Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Corpuscles Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> However after
> 200years of further study it is not valid to
> suggest the translations (particularly of the
> hieroglyphs )are based on (particularly
> entirely) on that "1000 year later" style
> and content of such writings.

Nonsense.

I could provide examples for almost every word in the PT and would remind you that this vocabulary breaks Zipf's Law proving we don't understand it but let's just take the one word that best exemplifies Egyptology's horrendous and illegitimate methodology. Let's take 'rennenutet" as an example. I know a great deal more about this word than I'll let on but suffice to say it is a device that is in the upper eye of horus and collects gas (specifically "I3.t-wt.t"/ CO2) and channels it to the mks-sceptre to keep it afloat. It causes a gas to flow through a conduit that a moving thing can remain "alive". Egyptology as often is the case has it right in a left handed sort of way; they believe that "Rennenutet" is the "Goddess of Respiration". They believe this not because they solved it in the PT because it's mentioned a single time in the PT: They ripped it straight out of the "book of the dead". After the language changed this is the exact same misunderstanding the people had who wrote the book of the dead.

How can Egyptologists ever see their mistake when they can't even see the obvious? They blithely interpret and translate the PT improperly so they can't see the nature of words and of language changed. The pyramid builders used science just like all people before the language failed. It looks like aliens mustta built them because it was an entirely different species that did build them. They used knowledge > creation > understanding to build the pyramids and not superstition.

People will laugh some day.

> Sam, criticises the actual translation of ancient
> Egyptian writing without any ability himself to
> decipher or translate it.

Nobody can translate Ancient Language and it's impossible anyone ever will. It is not translatable into any parseable language. Just like you can't parse one plus one as one times one. The meaning exists in context and evaporates when it is parsed.

Man fears the pyramid, time fears man.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
A question about Thoth 1250 coarvus 11-Mar-19 19:21
Re: A question about Thoth 362 cladking 11-Mar-19 19:51
Re: A question about Thoth 294 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 19:56
Re: A question about Thoth 302 cladking 11-Mar-19 20:18
Re: A question about Thoth 282 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 20:15
Re: A question about Thoth 266 coarvus 11-Mar-19 20:17
Re: A question about Thoth 209 coarvus 11-Mar-19 20:21
Re: A question about Thoth 247 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 21:11
Re: A question about Thoth 224 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:13
Re: A question about Thoth 243 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 21:58
Re: A question about Thoth 237 coarvus 11-Mar-19 22:01
Re: A question about Thoth 222 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 22:11
Re: A question about Thoth 216 coarvus 11-Mar-19 22:13
Re: A question about Thoth 209 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:22
Re: A question about Thoth 236 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 21:30
Re: A question about Thoth 219 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:58
Re: A question about Thoth 218 eyeofhorus33 12-Mar-19 17:32
Re: A question about Thoth 183 coarvus 13-Mar-19 04:44
Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 246 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 17:24
a rebuttal prediction 205 Warwick 13-Mar-19 19:11
Re: Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 185 coarvus 13-Mar-19 20:01
Re: Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 185 coarvus 13-Mar-19 20:01
Re: A question about Thoth 229 cladking 12-Mar-19 17:44
Re: A question about Integrity 224 eyeofhorus33 12-Mar-19 17:53
Re: A question about Integrity 207 cladking 12-Mar-19 18:53
Re: A question about Integrity 201 Warwick 12-Mar-19 19:11
Re: A question about Integrity 215 coarvus 13-Mar-19 04:51
Putting aside your profanities 225 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 17:13
Re: Putting aside your profanities 198 Warwick 13-Mar-19 19:16
Re: Putting aside your profanities 178 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:02
I notice you swerved my request 224 eyeofhorus33 15-Mar-19 07:03
Re: Putting aside your profanities 181 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:45
Re: Putting aside your profanities 273 cladking 13-Mar-19 20:02
Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 208 Corpuscles 13-Mar-19 21:31
More Than Is Being Said? 233 Barbelo 13-Mar-19 22:05
Here's what they said to me .... 212 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 22:32
Re: Here's what they said to me .... 178 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:03
Re: Here's what they said to me .... 205 eyeofhorus33 15-Mar-19 06:56
The Book Of The Dead Is Dead 200 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 20:19
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 207 cladking 14-Mar-19 00:23
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 230 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 01:33
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 224 cladking 14-Mar-19 02:06
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 221 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 02:46
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 204 cladking 14-Mar-19 03:18
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 186 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 03:54
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 178 cladking 14-Mar-19 04:01
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 202 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 04:40
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 187 coarvus 14-Mar-19 06:23
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 255 cladking 14-Mar-19 13:25
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 209 coarvus 14-Mar-19 13:50
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 177 cladking 14-Mar-19 14:20
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 174 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:07
FTR 216 Warwick 14-Mar-19 19:58
Re: FTR 179 coarvus 14-Mar-19 20:54
Re: FTR 181 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:54
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 196 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 14:29
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 179 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:10
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 178 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 22:01
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 172 coarvus 14-Mar-19 23:02
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 189 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 01:19
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 179 cladking 15-Mar-19 01:45
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 179 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 02:53
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 191 coarvus 15-Mar-19 03:32
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 184 cladking 15-Mar-19 03:49
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 191 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 04:25
I suggest they both Google Search this...... 182 Warwick 15-Mar-19 17:07
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 200 cladking 14-Mar-19 13:14
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 182 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 14:21
No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 192 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 20:02
Re: No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 196 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 04:38
Re: No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 185 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:58
Perhaps you should join DA 197 Warwick 14-Mar-19 20:05
Re: Perhaps you should join DA 185 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 14:53
Been tried before Corpuscles 188 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 14:45
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 194 Thanos5150 17-Mar-19 16:06
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 196 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 18:26
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 206 Corpuscles 17-Mar-19 23:12
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 213 Thanos5150 18-Mar-19 02:24
The secret reason 210 Hanslune 21-Mar-19 04:51
Re: The secret reason 233 Corpuscles 21-Mar-19 06:22
Question 189 Warwick 21-Mar-19 17:05
Re: Question 204 Corpuscles 21-Mar-19 23:04
re VAGUE 166 Warwick 27-Mar-19 19:41
Re: re VAGUE 187 cladking 27-Mar-19 20:52
Re: re VAGUE 178 Thanos5150 28-Mar-19 02:15
Re: re VAGUE 177 cladking 28-Mar-19 02:34
Re: re VAGUE 177 Thanos5150 28-Mar-19 03:01
Re: re VAGUE 190 cladking 28-Mar-19 04:05
Bovine Scatology 227 Warwick 28-Mar-19 06:24
Re: re VAGUE 156 Warwick 28-Mar-19 06:18
Re: The secret reason 216 Hanslune 28-Mar-19 00:00
Re: The secret reason 214 Thanos5150 22-Mar-19 01:29
Thanos 175 Hanslune 28-Mar-19 00:10
10,000 posts Cladking 188 Hanslune 14-Mar-19 05:28
Bait & Bizarro World 193 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 02:51
Re: Bait & Bizarro World 189 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 03:48
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 175 coarvus 15-Mar-19 03:37
I can't resist 224 Warwick 15-Mar-19 17:11
Re: A question about Thoth 249 Broker 11-Mar-19 21:30
Re: A question about Thoth 208 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:34
Re: A question about Thoth 233 engbren 12-Mar-19 10:39
Re: A question about Thoth 235 engbren 16-Mar-19 13:28
Re: A question about Thoth 249 eyeofhorus33 16-Mar-19 14:59
Re: A question about Thoth 190 Warwick 16-Mar-19 15:59
Re: A question about Thoth 184 engbren 16-Mar-19 23:51
G. Patrick Flanagan 216 Dr. Troglodyte 11-Mar-19 21:57
Re: G. Patrick Flanagan 217 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:59
Re: A question about Thoth 201 Corpuscles 13-Mar-19 21:46
He Spent a Night In The King's Chamber 245 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 03:27
Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 191 eyeofhorus33 18-Mar-19 18:50
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 196 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 20:00
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 217 Martin Stower 18-Mar-19 20:43
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 217 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 23:43


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.