Thanos5150 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Merrell Wrote:

> > "Other documents"?
>
> How bizarre. I am actually quoting Tallet himself
> explaining this that the 13th cattle count is part
> of other administrative documents found at Wadi
> al-Jarf and not part of the Merer diary yet you
> question "other documents"?
>
> Let me quote more of Tallet so maybe it will sink
> in this time
> The Harbor of Khufu on the Red Sea Coast at WAdi al-Jarf, Egypt[/i] Pierre
> Tallet and Gregory Marouard:

[snip]

Thank you for the 2014 quote and link (I have read several of Tallet's and Marouard's papers.)

You might also be interested in this 2017 translation of the final pages of MIFAO 136 here. * It explains how all these documents form a:

Quote

... coherent ensemble of archives—firstly, the other logbooks (papyri C, D, E and F), and then the numerous accounts that are associated (papyri G, H, I, J, K, L and other fragments) (161).

So, while the evidence for the supposed "Year 17 count" is now looking rather tenuous, the evidence for the "Year 13 count" found at Wadi el-Jarf OTOH seems rather more substantial.

* (I think the translation was originally posted by Dr. Troglodyte, although I haven't been able to find that previous link).