Science & Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For all that is Scientifically related to Cosmology and Space. (NB: Please take discussions about UFOs, possible Alien contact, Crop-Circles, Alien Abductions, Planet-X and Niburu to the ‘Paranormal and Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Thank you.

Too bad the CMB is useless, it is not really cosmic, nor proof of any big bang, but as said that is another discussion, no point in discussing that, waste of time.

I can point a flaw in reasoning, or an assumption that was made , it is here bolded>

Quote

The space between the stars and the galaxies appears to us as void and black, but in reality it is permeated
by a background radiation, an electromagnetic radiation that is not determined by the bodies that surround it
and which is considered the proof of the Big Bang. In this radiation, says Hawking, there are particularities
that confirm the existence of infinite other universes, and that could be identified if we launched a
spaceship equipped with special sensors in space.


Any and all EM is produced by matter, this matter is in our Universe, it is not proof of a big bang, it is only prove of radiation, saying that a big bang caused it is the assumption.

Further, what "particularities"?, how can normal radiation be used to confirm the existence of other universes, how can you see something VERY LARGE in something as small as radiaton, this is not possible.. another reasoning flaw. Only 1 universe is observed, if you observe something novel that is still part of our 1 Universe... that is logic and scientific, to propose something incredulous is not.

Regards,
Daniel Archer
Keeping it real since 1982



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 23-Mar-18 11:37 by D-Archer.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 1162 Eddie Larry 20-Mar-18 01:34
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 305 D-Archer 20-Mar-18 11:28
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 269 Archaic 20-Mar-18 14:02
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 261 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 14:17
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 249 Eddie Larry 21-Mar-18 14:41
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 265 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 16:21
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 257 Eddie Larry 21-Mar-18 20:34
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 247 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:13
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 240 Eddie Larry 22-Mar-18 13:47
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 257 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 14:58
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 249 Eddie Larry 22-Mar-18 16:24
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 240 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 11:13
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 237 Eddie Larry 23-Mar-18 13:51
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 239 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 14:45
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 253 carolb 21-Mar-18 22:03
Mod Note 408 JonnyMcA 20-Mar-18 15:47
Re: Mod Note 254 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 14:12
Re: Mod Note 248 carolb 21-Mar-18 14:56
Re: Mod Note 399 JonnyMcA 22-Mar-18 12:09
Re: Mod Note 244 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:17
Re: Mod Note 384 JonnyMcA 22-Mar-18 13:15
Re: Mod Note 246 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 15:03
Re: Mod Note 426 JonnyMcA 22-Mar-18 15:31
Re: Mod Note 246 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 11:26
Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 301 Vanya 21-Mar-18 15:46
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 258 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 16:31
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 250 drrayeye 22-Mar-18 05:20
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 245 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:18
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 262 Vanya 22-Mar-18 10:35
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 270 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:20
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 266 Vanya 22-Mar-18 13:40
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 256 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 15:13
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 280 Vanya 22-Mar-18 15:48
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 241 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 11:36
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 250 carolb 23-Mar-18 12:21
MODS!!!! 246 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 14:45
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 249 cladking 23-Mar-18 19:20
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 455 Eddie Larry 23-Mar-18 19:41


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.