Science & Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For all that is Scientifically related to Cosmology and Space. (NB: Please take discussions about UFOs, possible Alien contact, Crop-Circles, Alien Abductions, Planet-X and Niburu to the ‘Paranormal and Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
cloister Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Here you are Ian, from Hans Jorg Farh. All he
> wants is for someone to prove him wrong. Off you
> go....
>
>
> [nautil.us]
> e-big-bang-theory-all-wrong


He has been. He relies on tired light woo, among other things, which is totally ruled out.

Quote

This is seen in the paper by Fahr and Zönnchen (2009). These authors critically review
major results of the CMB astrophysics and propose retreating to what is essentially the QSS
framework. They recycle an old argument of Rees (1978) on the dimension analysis of the
baryon-to-photon ratio, this time without proper emphasis on the fact that fusion/accretion
must proceed at the Eddington limit to provide the necessary CMB energy. Ironically but
fittingly for this rear-guard action, they find that even the entirely hypothetical metallic
whiskers are not enough for thermalization to satisfy modern observational constraints - so
they invoke the ancient tired-light yarn (photons losing energy as they interact with the matter
while travelling through the static universe) as part of the explanation.

ALTERNATIVE EXPLANATIONS OF THE COSMIC MICROWAVE BACKGROUND: A HISTORICAL AND AN EPISTEMOLOGICAL PERSPECTIVE
Ćirković, M. M. & Perović, S.
[arxiv.org]


(QSS is quasi-steady state. Again, ruled out at a very high confidence level. If light is 'tired', how did the EM signature from the neutron star merger in 2017, get here at the same time as the gravitational wave? It is nonsense, and long since ignored. A retreat of ageing Hoyle acolytes. Anything that relies on 'tired light' isn't worth wasting time on.)

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 2564 jamesglory 22-May-19 22:04
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 276 D-Archer 23-May-19 12:34
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 290 ianw16 23-May-19 15:41
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 285 D-Archer 24-May-19 12:27
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 266 ianw16 24-May-19 16:27
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 283 D-Archer 24-May-19 18:39
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 283 ianw16 25-May-19 02:30
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 303 D-Archer 25-May-19 09:33
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 273 ianw16 26-May-19 12:00
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 284 D-Archer 27-May-19 13:58
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 321 jamesglory 27-May-19 14:18
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 264 D-Archer 27-May-19 18:49
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 281 ianw16 27-May-19 19:44
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 296 ianw16 27-May-19 19:50
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 263 D-Archer 28-May-19 12:19
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 280 ianw16 28-May-19 16:44
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 291 cloister 29-May-19 07:44
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 257 D-Archer 29-May-19 15:11
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 287 Eddie Larry 29-May-19 22:55
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 303 cloister 30-May-19 04:36
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 280 Eddie Larry 30-May-19 13:33
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 273 cloister 31-May-19 07:39
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 287 ianw16 31-May-19 01:28
For the hard of reading; 273 ianw16 31-May-19 01:42
Re: For the hard of reading; 269 D-Archer 31-May-19 15:17
Re: For the hard of reading; 267 ianw16 31-May-19 20:25
Re: For the hard of reading; 255 D-Archer 01-Jun-19 10:58
Re: For the hard of reading; 287 ianw16 01-Jun-19 20:46
Re: For the hard of reading; 283 D-Archer 02-Jun-19 08:37
Re: For the hard of reading; 277 cloister 02-Jun-19 09:50
Re: For the hard of reading; 284 Eddie Larry 02-Jun-19 13:41
Re: For the hard of reading; 254 cloister 02-Jun-19 18:47
Re: For the hard of reading; 257 D-Archer 03-Jun-19 10:28
Re: For the hard of reading; 271 ianw16 03-Jun-19 16:11
Re: For the hard of reading; 291 ianw16 03-Jun-19 16:09
Re: For the hard of reading; 248 D-Archer 03-Jun-19 19:48
Re: For the hard of reading; 260 ianw16 03-Jun-19 21:20
Re: For the hard of reading; 253 Susan Doris 22-Jun-19 16:37
Re: For the hard of reading; 250 cloister 22-Jun-19 17:32
Re: For the hard of reading; 248 Susan Doris 22-Jun-19 16:31
Re: For the hard of reading; 235 D-Archer 23-Jun-19 12:16
Re: For the hard of reading; 240 ianw16 23-Jun-19 14:53
Re: For the hard of reading; 264 D-Archer 24-Jun-19 09:19
Re: For the hard of reading; 246 ianw16 24-Jun-19 13:39
Re: For the hard of reading; 238 D-Archer 24-Jun-19 18:19
Re: For the hard of reading; 266 ianw16 24-Jun-19 18:32
Re: For the hard of reading; 248 D-Archer 25-Jun-19 11:22
Re: For the hard of reading; 244 ianw16 25-Jun-19 11:41
Re: For the hard of reading; 228 D-Archer 26-Jun-19 11:43
Re: For the hard of reading; 265 ianw16 26-Jun-19 19:16
Re: For the hard of reading; 259 ianw16 03-Jun-19 16:06
Re: For the hard of reading; 251 ianw16 03-Jun-19 16:05
Re: For the hard of reading; 250 D-Archer 03-Jun-19 19:57
Re: For the hard of reading; 254 ianw16 03-Jun-19 21:28
Re: For the hard of reading; 268 D-Archer 04-Jun-19 10:17
Re: For the hard of reading; 262 ianw16 04-Jun-19 11:20
Re: For the hard of reading; 250 D-Archer 04-Jun-19 17:48
Re: For the hard of reading; 269 ianw16 04-Jun-19 18:47
Re: For the hard of reading; 250 D-Archer 04-Jun-19 21:01
Re: For the hard of reading; 245 ianw16 04-Jun-19 21:11
Re: For the hard of reading; 248 D-Archer 05-Jun-19 15:46
Re: For the hard of reading; 247 ianw16 05-Jun-19 16:44
Re: For the hard of reading; 251 D-Archer 05-Jun-19 19:46
Re: For the hard of reading; 253 ianw16 07-Jun-19 16:37
Re: For the hard of reading; 261 D-Archer 09-Jun-19 09:26
Re: For the hard of reading; 256 ianw16 11-Jun-19 20:39
Re: For the hard of reading; 286 cloister 04-Jun-19 10:56
Re: For the hard of reading; 258 ianw16 04-Jun-19 11:19
Re: For the hard of reading; 256 D-Archer 04-Jun-19 17:48
Re: For the hard of reading; 259 ianw16 04-Jun-19 18:19
Re: For the hard of reading; 279 cloister 04-Jun-19 18:22
Re: For the hard of reading; 254 ianw16 04-Jun-19 18:44
Re: For the hard of reading; 280 cloister 04-Jun-19 20:01
Re: For the hard of reading; 269 ianw16 04-Jun-19 20:16
Re: For the hard of reading; 261 cloister 05-Jun-19 07:17
Re: For the hard of reading; 247 ianw16 05-Jun-19 16:48
Re: For the hard of reading; 286 cloister 05-Jun-19 16:56
Re: For the hard of reading; 272 ianw16 07-Jun-19 16:39
Re: For the hard of reading; 263 cloister 07-Jun-19 18:51
Re: For the hard of reading; 263 ianw16 08-Jun-19 19:53
Re: For the hard of reading; 242 cloister 08-Jun-19 21:46
Re: For the hard of reading; 235 ianw16 08-Jun-19 22:06
Re: For the hard of reading; 268 cloister 09-Jun-19 20:00
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 320 jamesglory 10-Jun-19 23:26
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 256 D-Archer 14-Jun-19 13:31
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 284 jamesglory 15-Jun-19 02:01
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 263 D-Archer 15-Jun-19 11:58
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 244 ianw16 16-Jun-19 11:51
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 239 D-Archer 17-Jun-19 18:55
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 245 ianw16 18-Jun-19 00:16
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 259 cloister 18-Jun-19 12:01
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 246 ianw16 18-Jun-19 17:18
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 230 cloister 19-Jun-19 10:29
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 242 ianw16 19-Jun-19 14:02
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 243 cloister 20-Jun-19 07:29
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 248 ianw16 21-Jun-19 10:34
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 238 D-Archer 21-Jun-19 14:41
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 248 ianw16 21-Jun-19 17:24
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 235 D-Archer 21-Jun-19 20:37
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 245 ianw16 21-Jun-19 21:06
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 238 cloister 22-Jun-19 20:38
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 240 ianw16 22-Jun-19 21:56
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 262 cloister 23-Jun-19 07:38
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 232 ianw16 23-Jun-19 14:51
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 248 cloister 23-Jun-19 19:47
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 248 ianw16 24-Jun-19 13:31
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 249 cloister 25-Jun-19 07:43
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 236 ianw16 25-Jun-19 11:38
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 227 cloister 25-Jun-19 12:43
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 219 ianw16 25-Jun-19 17:56
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 252 cloister 25-Jun-19 18:21
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 249 ianw16 25-Jun-19 21:09
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 240 cloister 26-Jun-19 08:16
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 246 ianw16 26-Jun-19 10:56
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 240 cloister 26-Jun-19 14:11
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 269 ianw16 26-Jun-19 18:17
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 250 cloister 28-Jun-19 11:03
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 257 ianw16 28-Jun-19 11:19
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 251 cloister 28-Jun-19 14:23
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 253 ianw16 28-Jun-19 17:02
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 231 cloister 28-Jun-19 21:55
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 256 ianw16 28-Jun-19 22:33
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 258 Eddie Larry 29-Jun-19 00:01
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 249 cloister 29-Jun-19 07:47
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 243 cloister 29-Jun-19 07:32
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 269 ianw16 29-Jun-19 09:34
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 242 cloister 29-Jun-19 09:59
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 252 ianw16 29-Jun-19 10:33
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 261 cloister 30-Jun-19 09:42
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 270 ianw16 02-Jul-19 22:20
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 259 cloister 03-Jul-19 08:14
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 414 ianw16 05-Jul-19 19:56
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 252 D-Archer 25-Jun-19 12:00
Re: MORE NEW PROOF!!!!! 270 ianw16 25-Jun-19 18:09
Re: For the hard of reading; 253 ianw16 11-Jun-19 20:36
Re: For the hard of reading; 248 cloister 12-Jun-19 05:08
Re: For the hard of reading; 265 ianw16 12-Jun-19 14:30
Re: For the hard of reading; 315 jamesglory 13-Jun-19 01:32
Re: For the hard of reading; 270 cloister 13-Jun-19 05:14
Re: For the hard of reading; 254 cloister 15-Jun-19 08:20
Re: For the hard of reading; 253 ianw16 15-Jun-19 11:04
Re: For the hard of reading; 325 jamesglory 16-Jun-19 21:31
Re: For the hard of reading; 257 ianw16 17-Jun-19 23:30
Re: For the hard of reading; 263 Susan Doris 20-Jun-19 14:41
Re: For the hard of reading; 342 cloister 31-May-19 16:48
Re: For the hard of reading; 320 ianw16 31-May-19 20:26
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 276 Me 26-Jun-19 12:51
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 246 D-Archer 27-Jun-19 10:13
Re: PROOF. Brown dwarfs are formed in the same way as sun-like stars.. 285 ianw16 27-Jun-19 15:53


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.