Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Russian-born world renowned anthropologist and Egyptologist Alexandre Piankoff, known for his translation of the Pyramid Texts of Unas, writes:

“The embalmed body of the king lay in or under the pyramid, which together with its entire compound, was considered his body. The pyramids were personified.”

However, while researchers like Scott and Robert Bauval concur that the pyramid constructions are a representation of Osiris, they disagree with the tomb theory for, as they rightly point out, there is no archaeological evidence to support the idea that the pyramids were built as tombs – citing the established fact that no mummified bodies have ever been found at Saqqara or any of the other pyramid sites at the Memphite Necropolis.

Furthermore, the translation of Pyramid Text 1657 to which Scott refers in his original post is hardly ambiguous. Orthodox Egyptologists, like Piankoff, acknowledge the personification of the pyramid as the body of Osiris: Scott is just taking the 'physical' mummified body out of the equation (and the pyramid!) imho.

And, if you are going to argue that there is ambiguity in the translation of the Pyramid Texts, then you must concede that Scott's is an equally plausible – and, in the absence of any mummies – reasonable interpretation of Samuel Mercer’s translation of PT 1657b: “this pyramid (of N.) is Osiris; this his temple is Osiris.”

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Birth of Osiris? 1238 Scott Creighton 24-Jul-12 21:18
Re: Birth of Osiris? 405 michael seabrook 24-Jul-12 21:35
Re: Birth of Osiris? 395 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 00:52
Re: Birth of Osiris? 360 michael seabrook 25-Jul-12 16:03
Re: Birth of Osiris? 330 Gary Osborn 25-Jul-12 17:40
Re: Birth of Osiris? 388 Gary Osborn 25-Jul-12 17:59
Re: Birth of Osiris? 422 michael seabrook 25-Jul-12 20:25
Re: Birth of Osiris? 410 Gary Osborn 25-Jul-12 22:16
Re: Birth of Osiris? 422 michael seabrook 26-Jul-12 20:21
Re: Birth of Osiris? 334 Gary Osborn 26-Jul-12 23:03
Re: Birth of Osiris? 404 michael seabrook 27-Jul-12 20:02
Re: Birth of Osiris? 406 Gary Osborn 28-Jul-12 16:02
Re: Birth of Osiris? 434 Scott Creighton 28-Jul-12 16:43
Re: Birth of Osiris? 360 Gary Osborn 28-Jul-12 17:27
Re: Birth of Osiris? 337 michael seabrook 28-Jul-12 21:04
Re: Birth of Osiris? 463 Gary Osborn 28-Jul-12 21:55
Re: Birth of Osiris? 415 MJT 28-Jul-12 23:06
Re: Birth of Osiris? 406 Gary Osborn 28-Jul-12 23:38
Re: Birth of Osiris? 338 MJT 29-Jul-12 01:06
Re: Birth of Osiris? 377 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 03:02
Re: Birth of Osiris? 359 Audrey 29-Jul-12 06:03
Re: Birth of Osiris? 474 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 11:40
Re: Birth of Osiris? 301 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 00:17
Re: Birth of Osiris? 376 MJT 29-Jul-12 01:12
Re: Birth of Osiris? 519 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 00:50
Re: Birth of Osiris? 319 michael seabrook 29-Jul-12 19:48
Re: Birth of Osiris? 359 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 20:40
Re: Birth of Osiris? 388 Gary Osborn 30-Jul-12 00:54
Re: Birth of Osiris? 393 MJT 30-Jul-12 00:33
Re: Birth of Osiris? 364 Gary Osborn 30-Jul-12 01:14
Re: Birth of Osiris? 347 michael seabrook 30-Jul-12 09:12
Re: Birth of Osiris? 392 Gary Osborn 04-Aug-12 15:26
Re: Birth of Osiris? 347 Spiros 25-Jul-12 20:54
Re: Birth of Osiris? 357 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 18:00
Re: Birth of Osiris? 356 Gary Osborn 25-Jul-12 18:03
Re: Birth of Osiris? 387 michael seabrook 26-Jul-12 20:01
Re: Birth of Osiris? 369 eyeofhorus33 26-Jul-12 21:47
Re: Birth of Osiris? 307 michael seabrook 27-Jul-12 19:58
Re: Birth of Osiris? 400 Gary Osborn 26-Jul-12 22:50
Re: Birth of Osiris? 341 Spiros 24-Jul-12 22:31
Re: Birth of Osiris? 393 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 00:45
Re: Birth of Osiris? 397 Spiros 25-Jul-12 08:35
Re: Birth of Osiris? 384 Spiros 25-Jul-12 09:04
Re: Birth of Osiris? 380 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 09:55
Re: Birth of Osiris? 394 NetWorkAngel 25-Jul-12 01:51
Re: Birth of Osiris? 390 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 10:15
Re: Birth of Osiris? 417 eyeofhorus33 25-Jul-12 09:58
Re: Birth of Osiris? 362 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 10:45
Re: Birth of Osiris? 369 eyeofhorus33 25-Jul-12 17:57
Re: Birth of Osiris? 370 eyeofhorus33 25-Jul-12 18:31
Re: Birth of Osiris? 419 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 18:35
Re: Birth of Osiris? 388 eyeofhorus33 26-Jul-12 08:21
Re: Birth of Osiris? 385 Scott Creighton 26-Jul-12 10:22
Re: Birth of Osiris? 860 Gary Osborn 26-Jul-12 14:38
Re: Birth of Osiris? 411 Gary Osborn 26-Jul-12 17:57
Re: Birth of Osiris? 358 Gary Osborn 27-Jul-12 16:21
Re: Birth of Osiris? 380 Archae Solenhofen 25-Jul-12 16:57
Re: Birth of Osiris? 388 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 17:15
Re: Birth of Osiris? 467 Archae Solenhofen 25-Jul-12 17:46
Re: Birth of Osiris? 381 Scott Creighton 25-Jul-12 17:54
Re: Birth of Osiris? 405 eyeofhorus33 25-Jul-12 18:12
Question... 401 LonelyAngel 25-Jul-12 21:13
Re: Question... 367 Scott Creighton 26-Jul-12 10:36
Re: Question... 410 LonelyAngel 27-Jul-12 18:59
Re: Question... 391 Scott Creighton 28-Jul-12 15:29
Re: Birth of Osiris? 423 Corpuscles 26-Jul-12 01:11
Re: Birth of Osiris? 408 Scott Creighton 26-Jul-12 11:33
Re: Birth of Osiris? - Not exactly 322 Eddie Larry 26-Jul-12 04:02
Re: Birth of Osiris? - Not exactly 379 Scott Creighton 26-Jul-12 10:54
Re: depending on the intention of the parties concerned. 384 Thunderbird 29-Jul-12 19:33
Re: depending on the intention of the parties concerned. 328 Eddie Larry 29-Jul-12 22:05
Re: Birth of Osiris? 437 eyeofhorus33 26-Jul-12 13:49
Re: Birth of Osiris? 416 Scott Creighton 26-Jul-12 13:56
Re: Birth of Osiris? 383 eyeofhorus33 26-Jul-12 15:16
Re: Birth of Osiris? 393 eyeofhorus33 26-Jul-12 23:13
Re: Birth of Osiris? 424 Thanos5150 29-Jul-12 04:20
Re: Birth of Osiris? 441 Audrey 29-Jul-12 06:08
Re: Birth of Osiris? 436 eyeofhorus33 29-Jul-12 09:33
Re: Birth of Osiris? 386 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 11:55
Re: Birth of Osiris? 373 Scott Creighton 30-Jul-12 00:35
Re: Birth of Osiris? 473 Thanos5150 30-Jul-12 04:39
Re: Birth of Osiris? 443 eyeofhorus33 30-Jul-12 10:25
Re: Birth of Osiris? 441 Thanos5150 30-Jul-12 18:06
Re: Birth of Osiris? 412 Scott Creighton 31-Jul-12 01:36
Re: Birth of Osiris? 523 Thanos5150 31-Jul-12 07:04
Re: Birth of Osiris? 345 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 11:48
Re: Birth of Osiris? 313 Scott Creighton 29-Jul-12 17:04
Re: Birth of Osiris? 376 Gary Osborn 29-Jul-12 20:42
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 1360 Thunderbird 30-Jul-12 19:48
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 430 Gary Osborn 30-Jul-12 20:48
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 403 Thunderbird 31-Jul-12 03:20
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 387 Gary Osborn 31-Jul-12 12:30
Re: Migrations....lower world ocean levels 389 Thunderbird 31-Jul-12 16:09
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 357 michael seabrook 01-Aug-12 09:44
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 432 sfbey 01-Aug-12 16:01
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 377 Gary Osborn 01-Aug-12 16:50
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 366 sfbey 01-Aug-12 17:14
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 414 Gary Osborn 01-Aug-12 17:36
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 426 Gary Osborn 01-Aug-12 17:59
Re: Naqada III - Sed 372 Thunderbird 01-Aug-12 20:18
Re: Naqada III - Sed 403 sfbey 02-Aug-12 20:27
Re: Earliest Egyptian Glyphs 368 Thunderbird 03-Aug-12 18:59
Re: Earliest Egyptian Glyphs 360 sfbey 03-Aug-12 20:50
Re: Earliest Egyptian Glyphs 384 michael seabrook 04-Aug-12 05:59
Re: Earliest Egyptian Glyphs 372 Eddie Larry 04-Aug-12 14:52
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 397 michael seabrook 01-Aug-12 23:32
Re: the house of Osiris, Lord of Rastaw 373 Gary Osborn 02-Aug-12 01:03
Re: Birth of Osiris? 308 DUNE 31-Jul-12 17:12
Re: Abydos....the Abzu 511 Thunderbird 05-Aug-12 05:16


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.