Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
The matter of Cygnus was discussed at length on this and other messgae boards several years ago.

The Cygnus stars may fit the layout, but there is no context. I know Andy Collins believes there is, but I have looked at the matter in great detail, and the dwn-nwy figure cannot be Cygnus. And even if by a stretch of imagination it was Cygnus, there is still no textual support in the Pyramid Texts, or archaeological support such as the shafts and the position of the Sphinx, and geographical support such as the relative position of the Nile.

But I must not linger on this, as people will say I am biased.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 1456 lukehancock 27-Jul-12 06:28
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 458 Carl Tanner 27-Jul-12 09:15
Ancient Knowledge and Societal Advancements Close Than Anticipated? 446 Chaser 28-Jul-12 00:54
Re: Ancient Knowledge and Societal Advancements Close Than Anticipated? 494 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:02
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 429 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:00
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 422 Carl Tanner 28-Jul-12 13:06
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 390 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:27
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 423 PB Bytes 28-Jul-12 19:52
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 421 D-Archer 27-Jul-12 09:28
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 512 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:23
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 431 D-Archer 30-Jul-12 09:30
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 483 Loki74 27-Jul-12 10:39
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 420 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:27
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 446 richarddullum 30-Jul-12 00:15
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 434 W_C_Sally 31-Jul-12 06:56
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 397 richarddullum 01-Aug-12 01:06
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 451 W_C_Sally 02-Aug-12 11:28
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 402 richarddullum 03-Aug-12 13:16
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 448 W_C_Sally 05-Aug-12 07:29
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 446 eohpyratech 05-Aug-12 07:59
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 437 Carl Tanner 05-Aug-12 08:56
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 448 eohpyratech 05-Aug-12 09:55
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 386 Carl Tanner 05-Aug-12 13:36
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 399 eohpyratech 06-Aug-12 09:17
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 365 Carl Tanner 06-Aug-12 10:32
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 417 eohpyratech 06-Aug-12 11:35
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 408 Carl Tanner 06-Aug-12 11:58
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 510 Carl Tanner 06-Aug-12 12:12
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 433 eohpyratech 06-Aug-12 12:27
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 440 Carl Tanner 06-Aug-12 12:56
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 439 Carl Tanner 06-Aug-12 12:18
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 419 eohpyratech 06-Aug-12 14:29
Mod Note > Off Topic "brickmaking" 379 lukehancock 06-Aug-12 15:16
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 414 eohpyratech 06-Aug-12 11:48
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 444 annj1123 05-Aug-12 12:14
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 409 evedropper 27-Jul-12 21:27
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 398 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:29
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 380 evedropper 29-Jul-12 06:33
Ancient Knowledge and Societal Advancements Close Than Anticipated? 425 Chaser 28-Jul-12 00:57
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 434 cladking 28-Jul-12 02:09
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 450 Robert Bauval 28-Jul-12 13:31
Don Barone 416 hendrik dirker 28-Jul-12 11:12
Henrik 460 PB Bytes 28-Jul-12 20:11
In addition to Orion's belt 418 hendrik dirker 29-Jul-12 14:51
Re: In addition to Orion's belt 461 PB Bytes 29-Jul-12 17:16
Re: In addition to Orion's belt 407 W_C_Sally 31-Jul-12 07:42
another question for Robert: 513 hendrik dirker 06-Aug-12 10:05
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 409 Obeone 28-Jul-12 20:05
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 414 Robert Bauval 31-Jul-12 11:34
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 431 gulsbo 31-Jul-12 21:03
Either-Or, and back to basics 414 PB Bytes 28-Jul-12 20:08
Re: Either-Or, and back to basics 428 Robert Bauval 31-Jul-12 11:39
Re: Either-Or, and back to basics 466 Carl Tanner 31-Jul-12 11:51
Re: Either-Or, and back to basics 526 W_C_Sally 31-Jul-12 13:49
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 416 eyeofhorus33 29-Jul-12 18:35
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 352 Carl Tanner 31-Jul-12 01:29
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 450 Richard Fusniak 31-Jul-12 03:02
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 399 Carl Tanner 31-Jul-12 08:18
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 493 Richard Fusniak 31-Jul-12 10:19
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 450 Carl Tanner 31-Jul-12 11:28
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 383 Robert Bauval 31-Jul-12 11:41
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 434 Titus Livius 30-Jul-12 08:37
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 388 Robert Bauval 31-Jul-12 11:46
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 406 Carl Tanner 31-Jul-12 14:23
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 388 Titus Livius 01-Aug-12 07:57
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 387 Archae Solenhofen 30-Jul-12 19:33
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 527 W_C_Sally 31-Jul-12 07:52
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 469 Vanya 30-Jul-12 20:28
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 431 Robert Bauval 31-Jul-12 11:51
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 416 LonelyAngel 31-Jul-12 20:14
Mod Note > “Edit my Post” Function 488 Dr. Troglodyte 31-Jul-12 20:42
Re:Serpent 472 gulsbo 31-Jul-12 21:31
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 385 Thanos5150 01-Aug-12 02:21
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 421 colt 01-Aug-12 05:42
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 493 DUNE 01-Aug-12 09:42
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 427 DUNE 04-Aug-12 10:11
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 483 Robert Bauval 06-Aug-12 04:59
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 426 annj1123 05-Aug-12 11:59
facebook 422 lukehancock 06-Aug-12 15:24
Re: facebook 404 annj1123 07-Aug-12 00:08
Re: facebook 461 Graham Hancock 07-Aug-12 18:36
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 443 hansmittendorf 06-Aug-12 08:30
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 455 W_C_Sally 08-Aug-12 05:57
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 398 hansmittendorf 08-Aug-12 12:09
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 428 W_C_Sally 13-Aug-12 05:42
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 474 DUNE 06-Aug-12 08:40
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 426 drew 06-Aug-12 12:51
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 384 BethSwiss 07-Aug-12 04:41
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 448 wordsmyth 08-Aug-12 20:31
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 528 W_C_Sally 13-Aug-12 05:47
Re: Robert Bauval: GHMB Community Interview --Ask Anything 442 finaltom 11-Aug-12 03:23


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.