Mysteries :  The Official forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
No, I don't think the Antikythera device is attributed to Archimedes personally. His life span falls about a century earlier than the estimated date of manufacture for the device. But there is quite a bit of evidence of it having been made in Syracuse, where he lived. Even though it was made of bronze, it could not have lasted for a century without at least some maintenance and probably replacement parts. So it would be the product of a tradition, and maybe even a particular "shop" that he may have founded.

And it seems extremely unlikely that even a "great genius" could have invented such a complex mechanism from whole cloth. There must have been geared devices of some sort that he grew up learning about. Then he may have advanced the state of the art -- or not. It's quite possible that these things already existed but were rare enough that this is the first one recovered. So what the Antikythera device shows us is that the ancients in general were quite able to understand the concept of complex mechanical devices.

Like ancient Rome, we today are once more importing every form of exotic superstition in the hope of finding the right remedy for our sickness.
-- C. G. Jung
Richard Wilhelm: In Memoriam (1930), CW 15: pg. 60

Options: ReplyQuote

Subject Views Written By Posted
Antikythera Mechanism 1048 Mr.Ward 15-May-12 14:32
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 161 carolb 15-May-12 14:55
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 182 Mr.Ward 15-May-12 15:03
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 154 Nolondil 15-May-12 21:02
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 197 Mr.Ward 16-May-12 14:53
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 161 Spiros 16-May-12 17:45
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 159 Nolondil 16-May-12 18:38
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 145 Mr.Ward 17-May-12 12:31
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 137 Nolondil 20-May-12 21:31
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 126 Redoubt 20-May-12 22:52
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 155 carolb 20-May-12 23:01
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 145 Redoubt 21-May-12 02:26
Re: Antikythera Mechanism 147 carolb 21-May-12 04:15

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.