Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
DScribr wrote:


> >
> > > Like us, Vyse and Co. had no way of knowing the age of the
> > iron
> > > pc. (But this doesn't stop some from previously
> speculating,
> > > [incorrectly] a few months ago that Vyse planted the pc.
> > there,
> > > and now are wildly speculating that this pc. was made by
> the
> > > 'VAE' some 1,000's of yrs. prior to the 4th D.)
> > >
> > >
> > >
> > > Their assuming it was a 4th D. made pc. was a mistake.
> >
> > That's gibberish..
> > Vyse stated in his journal that the iron plate could only be
> > contemporary with the structure.. I'm sure you believe that.
> I
> > mean if it was a mistake consisting of about 100 words in a
> > published journal it would hardly constitute a slip of the
> pen
> > would it. And if it is a "Mistake" how many other "mistakes"
> > did he make?
> > Are you bringing into question the integrity of Vyse's
> journal?
> > Implying that he could have made such a gargantuan "mistake"
> >
> > Therefore we must assume that if the GP was built during the
> > 4th dynasty then the builders had iron. I'm sure you can get
> > your head around that.
> >
> > Unfortunately... The archaeological record & Egyptology
> clearly
> > say that the 4th AE did not have iron..
> >
> >
> > >
> >
>
> It's plain English actually.
>
>
> As stated, "Their assuming it was a 4th D. made pc. was a
> mistake." They believed it to be authentic, and wrote it up,
> (and acted) accordingly, (see catchpenny.org for the
> controversy regarding its authenticity that followed, and
> continues.) It's an old argument, and we still can't date the
> pc. so it's all speculations.

I agree with you, they believed that it was authentic because say they discovered it behind two whole layers of core blocks. They wrote it up accordingly.
>
> This possibility still exists: "The iron pc. could've been
> dropped by a 16th Century worker removing casing stones.")

Vyse wrote that it was impossible for that to have occurred. I guess that was another "mistake".. He wasn't having a good day was he..
>
>
> The AE certainly could've built the Pyramids without iron in
> the 4th Dynasty, regardless of your attempts to spin it
> otherwise here.

Don't know what you are talking about. What's that got to do with the circumstances surrounding the discovery of an iron plate?
>
>
> 'We' are welcome to assume whatever, and ignore whatever parts
> you care to, (see above)....I'll stick to the facts, thanks
> anyway.

And you are "welcome to" also...
>
>
> (We already had this circular 'discussion' some months
> ago....you may recall there were those who claimed loudly that
> Vyse planted that pc.

That remains a possibility.
>



x

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Early Dynastic Technology. 525 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 09:19
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 303 Scott Creighton 02-Apr-15 09:38
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 547 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 09:49
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 261 charly 02-Apr-15 12:14
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 264 Origyptian 02-Apr-15 15:35
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 157 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 15:41
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 289 Skatha 04-Apr-15 15:36
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 245 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 15:44
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 291 Archae Solenhofen 04-Apr-15 16:30
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 262 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 16:48
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 304 Archae Solenhofen 04-Apr-15 17:11
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 263 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 17:18
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 204 Archae Solenhofen 04-Apr-15 17:40
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 262 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 18:03
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 222 Archae Solenhofen 04-Apr-15 18:37
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 250 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 19:12
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 296 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 15:58
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 256 OCaptain 04-Apr-15 19:30
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 211 Archae Solenhofen 04-Apr-15 21:14
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 274 cladking 02-Apr-15 15:39
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 256 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 15:45
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 284 cladking 02-Apr-15 16:12
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 252 Thanos5150 04-Apr-15 18:10
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 297 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 18:13
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 291 Thanos5150 04-Apr-15 19:11
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 299 cladking 04-Apr-15 19:11
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 271 Thanos5150 04-Apr-15 20:58
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 273 cladking 02-Apr-15 16:10
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 276 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 16:24
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 338 Origyptian 02-Apr-15 21:41
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 248 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 21:54
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 280 Origyptian 02-Apr-15 22:24
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 285 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 22:54
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 281 DScribr 04-Apr-15 19:49
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 298 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 19:58
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 244 DScribr 05-Apr-15 00:32
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 283 Jon Ellison 05-Apr-15 00:40
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 286 DScribr 05-Apr-15 16:55
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 289 Jon Ellison 05-Apr-15 17:18
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 271 DScribr 05-Apr-15 19:04
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 298 Jon Ellison 05-Apr-15 19:42
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 260 DScribr 06-Apr-15 06:07
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 316 MJT 05-Apr-15 20:04
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 283 Jon Ellison 05-Apr-15 21:05
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 311 DScribr 06-Apr-15 06:19
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 348 Jon Ellison 06-Apr-15 09:27
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 243 DScribr 06-Apr-15 06:02
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 285 Martin Stower 08-Apr-15 20:30
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 246 MJT 08-Apr-15 21:32
Re: Early Dynastic Technology can stand up to the speculators. 274 Martin Stower 08-Apr-15 23:40
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 231 Origyptian 05-Apr-15 06:06
Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids 299 DScribr 05-Apr-15 17:03
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids 277 Origyptian 06-Apr-15 04:57
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids....'growing evidence' 282 DScribr 06-Apr-15 06:32
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids....'growing evidence' 250 Origyptian 06-Apr-15 14:29
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids....'growing evidence' 325 Jon Ellison 06-Apr-15 14:38
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids....'growing evidence' 298 Origyptian 06-Apr-15 16:43
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids....'growing evidence' 299 Jon Ellison 06-Apr-15 16:51
Re: Early Dynastic Technology Built Pyramids....'growing evidence' 245 DScribr 06-Apr-15 14:55
Denial of the evidence... 264 Ratcho 06-Apr-15 15:31
Re: Denial of the evidence... 290 Jon Ellison 06-Apr-15 15:47
Sinister... 315 Ratcho 06-Apr-15 18:11
Re: Sinister... 268 Origyptian 06-Apr-15 18:20
Re: Sinister... 305 MJT 06-Apr-15 18:55
Re: Sinister... 259 Ratcho 06-Apr-15 19:49
Re: Sinister... 222 MJT 06-Apr-15 23:01
Re: Sinister... 309 Ratcho 07-Apr-15 00:13
Re: Sinister... 238 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 08:25
Re: Sinister... 269 MJT 07-Apr-15 11:26
Re: Sinister... 257 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 11:48
The lack of perfection... 295 Ratcho 08-Apr-15 07:28
Re: The lack of perfection... 278 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 10:26
Re: The lack of perfection... 294 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 12:13
Re: The lack of perfection... 265 MJT 08-Apr-15 14:19
Re: The lack of perfection... 204 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 14:24
Re: The lack of perfection... 235 Corpuscles 08-Apr-15 16:46
Re: The lack of perfection... 228 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 17:00
Not contributing to discussion 341 randompHactor 08-Apr-15 17:44
Re: Not contributing to discussion 208 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 17:45
Re: Not contributing to discussion 263 MJT 08-Apr-15 18:52
Re: Not contributing to discussion 274 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 19:13
Re: Not contributing to discussion 244 MJT 08-Apr-15 19:53
Re: Not contributing to discussion 261 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 20:07
Re: Not contributing to discussion 274 MJT 08-Apr-15 20:50
Re: Not contributing to discussion 263 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 20:52
Re: Not contributing to discussion 303 MJT 08-Apr-15 21:05
Re: Not contributing to discussion 279 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 21:12
Re: Not contributing to discussion 311 MJT 08-Apr-15 21:47
Re: Not contributing to discussion 249 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 23:25
Re: Not contributing to discussion 269 Jon Ellison 09-Apr-15 02:05
Re: The lack of perfection... 312 Corpuscles 08-Apr-15 17:46
Re: The lack of perfection... 277 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 18:09
Re: Sinister... 285 Frank D 07-Apr-15 10:43
Re: Sinister... 322 Ratcho 07-Apr-15 15:22
Re: Sinister... 226 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 16:31
Re: Sinister... 235 Origyptian 07-Apr-15 16:37
Re: Sinister... 353 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 17:14
Re: Sinister... 267 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 17:56
Re: Sinister... 278 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 18:21
Re: Sinister... 319 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 18:36
Re: Sinister... 322 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 19:01
Re: Sinister... 262 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 19:10
Re: Sinister... 281 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 19:42
Re: Sinister... 270 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 19:54
Re: Sinister... 304 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 20:22
Re: Sinister... 320 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 20:32
Re: Sinister... 256 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 20:46
Re: Sinister... 230 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 21:01
Re: Sinister... 323 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 21:31
Re: Sinister... 276 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 22:17
Re: Sinister... 204 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 22:57
Re: Sinister... 249 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 23:03
Re: Sinister... 231 Archae Solenhofen 08-Apr-15 00:43
Re: Sinister... 246 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 20:12
Re: Sinister... 235 Corpuscles 07-Apr-15 20:41
Re: Sinister... 249 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 18:26
Re: Sinister... 258 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 18:50
Re: Sinister... 271 Origyptian 07-Apr-15 23:23
Re: Sinister... 244 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 23:27
Re: Sinister... 223 Origyptian 07-Apr-15 23:38
Re: Sinister... 224 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 23:48
Re: Sinister... 182 MJT 08-Apr-15 11:43
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 271 MJT 04-Apr-15 20:43
Firemaking and associate technology 243 Skatha 02-Apr-15 16:22
Re: Firemaking and associate technology 303 Jon Ellison 02-Apr-15 16:27
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 233 OCaptain 04-Apr-15 18:52
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 213 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 19:08
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 249 Jon Ellison 04-Apr-15 19:36
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 268 Origyptian 05-Apr-15 05:57
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 229 drew 05-Apr-15 08:31
What to make of this...? 240 Ratcho 06-Apr-15 18:42
Re: again priceless!!! 285 charly 06-Apr-15 21:29
Debunking 247 Ratcho 07-Apr-15 15:15
Re: Debunking 240 charly 07-Apr-15 19:00
Re: priceless re-evaluation 272 DScribr 07-Apr-15 15:59
Re: priceless re-evaluation 288 charly 07-Apr-15 19:05
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 238 Jon Ellison 07-Apr-15 18:52
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 282 Archae Solenhofen 07-Apr-15 19:11
Re: Early Dynastic Technology.does anyone know of any limestone core drilling? 260 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 00:32
Re: Early Dynastic Technology.does anyone know of any limestone core drilling? 295 Origyptian 08-Apr-15 00:48
Re: Early Dynastic Technology.does anyone know of any limestone core drilling? 321 Jon Ellison 08-Apr-15 07:30
Re: Early Dynastic Technology. 230 Jon Ellison 09-Apr-15 12:44


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.