Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Archae said (to Mr. Von Daniken):

Quote

Why is it being mentioned in "Chariots" that fifty ton monoliths were all that could be moved until recently..... when the largest weight known to have been moved by human power using relatively simple technology is the transport of the 1200+ ton granite block used for the equestrian statue of Peter the Great's base at St Petersburg?

Considering that the original, uncarved estimated weight of the Thunder Stone was 1500 tons and this estimate is based on it's original rectangular hexahedron(ish) shape (7 × 14 × 9 m), what is your source for the 1200+ ton figure and how exactly was this figure determined considering the wave-like shape of the carved pedestal? (Which BTW, looks considerably smaller than the drawings of the original block, particularly when gauged to the height of bystanders.) Also, can you confirm that the density of red/pink granite the same as regular granite?

Quote

It was moved 7 km over land in the 1780's.

Which ultimately took over nine months to move the stone less than four miles!

Quote

They used levers to raise it up, mounted it on a platform of logs and then pull it over bronze balls along iron rails with grooves. Simple and innovative..... no need for technologically inferior, imaginary aliens to do so.

Ignoring your snarky/rude comments directed at Mr. Von Daniken, you appear to be claiming that Industrial Revolution era technology, such as bronze ball bearings and iron rails, is "relatively simple technology" and that they were possessed by some group in antiquity, correct? So please tell us exactly who had this Industrial Revolution era technology in antiquity?

Quote

I say "technologically inferior" because modern cranes and tunneljacking sleds are moving things more than just considerably larger than any of the real and even the grossly exaggerated and/or imaginary blocks attributed to the ancients.

Source please? I'd love to know exactly what modern cranes and tunneljacking sleds are moving more than 1200+ ton objects. Thanks.



Post Edited (22-May-12 22:24)

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman statue 1920 wordsmyth 22-May-12 21:44
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman statue 368 wordsmyth 23-May-12 03:38
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 321 Archae Solenhofen 23-May-12 05:23
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 336 wordsmyth 23-May-12 05:46
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 325 Archae Solenhofen 23-May-12 06:59
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 348 Archae Solenhofen 23-May-12 06:52
How many? 331 Ratcho 23-May-12 07:14
Re: How many? 320 Archae Solenhofen 23-May-12 07:37
2,000...1,000...800... 314 Ratcho 23-May-12 16:55
Re: 2,000...1,000...800... 316 Archae Solenhofen 23-May-12 18:00
Re: 2,000...1,000...800... 349 wordsmyth 23-May-12 20:12
Re: 2,000...1,000...800... 312 Archae Solenhofen 24-May-12 00:54
Re: 2,000...1,000...800... 313 wordsmyth 24-May-12 01:31
Re: 2,000...1,000...800... 299 Archae Solenhofen 24-May-12 06:18
Re: 2,000...1,000...800... 297 wordsmyth 24-May-12 09:44
Hah! 320 RaVaN 24-May-12 15:34
Re: Hah! 297 RaVaN 24-May-12 17:35
Re: Hah! 269 Archae Solenhofen 24-May-12 17:56
Re: Hah! 185 RaVaN 24-May-12 19:16
go to the 5:57 min. mark 311 Ratcho 25-May-12 01:31
Re: go to the 5:57 min. mark 327 RaVaN 25-May-12 14:38
I guess you didn't go to that mark and listen 355 Ratcho 25-May-12 20:04
Re: I guess you didn't go to that mark and listen 309 RaVaN 25-May-12 21:05
Mod Caution > wordsmyth 333 Dr. Troglodyte 24-May-12 18:18
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 361 wordsmyth 23-May-12 19:38
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 367 Archae Solenhofen 23-May-12 23:08
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 338 wordsmyth 24-May-12 01:06
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 315 Archae Solenhofen 24-May-12 06:07
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 320 Sirfiroth 24-May-12 14:51
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 568 wordsmyth 24-May-12 20:52
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 306 Archae Solenhofen 25-May-12 00:54
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 289 wordsmyth 25-May-12 01:41
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 289 Archae Solenhofen 25-May-12 04:34
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 322 wordsmyth 25-May-12 09:26
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 290 RaVaN 25-May-12 14:44
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 349 Archae Solenhofen 25-May-12 15:47
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 298 wordsmyth 25-May-12 19:58
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 487 Archae Solenhofen 26-May-12 16:46
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 343 wordsmyth 26-May-12 23:47
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 269 Archae Solenhofen 27-May-12 03:45
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 309 wordsmyth 27-May-12 04:09
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 278 Archae Solenhofen 27-May-12 04:32
Re: Questions about the Thunder Stone pedestal supporting the Bronze Horseman st 284 cladking 27-May-12 01:09


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.