Global Village :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For good-natured and mutually-respectful discussions of politics and current affairs. Soap-boxing and the promotion of extremist causes motivated by hate will not be tolerated by our moderators. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
To all

Ok, let's try this out. Before this gets too deep into a tit-for-tat debate/argument, in which case nothing will ever be resolved, let's take a step back and try this again. Moderating v. Censoring. Before I get into this let me make sure I understand GH's concerns: Although he wishes for everyone to post their views on GV, he is concerned that some topics such as politics may be causing some posters to denegrate into outright hatred, correct? OK, now comes in his concern for censorship and moderation. Although he wishes egalitarianism on his GVDB he now realizes that some topics might not be suitable because if something aggregious does happen, his name is forever attached to it, regardless if he was directly involved or not. Now comes in the question of moderating. He is probably thinking to himself: "Hmmm, I realize that some topics might not be suitable for a general DB, but some of the threads are down right grotesque in regards to certain topics, should I (A) Remove the GVDB? or (B) Should I set in place certain set of ground rules"? (Because he can make or break his DB).
To the moderators of his DB he goes for recommendations. Removing his GVDB entirely is a quick remedy, but does he want to do it? Most likely not. If he decides to set ground rules in motion, then he is concerned about people running away from posting on his DB, which he really wants to avoid. But alas, he can't have it both ways. This is where it is lonely at the top, you can't please everyone and it is a fact of life. So I am stating that ground rules must be set in motion to avoid the potential disaster of the GVDB becoming a free for all, gloves off discussion board. If it does denegrate into this, then what do you have? I can think of one word: Anarchy on the DB that has the potential of damaging his credibility. This is far worse than upsetting a few people for the sake of setting up ground rules.
The moderators of any discussion board that wishes it to have a decent reputation, especially when they are doing it for a famous or not so famous person, depending on how one looks at it, can be difficult. And it is difficult at times because when a moderator is compelled to remove a posters thread, ban them for a few days or months or worse by having them banned for good, we do not like it. But, it does not stop there for the moderator, we have to endure countless emails that contain threats or ugly remarks. I would like to share with you some of them that I have received, but because I believe in confidentiality, I can't.
Read the rules on the opening page. Rules in and of themselves negates egalitarianism point blank.

I hope this explains it.

Steve

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Final thoughts on Censorship v. Moderation 495 Steve_L 24-Nov-03 01:28
Re: Final thoughts on Censorship v. Moderation 149 Margaret 24-Nov-03 02:23
Re: Final thoughts on Censorship v. Moderation 132 Steve_L 24-Nov-03 04:26
Steve, Steve, Steve, Steve... 140 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 10:23
Re: Steve, Steve, Steve, Steve... 128 RichardC 24-Nov-03 10:44
Re: Steve, Steve, Steve, Steve... 130 Richard Fusniak 24-Nov-03 12:07
Good Bye Global Village 128 Ahatmose 24-Nov-03 12:15
Re: Good Bye Global Village 190 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 12:52
Re: Good Bye Global Village 116 Ahatmose 24-Nov-03 13:08
Re: Good Bye Global Village 79 Brian Patterson 18-Aug-20 03:24
Re: Good Bye Global Village 121 Warwick 18-Aug-20 18:56
Re: Good Bye Global Village 87 Brian Patterson 15-Nov-20 03:40
Re: Good Bye Global Village 94 Warwick 19-Nov-20 18:09
Posting is not compulsory 115 Richard Fusniak 24-Nov-03 13:09
For Your Information ! 119 Thirdwave 24-Nov-03 13:10
thank you 112 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 12:45
one idea 122 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 13:07
Re: one idea 116 Steve_L 24-Nov-03 13:13
Excellent idea 126 Richard Fusniak 24-Nov-03 13:16
Re: Excellent idea 119 Steve_L 24-Nov-03 13:18
Re: Excellent idea 127 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 13:20
Re: Excellent idea 111 Steve_L 24-Nov-03 13:21
Re: Excellent idea 118 Richard Fusniak 24-Nov-03 13:35
off topic 111 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 13:38
Re: Excellent idea 105 Ahatmose 24-Nov-03 15:42
Re: Excellent idea 100 Cleopatra 24-Nov-03 16:14
Re: Steve, Steve, Steve, Steve... 118 Steve_L 24-Nov-03 13:10
Re: Final thoughts on Censorship v. Moderation and Covid 77 PB Bytes 19-Nov-20 15:28
Brack! 89 Deep1 19-Nov-20 17:00


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.