Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
cladking Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> There is reason to believe this site was important
> long before the "pre-dynastic" period.

There is? What reason(s) is that specifically?

> Indeed,
> the scattered graves from before the 4th dynasty
> may be misleading since this area was never a
> "cemetery" at all until AFTER the construction of
> pyramids began.

In contradiction to Petrie and the totality of evidence- you know this how exactly?
And tell us what and where these "scattered graves" are that would not constitute a "cemetery"?

> Graves were mostly scattered
> because the site was in use for other purposes.

It was? Like what and please give evidence and sources. And what makes you think they were "scattered" and again where are they?

> This site was important even before the ice age
> since it's the easiest place to cross the river
> since a very long time ago.

Really? And you know about the Nile and Giza plateau before the "ice age" do you? Give examples. And who is crossing the Nile at Giza and where were they going?

> It had military
> significance as far back as the roots of
> civilization.

It did? What evidence can you provide to support this? Civilization goes back long before anything is found at Giza-what military? Who were they fighting?

> Of course it was occupied and
> used.

It was? What is the evidence for this? Who occupied it and what did they use it for-and not your opinion but cite evidence for this.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
A question about Thoth 1250 coarvus 11-Mar-19 19:21
Re: A question about Thoth 362 cladking 11-Mar-19 19:51
Re: A question about Thoth 294 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 19:56
Re: A question about Thoth 302 cladking 11-Mar-19 20:18
Re: A question about Thoth 282 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 20:15
Re: A question about Thoth 265 coarvus 11-Mar-19 20:17
Re: A question about Thoth 209 coarvus 11-Mar-19 20:21
Re: A question about Thoth 247 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 21:11
Re: A question about Thoth 224 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:13
Re: A question about Thoth 242 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 21:58
Re: A question about Thoth 237 coarvus 11-Mar-19 22:01
Re: A question about Thoth 222 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 22:11
Re: A question about Thoth 216 coarvus 11-Mar-19 22:13
Re: A question about Thoth 209 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:22
Re: A question about Thoth 236 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 21:30
Re: A question about Thoth 218 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:58
Re: A question about Thoth 218 eyeofhorus33 12-Mar-19 17:32
Re: A question about Thoth 183 coarvus 13-Mar-19 04:44
Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 246 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 17:24
a rebuttal prediction 204 Warwick 13-Mar-19 19:11
Re: Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 185 coarvus 13-Mar-19 20:01
Re: Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 184 coarvus 13-Mar-19 20:01
Re: A question about Thoth 229 cladking 12-Mar-19 17:44
Re: A question about Integrity 224 eyeofhorus33 12-Mar-19 17:53
Re: A question about Integrity 206 cladking 12-Mar-19 18:53
Re: A question about Integrity 201 Warwick 12-Mar-19 19:11
Re: A question about Integrity 215 coarvus 13-Mar-19 04:51
Putting aside your profanities 225 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 17:13
Re: Putting aside your profanities 198 Warwick 13-Mar-19 19:16
Re: Putting aside your profanities 178 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:02
I notice you swerved my request 224 eyeofhorus33 15-Mar-19 07:03
Re: Putting aside your profanities 180 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:45
Re: Putting aside your profanities 273 cladking 13-Mar-19 20:02
Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 208 Corpuscles 13-Mar-19 21:31
More Than Is Being Said? 232 Barbelo 13-Mar-19 22:05
Here's what they said to me .... 212 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 22:32
Re: Here's what they said to me .... 177 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:03
Re: Here's what they said to me .... 205 eyeofhorus33 15-Mar-19 06:56
The Book Of The Dead Is Dead 200 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 20:19
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 206 cladking 14-Mar-19 00:23
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 229 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 01:33
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 224 cladking 14-Mar-19 02:06
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 221 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 02:46
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 204 cladking 14-Mar-19 03:18
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 185 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 03:54
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 178 cladking 14-Mar-19 04:01
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 202 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 04:40
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 186 coarvus 14-Mar-19 06:23
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 255 cladking 14-Mar-19 13:25
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 209 coarvus 14-Mar-19 13:50
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 177 cladking 14-Mar-19 14:20
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 173 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:07
FTR 216 Warwick 14-Mar-19 19:58
Re: FTR 179 coarvus 14-Mar-19 20:54
Re: FTR 181 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:54
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 196 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 14:29
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 179 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:10
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 178 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 22:01
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 172 coarvus 14-Mar-19 23:02
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 189 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 01:19
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 179 cladking 15-Mar-19 01:45
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 179 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 02:53
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 191 coarvus 15-Mar-19 03:32
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 184 cladking 15-Mar-19 03:49
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 191 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 04:25
I suggest they both Google Search this...... 182 Warwick 15-Mar-19 17:07
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 199 cladking 14-Mar-19 13:14
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 182 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 14:21
No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 191 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 20:02
Re: No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 195 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 04:38
Re: No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 185 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:58
Perhaps you should join DA 196 Warwick 14-Mar-19 20:05
Re: Perhaps you should join DA 185 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 14:53
Been tried before Corpuscles 188 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 14:45
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 194 Thanos5150 17-Mar-19 16:06
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 196 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 18:26
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 206 Corpuscles 17-Mar-19 23:12
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 212 Thanos5150 18-Mar-19 02:24
The secret reason 210 Hanslune 21-Mar-19 04:51
Re: The secret reason 233 Corpuscles 21-Mar-19 06:22
Question 189 Warwick 21-Mar-19 17:05
Re: Question 203 Corpuscles 21-Mar-19 23:04
re VAGUE 165 Warwick 27-Mar-19 19:41
Re: re VAGUE 186 cladking 27-Mar-19 20:52
Re: re VAGUE 178 Thanos5150 28-Mar-19 02:15
Re: re VAGUE 177 cladking 28-Mar-19 02:34
Re: re VAGUE 176 Thanos5150 28-Mar-19 03:01
Re: re VAGUE 190 cladking 28-Mar-19 04:05
Bovine Scatology 227 Warwick 28-Mar-19 06:24
Re: re VAGUE 156 Warwick 28-Mar-19 06:18
Re: The secret reason 216 Hanslune 28-Mar-19 00:00
Re: The secret reason 214 Thanos5150 22-Mar-19 01:29
Thanos 175 Hanslune 28-Mar-19 00:10
10,000 posts Cladking 188 Hanslune 14-Mar-19 05:28
Bait & Bizarro World 193 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 02:51
Re: Bait & Bizarro World 188 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 03:48
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 174 coarvus 15-Mar-19 03:37
I can't resist 224 Warwick 15-Mar-19 17:11
Re: A question about Thoth 248 Broker 11-Mar-19 21:30
Re: A question about Thoth 208 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:34
Re: A question about Thoth 232 engbren 12-Mar-19 10:39
Re: A question about Thoth 235 engbren 16-Mar-19 13:28
Re: A question about Thoth 249 eyeofhorus33 16-Mar-19 14:59
Re: A question about Thoth 190 Warwick 16-Mar-19 15:59
Re: A question about Thoth 184 engbren 16-Mar-19 23:51
G. Patrick Flanagan 215 Dr. Troglodyte 11-Mar-19 21:57
Re: G. Patrick Flanagan 216 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:59
Re: A question about Thoth 201 Corpuscles 13-Mar-19 21:46
He Spent a Night In The King's Chamber 245 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 03:27
Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 191 eyeofhorus33 18-Mar-19 18:50
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 196 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 20:00
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 216 Martin Stower 18-Mar-19 20:43
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 216 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 23:43


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.