 18:18
Where Did the Earth's Helium Come From? 539 jeffreyw 29-Oct-18 19:59
Stars and brown dwarfs belong together 477 D-Archer 02-Nov-18 13:48
Re: Stars and brown dwarfs belong together 518 jeffreyw 02-Nov-18 19:29
The Charge Engine of Stellar Evolution 494 D-Archer 11-Nov-18 13:28
Elemental Mass Equilibrium 476 jeffreyw 14-Nov-18 18:18
Sea to Land Animal Transformation 471 jeffreyw 14-Nov-18 18:28
Re: Sea to Land Animal Transformation 485 D-Archer 15-Nov-18 12:25
Re: Sea to Land Animal Transformation 494 jeffreyw 15-Nov-18 14:09
Re: Sea to Land Animal Transformation 501 D-Archer 16-Nov-18 12:38
Crustal vs. Total Diameters During Ocean world transition 465 jeffreyw 26-Nov-18 18:41
Re: Crustal vs. Total Diameters During Ocean world transition 494 D-Archer 27-Nov-18 16:22
Re: Crustal vs. Total Diameters During Ocean world transition 459 jeffreyw 03-Dec-18 19:52
Experts vs Prepared Minds 507 jeffreyw 03-Dec-18 15:19
Destroying and Recycling Dead Stars (with stars) 478 jeffreyw 03-Dec-18 20:07
SM vs Columbia University and Forbes Magazine 489 jeffreyw 18-Dec-18 15:16
Re: SM vs Columbia University and Forbes Magazine 483 D-Archer 19-Dec-18 15:09
Re: SM vs Columbia University and Forbes Magazine 442 D-Archer 28-Dec-18 14:16
Re: SM vs Columbia University and Forbes Magazine 465 jeffreyw 15-Jan-19 20:51
Re: SM vs Columbia University and Forbes Magazine 492 D-Archer 17-Jan-19 19:48
Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 454 jeffreyw 21-Dec-18 15:01
Re: Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 472 D-Archer 21-Dec-18 20:52
Re: Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 471 jeffreyw 21-Dec-18 21:33
Re: Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 446 D-Archer 22-Dec-18 09:59
Re: Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 443 jeffreyw 24-Dec-18 14:19
Re: Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 435 D-Archer 28-Dec-18 14:26
Re: Neptunes transformed into super Earths... 456 jeffreyw 03-Jan-19 18:02
Grey Dwarfs 451 jeffreyw 15-Jan-19 20:26
Re: Grey Dwarfs 422 D-Archer 17-Jan-19 19:33
Thousands Of Stars Turning Into Crystals 449 D-Archer 21-Jan-19 13:03
Re: Thousands Of Stars Turning Into Crystals 443 jeffreyw 21-Jan-19 19:03
Re: Thousands Of Stars Turning Into Crystals 439 D-Archer 22-Jan-19 11:14
Re: Thousands Of Stars Turning Into Crystals - comment paper 439 D-Archer 22-Jan-19 20:06
Re: Thousands Of Stars Turning Into Crystals - comment paper 433 jeffreyw 23-Jan-19 14:05
Re: Thousands Of Stars Turning Into Crystals - comment paper 439 ianw16 25-Jan-19 22:30
Stellar Metamorphosis: The Location of Subdwarf B and O Stars on the Wolynski-Taylor Diagram 424 jeffreyw 28-Jan-19 16:02
Most Mass-Dependent Isotope Fractionation is Due to Stellar Evolution (Planet Formation) 431 jeffreyw 31-Jan-19 15:36
Classification of astrons within 20 light years 436 D-Archer 04-Feb-19 08:13
Re: Classification of astrons within 20 light years 421 jeffreyw 04-Feb-19 15:17
Re: Classification of astrons within 20 light years 406 D-Archer 05-Feb-19 09:51
Re: Classification of astrons within 20 light years 417 jeffreyw 05-Feb-19 14:45
Nitrogen Dioxide to Dinitrogen tetroxide loop on Jupiter 395 jeffreyw 11-Feb-19 15:10
Flat Earth vs. Nebular Hypothesis vs. Stellar Metamorphosis 391 jeffreyw 18-Feb-19 16:10
Re: Flat Earth vs. Nebular Hypothesis vs. Stellar Metamorphosis 420 D-Archer 20-Feb-19 11:00
Re: Flat Earth vs. Nebular Hypothesis vs. Stellar Metamorphosis 410 jeffreyw 20-Feb-19 22:39
The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 411 jeffreyw 18-Feb-19 16:48
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 412 D-Archer 20-Feb-19 14:09
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 417 jeffreyw 20-Feb-19 22:44
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 422 D-Archer 21-Feb-19 16:17
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 410 jeffreyw 21-Feb-19 17:33
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 405 D-Archer 22-Feb-19 10:01
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 419 ianw16 25-Feb-19 21:32
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 433 jeffreyw 26-Feb-19 23:08
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 401 D-Archer 27-Feb-19 16:34
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 381 jeffreyw 28-Feb-19 21:43
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 415 ianw16 28-Feb-19 21:51
Re: The Astrochemical Principle of Planet Formation 422 ianw16 25-Feb-19 21:22
Counter-deception in Astronomy 377 jeffreyw 10-Mar-19 14:48
Re: Counter-deception in Astronomy 403 ianw16 10-Mar-19 15:05
Re: Counter-deception in Astronomy 403 D-Archer 11-Mar-19 15:37
Re: Counter-deception in Astronomy 384 jeffreyw 11-Mar-19 15:57
Re: Counter-deception in Astronomy 403 ianw16 11-Mar-19 21:17
Re: Counter-deception in Astronomy 389 ianw16 11-Mar-19 21:15
Iron Nickel Cores of Ancient Stars as Leftover Catalysts 413 jeffreyw 21-Mar-19 15:49
Re: Iron Nickel Cores of Ancient Stars as Leftover Catalysts 373 ianw16 22-Mar-19 18:30
Heuer's "Review of Biases and Their Implications for Deception" 370 jeffreyw 25-Mar-19 13:39
Re: Heuer's "Review of Biases and Their Implications for Deception" 382 ianw16 25-Mar-19 17:35
Locard's Exchange Principle and Stellar Metamorphosis 367 jeffreyw 25-Mar-19 13:49
Re: Locard's Exchange Principle and Stellar Metamorphosis 372 ianw16 25-Mar-19 17:36
A Few Thoughts on the Modus Operandi of Astronomers and Physicists 382 jeffreyw 25-Mar-19 13:54
Re: A Few Thoughts on the Modus Operandi of Astronomers and Physicists 372 ianw16 25-Mar-19 17:38
Mod Note > Topic Moved 442 Dr. Troglodyte 25-Mar-19 21:37
Re: Mod Note > Topic Moved 369 ianw16 25-Mar-19 22:02
Re: Mod Note > Topic Moved 393 jeffreyw 26-Mar-19 17:37
Re: Mod Note > Topic Moved 378 D-Archer 03-Apr-19 08:48
Re: Mod Note > Topic Moved 359 jeffreyw 03-Apr-19 19:34
Lowering Abundances During Stellar Metamorphosis: Three Types of Elemental and Isotopic Decay 367 jeffreyw 01-Apr-19 12:58
COMPLAINT 359 D-Archer 03-Apr-19 08:44
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 377 jamesglory 04-Apr-19 08:18
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 365 D-Archer 04-Apr-19 08:29
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 365 jeffreyw 04-Apr-19 13:33
What are White Dwarf Stars? - new paper 350 D-Archer 04-Apr-19 20:02
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 379 D-Archer 04-Apr-19 20:10
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 373 jeffreyw 05-Apr-19 14:05
Stellar Metamorphosis: Where are the Stars Earth Orbited in the Past? 354 jeffreyw 08-Apr-19 13:48
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Where are the Stars Earth Orbited in the Past? 348 D-Archer 09-Apr-19 10:19
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Where are the Stars Earth Orbited in the Past? 352 jeffreyw 09-Apr-19 13:34
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Where are the Stars Earth Orbited in the Past? 362 D-Archer 10-Apr-19 14:08
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Where are the Stars Earth Orbited in the Past? 352 jeffreyw 11-Apr-19 16:54
Re: Stellar Metamorphosis: Where are the Stars Earth Orbited in the Past? 519 D-Archer 12-Apr-19 12:04
Some thoughts on white dwarfs 379 jeffreyw 09-Apr-19 17:15
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis EHT Victory For REAL Science. & astronomy 371 jamesglory 10-Apr-19 13:51
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis EHT Victory For REAL Science. & astronomy 360 D-Archer 10-Apr-19 14:10
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis EHT Victory For REAL Science. & astronomy 376 jamesglory 24-Apr-19 00:05
An Alternative for the Giant-Impact Hypothesis for Moon Formation 352 jeffreyw 11-Apr-19 17:19
Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 342 jeffreyw 22-Apr-19 13:56
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 399 D-Archer 23-Apr-19 14:21
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 356 jeffreyw 23-Apr-19 17:13
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 342 D-Archer 23-Apr-19 17:40
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 337 jeffreyw 23-Apr-19 20:14
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 379 jamesglory 24-Apr-19 00:03
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 343 D-Archer 24-Apr-19 15:46
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 337 ianw16 24-Apr-19 15:47
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 352 D-Archer 24-Apr-19 15:59
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 354 ianw16 24-Apr-19 16:01
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 357 ianw16 24-Apr-19 16:57
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 342 jeffreyw 24-Apr-19 16:02
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 332 ianw16 24-Apr-19 15:46
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 354 D-Archer 24-Apr-19 16:01
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 355 ianw16 24-Apr-19 16:03
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 350 D-Archer 25-Apr-19 08:55
Re: Why Volatile Compounds are Mostly Missing from Inner Planets 357 ianw16 25-Apr-19 12:00
The General Theory (New video) 368 jeffreyw 26-Apr-19 15:08
Re: The General Theory (New video) 347 ianw16 26-Apr-19 18:40
Re: The General Theory (New video) 335 D-Archer 27-Apr-19 10:06
Re: The General Theory (New video) 370 ianw16 27-Apr-19 11:56
Re: The General Theory (New video) 368 jeffreyw 29-Apr-19 17:43
Re: The General Theory (New video) 366 ianw16 30-Apr-19 10:47
Oxygen (new paper) 342 jeffreyw 29-Apr-19 15:28
Re: Oxygen (new paper) 357 ianw16 30-Apr-19 10:48
Re: Oxygen (new paper) 337 D-Archer 03-May-19 10:21
Re: Oxygen (new paper) 363 jeffreyw 03-May-19 13:36
Re: Oxygen (new paper) 365 jamesglory 03-May-19 22:42
Re: Oxygen (new paper) 102 jeffreyw 19-Jun-20 14:24
Correction of Radiometric Dating Assumptions 364 jeffreyw 06-May-19 14:00
Re: Correction of Radiometric Dating Assumptions 344 D-Archer 12-May-19 10:02
Re: Correction of Radiometric Dating Assumptions 333 jeffreyw 13-May-19 18:22
Stellar metamorphosis: Carbon 334 jeffreyw 13-May-19 18:23
Interpreting the Deuterium/Hydrogen Ratios on Celestial Bodies 350 jeffreyw 06-May-19 18:52
Re: Interpreting the Deuterium/Hydrogen Ratios on Celestial Bodies 340 D-Archer 12-May-19 10:14
Re: Interpreting the Deuterium/Hydrogen Ratios on Celestial Bodies 340 jeffreyw 13-May-19 18:20
Aluminum 356 jeffreyw 13-May-19 18:49
Flipping the pH scale for the WT Diagram 319 jeffreyw 17-May-19 16:11
Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 338 jeffreyw 17-May-19 16:19
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 321 ianw16 20-May-19 11:10
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 355 D-Archer 20-May-19 15:17
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 342 jeffreyw 20-May-19 16:28
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 330 jeffreyw 20-May-19 17:38
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 334 ianw16 20-May-19 18:22
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 342 ianw16 20-May-19 18:13
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 331 D-Archer 20-May-19 19:13
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 329 ianw16 20-May-19 20:10
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 333 D-Archer 21-May-19 10:31
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 325 jeffreyw 23-May-19 14:46
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 325 ianw16 25-May-19 15:33
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 337 ianw16 25-May-19 15:27
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 324 D-Archer 27-May-19 18:53
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 325 ianw16 28-May-19 16:50
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 327 D-Archer 29-May-19 15:25
Re: Venus's D/H Ratio and Consequences 324 jeffreyw 20-May-19 19:50
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 325 Enigcom 20-May-19 04:50
The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 333 jeffreyw 20-May-19 15:15
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 322 ianw16 20-May-19 18:23
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 322 ianw16 20-May-19 18:43
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 76 jeffreyw 05-Aug-20 14:07
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 339 ianw16 20-May-19 20:18
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 81 jeffreyw 05-Aug-20 13:22
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 331 ianw16 20-May-19 20:25
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 336 ianw16 20-May-19 20:39
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 332 D-Archer 21-May-19 10:14
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 343 ianw16 21-May-19 10:35
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 321 D-Archer 21-May-19 19:17
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 339 jeffreyw 22-May-19 18:22
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 333 ianw16 23-May-19 09:38
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 80 jeffreyw 29-Jul-20 12:54
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 322 ianw16 23-May-19 09:37
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 326 D-Archer 24-May-19 15:05
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 322 ianw16 25-May-19 15:31
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 339 D-Archer 26-May-19 10:20
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 320 ianw16 28-May-19 16:51
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 77 jeffreyw 06-Aug-20 13:07
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 326 jeffreyw 22-May-19 17:36
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 342 ianw16 23-May-19 09:35
Re: The Age of Mars Using D/H Ratios 87 jeffreyw 06-Aug-20 13:11
The Sun 353 jeffreyw 21-May-19 14:06
Re: The Sun 327 ianw16 21-May-19 16:30
Re: The Sun 83 jeffreyw 25-Aug-20 13:12
Re: The Sun 327 D-Archer 21-May-19 19:23
Re: The Sun 383 ianw16 21-May-19 19:33
Re: The Sun 326 D-Archer 22-May-19 10:24
Re: The Sun 323 jeffreyw 22-May-19 14:43
Re: The Sun 319 ianw16 22-May-19 17:09
Re: The Sun 339 D-Archer 24-May-19 15:12
Re: The Sun 317 ianw16 25-May-19 15:25
Re: The Sun 343 D-Archer 27-May-19 18:51
Re: The Sun 345 ianw16 27-May-19 21:27
Re: The Sun 320 D-Archer 28-May-19 12:24
Re: The Sun 321 jeffreyw 28-May-19 13:39
Re: The Sun 322 D-Archer 29-May-19 14:34
Re: The Sun 318 ianw16 04-Jun-19 14:14
Re: The Sun 82 jeffreyw 29-Jul-20 17:05
Re: The Sun 341 ianw16 28-May-19 16:47
Re: The Sun 327 D-Archer 29-May-19 15:24
Re: The Sun 326 jeffreyw 29-May-19 19:39
Re: The Sun 334 ianw16 31-May-19 20:29
Re: The Sun 109 jeffreyw 16-Jun-20 15:13
Re: The Sun 111 jeffreyw 16-Jun-20 15:15
Re: The Sun 327 ianw16 31-May-19 20:28
Re: The Sun 89 jeffreyw 30-Jul-20 14:09
Re: The Sun 326 ianw16 22-May-19 17:07
Re: The Sun 108 jeffreyw 16-Jun-20 15:11
Re: The Sun 331 jeffreyw 22-May-19 14:27
Re: The Sun 334 ianw16 22-May-19 17:11
Re: The Sun 104 jeffreyw 16-Jun-20 15:09
The Ages of Uranus and Neptune by D/H ratios 334 jeffreyw 23-May-19 13:49
Re: The Ages of Uranus and Neptune by D/H ratios 327 ianw16 23-May-19 15:34
Re: The Ages of Uranus and Neptune by D/H ratios 78 jeffreyw 30-Jul-20 14:04
Re: The Ages of Uranus and Neptune by D/H ratios 339 D-Archer 24-May-19 15:14
Re: The Ages of Uranus and Neptune by D/H ratios 327 jeffreyw 24-May-19 19:08
The Ages of Jupiter and Saturn by D/H ratios 323 jeffreyw 24-May-19 13:38
Re: The Ages of Jupiter and Saturn by D/H ratios 343 ianw16 24-May-19 15:48
Re: The Ages of Jupiter and Saturn by D/H ratios 108 jeffreyw 16-Jun-20 15:06
Using D/H ratio to determine the ages of hydrous rocks and hydrocarbons 347 jeffreyw 25-May-19 23:27
Re: Using D/H ratio to determine the ages of hydrous rocks and hydrocarbons 338 ianw16 26-May-19 12:14
Re: Using D/H ratio to determine the ages of hydrous rocks and hydrocarbons 108 jeffreyw 19-Jun-20 14:26
Transformation Curves and What they mean 342 jeffreyw 27-May-19 18:08
Carbonaceous Meteorite Fingerprints Using D/H Ratios 347 jeffreyw 28-May-19 17:28
Pigeonholing Paper 318 jeffreyw 03-Jun-19 15:18
Re: Pigeonholing Paper 318 ianw16 03-Jun-19 18:31
Re: Pigeonholing Paper 108 jeffreyw 26-Jun-20 15:43
Re: Pigeonholing Paper 119 Susan Doris 27-Jun-20 05:54
Re: Pigeonholing Paper 117 jeffreyw 30-Jun-20 18:25
A Pongola-Like Glaciation on Uranus 321 jeffreyw 04-Jun-19 13:10
Re: A Pongola-Like Glaciation on Uranus 314 ianw16 04-Jun-19 14:14
Re: A Pongola-Like Glaciation on Uranus 329 jeffreyw 05-Jun-19 19:03
Re: A Pongola-Like Glaciation on Uranus 327 ianw16 08-Jun-19 20:00
Re: A Pongola-Like Glaciation on Uranus 111 jeffreyw 18-Jun-20 14:02
Stellar shrapnel exclusion zones on the WT Diagram 344 jeffreyw 10-Jun-19 13:58
Mercury is ~32.75 trillion years old 312 jeffreyw 01-Aug-19 14:33
Re: Mercury is ~32.75 trillion years old 281 D-Archer 06-Aug-19 11:28
Re: Mercury is ~32.75 trillion years old 305 jeffreyw 06-Aug-19 14:55
Numbers Added to Volume Principle of Life Formation 289 jeffreyw 28-Aug-19 13:57
Why Do Planets Spin at Different Energies? 366 jeffreyw 09-Sep-19 14:39
Gottfried Leibniz and Stellar Metamorphosis 162 D-Archer 17-Apr-20 08:55
Re: Gottfried Leibniz and Stellar Metamorphosis 114 jeffreyw 16-Jun-20 15:03
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 167 Kaaron 18-Apr-20 20:52
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 178 D-Archer 19-Apr-20 11:01
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 115 jeffreyw 03-Jun-20 14:55
Time 152 jeffreyw 22-May-20 16:49
Could life thrive on hydrogen-rich alien worlds? 146 D-Archer 09-May-20 08:12
Spinning Stars and Life 109 jeffreyw 07-Jul-20 18:29
What Dinosaurs Tell Us About Pre-Earth Astrons (New Daniel Archer Paper) 110 jeffreyw 14-Jul-20 14:16
Cluster Age, Star Age, Star System Ages 85 jeffreyw 12-Aug-20 16:29
Re: The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis 73 jeffreyw 15-Sep-20 14:49
New Video on Solar System Objects 75 jeffreyw 02-Nov-20 20:10


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.