Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Quote

DB: Only problem is THEY DO NOT LINE UP.

SC: This was not your initial point. Let us go a back a step here. You said:

Quote

DB: Recently it has been argued that [sic]Mark Lehner discovered a line that touched all three south east corners of the three Giza Pyramids.

SC: Notice how you were referring to a line claimed by Lehner "that touched all three south east corners of the three Giza pyramids" . When I presented to you what Lehner actually said which shows the complete misinformation of your statement, you do not retract your statement, you do not acknowledge your error. You simply gloss over and move on. So now your claim is that "...THEY DO NOT LINE UP."

Well Lehner knows that too but still it did not prevent him from inferring that this was the INTENT of the builders, to wit:

Quote

"A great SW-NE diagonal cuts the diagonal of Men-kau-re's first queen's pyramid, touches the SE corner of his pyramid, cuts the diagonal of his Mortuary Temple, passes the SE corner of the Khafre Pyramid court, cuts the diagonal of the fore-temple of Khafre's Mortuary Temple, touches the SE corner of Khufu's Pyramid, very nearly cuts the diagonal of his first queen's pyramid and ends in a large block of masonry built into the escarpment.“ - Mark Lehner. (Source).

SC: I rather suspect even if it was spot on perfect, you would still deny it. But it is not perfect and Lehner knew it as his statement above shows. And Lehner's reason as to why it is not a perfect line:

Quote

"These alignments are out by just about the amount that we would expect from methods of sighting and measuring using long cords across a kilometre of sloping plateau." -Mark Lehner, TCP, p.106

SC: There are no perfect squares on the Giza plateau. Nor are any of them set perfectly to the cardinal directions. That does not, however, prevent us - including you - from inferring what the intent was, does it? Why can we infer that intent? Because the error is so small in what is being observed that it is not unreasonable to infer what the builders were trying to do. You want perfection - well I hate to break it to you, Giza is not perfect. Not one single pyramid base is perfect.

Quote

DB: Scott do you honestly think that all the serious Giza researchers of the past would have missed this if they really lined up ?

SC: See above. I rather think Mark Lehner is a serious researcher and has access to more data about the plateau than you or I ever will.

Quote

DB: Observe. This is called beating them up with their own stick.

SC: You just beat yourself up. Hope it wasn't too painful for you.

Quote

DB: No offense but using Lehner as an authority on the geometry at Giza is just plain ludicrous.

SC: Yes, of course, Don. We are all to simply ignore all authorities that agree with what I say and disagree with what you say. Sheesh..............

SC



Post Edited (19-Feb-12 15:54)

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Real Giza Lines 598 Ahatmose 18-Feb-12 04:26
Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 175 Ahatmose 18-Feb-12 04:39
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 179 Scott Creighton 18-Feb-12 11:59
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 252 Citizen Attorney 18-Feb-12 13:48
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 153 Scott Creighton 18-Feb-12 14:15
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 203 Ahatmose 19-Feb-12 00:26
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 216 Thunderbird 19-Feb-12 05:00
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 204 Ahatmose 19-Feb-12 13:42
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 208 Scott Creighton 19-Feb-12 15:47
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 234 Ahatmose 19-Feb-12 23:37
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 201 Scott Creighton 20-Feb-12 10:28
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 163 Ahatmose 20-Feb-12 14:06
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 189 Scott Creighton 20-Feb-12 15:43
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 227 Ahatmose 20-Feb-12 16:03
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 205 Scott Creighton 20-Feb-12 17:27
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 142 Ahatmose 20-Feb-12 18:05
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 201 Ahatmose 21-Feb-12 00:14
Mod Caution > Scott Creighton 184 lukehancock 22-Feb-12 13:28
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 224 Scott Creighton 19-Feb-12 20:20
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 210 Merrell 20-Feb-12 16:08
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 222 Ahatmose 20-Feb-12 16:38
Re: Addendum to The Real Giza Lines 217 Merrell 21-Feb-12 09:01
Re: The Real Giza Lines 230 magisterchessmutt 18-Feb-12 17:47
Re: The Real Giza Lines 173 Scott Creighton 19-Feb-12 17:07
Re: The Real Giza Lines 219 magisterchessmutt 19-Feb-12 22:30
Re: The Real Giza Lines 182 Ahatmose 18-Oct-12 14:31
Gentlemen please... 254 LonelyAngel 20-Feb-12 20:29
Re: The Real Giza Lines 190 Ahatmose 21-Feb-12 02:16


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.