Global Village :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For good-natured and mutually-respectful discussions of politics and current affairs. Soap-boxing and the promotion of extremist causes motivated by hate will not be tolerated by our moderators. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Aine Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Archaic Wrote:
> --------------------------------------------------
> -----
> > No it doesn't.
> >
> > There is no scientific demonstration for the
> > existence of gender. It's a construct, not a
> > reality. It's unfalsifable.
>
>
> You are confusing sex with gender...and sex isn't
> binary. Don't believe me? Look up gene SRY.

In the vast, vast, vast majority of examples, sex is binary. You always look for the rare 1 in a million exception to the rule then say, "see!!!! it applies to everyone!!". No, it doesn't.

> Riddle me this. If gender is a socially
> constructed phenomena , then how can gender
> identity be part of the inherent and inborn sense
> of self of an individual?

It's your sex. The product of chromosomes and hormones. There is no evidence for it being seperate.

You have to be the first regressive on the planet to claim gender isn't a social construct.

> Where does an individual's sense of gender
> identity come from? You must answer this question
> or STFU.

Just did. The whole idea of a "gender identity" is post-modernist and did not exist prior to the 50s.

> You're terrified that if gender isn't a social
> construct, your religious and political ideology
> loses all credibility. Not that is had much to
> begin with.

I don't have religious ideology.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 655 OCaptain 09-Aug-21 16:22
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 103 Nolondil 09-Aug-21 21:48
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 148 Archaic 12-Aug-21 01:06
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 109 Glass Jigsaw 12-Aug-21 21:02
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 112 OCaptain 13-Aug-21 14:42
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 77 Aine 13-Aug-21 15:50
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 87 Glass Jigsaw 14-Aug-21 13:10
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 153 Archaic 14-Aug-21 21:16
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 75 Glass Jigsaw 15-Aug-21 12:09
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 97 Archaic 14-Aug-21 21:11
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 82 eli stills 15-Aug-21 01:48
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 83 Archaic 15-Aug-21 01:59
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 77 eli stills 15-Aug-21 12:10
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 76 Archaic 21-Aug-21 04:00
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 66 eli stills 21-Aug-21 13:51
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 76 Archaic 26-Aug-21 02:36
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 81 eli stills 27-Aug-21 00:54
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 61 Archaic 04-Sep-21 01:28
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 101 eli stills 04-Sep-21 01:32
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 57 Archaic 04-Sep-21 02:40
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 59 eli stills 04-Sep-21 03:16
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 52 Archaic 05-Sep-21 23:20
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 43 eli stills 06-Sep-21 00:24
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 47 Archaic 06-Sep-21 00:30
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 45 eli stills 06-Sep-21 01:01
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 46 Archaic 06-Sep-21 01:03
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 43 eli stills 06-Sep-21 01:11
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 43 Archaic 06-Sep-21 01:38
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 56 OCaptain 04-Sep-21 02:36
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 65 Archaic 04-Sep-21 02:40
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 55 eli stills 04-Sep-21 03:18
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 62 Warwick 04-Sep-21 16:07
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 59 Archaic 05-Sep-21 23:19
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 58 eli stills 06-Sep-21 00:26
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 44 Archaic 06-Sep-21 00:32
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 42 eli stills 06-Sep-21 01:04
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 45 Archaic 06-Sep-21 01:05
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 49 eli stills 06-Sep-21 01:08
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 49 Archaic 06-Sep-21 01:39
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 96 Brian Patterson 10-Aug-21 01:36
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 155 OCaptain 10-Aug-21 18:53
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 110 Brian Patterson 11-Aug-21 04:51
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 154 OCaptain 11-Aug-21 17:20
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 178 Archaic 12-Aug-21 00:45
trans rights are human rights! 104 OCaptain 13-Aug-21 17:19
Re: trans rights are human rights! 102 Archaic 14-Aug-21 21:08
When you're calmly outreasoned, you become enraged! 76 OCaptain 15-Aug-21 20:37
Re: When you're calmly outreasoned, you become enraged! 77 Archaic 21-Aug-21 04:06
Re: When you're calmly outreasoned, you become enraged! 72 OCaptain 21-Aug-21 19:41
Re: When you're calmly outreasoned, you become enraged! 144 Archaic 26-Aug-21 02:44
Re: When you're calmly outreasoned, you become enraged! 79 OCaptain 26-Aug-21 22:04
Triggered!! 69 OCaptain 01-Sep-21 14:19
Re: Triggered!! 58 Archaic 04-Sep-21 01:38
Re: Triggered!! 56 eli stills 04-Sep-21 02:33
Re: Triggered!! 47 Archaic 04-Sep-21 02:47
Re: Triggered!! 57 eli stills 04-Sep-21 03:12
Re: Triggered!! 58 Archaic 05-Sep-21 23:24
Re: Triggered!! 55 OCaptain 04-Sep-21 02:51
Re: Triggered!! 65 Archaic 04-Sep-21 02:53
Re: Triggered!! 63 OCaptain 04-Sep-21 02:56
Re: Triggered!! 51 Archaic 04-Sep-21 02:58
Re: Triggered!! 55 OCaptain 04-Sep-21 03:03
Re: Triggered!! 64 Archaic 04-Sep-21 03:04
Re: Triggered!! 53 OCaptain 04-Sep-21 03:10
Re: Triggered!! 65 Aine 05-Sep-21 17:47
Re: Triggered!! 59 Archaic 05-Sep-21 23:28
Re: Triggered!! 45 OCaptain 06-Sep-21 02:08
Re: Triggered!! 89 Archaic 06-Sep-21 02:22
Re: Let's talk about the facts on trans people and trans rights 117 debraregypt 15-Aug-21 23:38
You wouldn't be trying to start a moral panic, would you? 97 OCaptain 16-Aug-21 00:28


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.