Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
coarvus Wrote:

coarvus, dude you demonstrate that you know even far less (more ignorant) than even Cladking is about the decipherment, and translation of ancient Egyptian writing and the interpretation of it.
You are merely parroting Cladking's inaccuracies


-------------------------------------------------------
> Ok so if you didn't infer or imply anything than
> you must agree that these translations cannot
> possibly be fully translted from a book from a
> thousande years later.

The truth of it is that in the early development of the understanding of the AE language correlations with the then found extant copies of "Book of the Dead***" were made! However after 200years of further study it is not valid to suggest the translations (particularly of the hieroglyphs )are based on (particularly entirely) on that "1000 year later" style and content of such writings.

***(actually more accurately translated "The book of coming forth by day" but other translations which you could learn a little about in general here.
That one is another modern internet version of a book called an "Encycopedia"

In fact, if you read the posted brief article, rather it suggests the exact opposite.



Also love how you can't use
> that big ol brain of yours to read something with
> few misspellings and infer what I was saying. Also
> you just look like a moron when you criticize
> someones spelling on a forum or something of the
> like because that just opens you too look like a
> massive hypocritical moron when you misspell
> something(notice how eye,war,sam, and I have all
> misspelled a few words and haven't called the
> other on it)

I understand your comment regarding criticism of spelling however this:

"have difficulting stating the manying of something"

Is a tad more serious than just spelling. Note you were accusing me of being a "hypocritical moron"!
If you are just trolling then well done! Quite funny, in indicating that you "have difficulting stating the manying of something"

Further, my comments were about your choice of words "depict" I can only guess you meant "decipher"? and "infer" instead of imply (which the exact opposite to the presumably intended? otherwise renders the statement incoherent )


Also, if you'd like to draw your
> attention to the top of the screen you will notice
> that this webstie is meant to discuss
> controversies. Now either bring forward evidince
> that the book of incantations is able to
> accurately decoded every hieroglyph, or understand
> that Sam is just pointing out that a book from a
> thousand years in the future won't accurately
> depic the past.



Anyway, given that Cladking has failed or stubbornly refuses to understand , the regular criticism from many posters , perhaps you can attempt to genuinely grasp the issue .

Sam, criticises the actual translation of ancient Egyptian writing without any ability himself to decipher or translate it.
Nor, has he any clear understanding of the methodology and history of how such has progressively been validated.
Sure there are areas of contention in translation . However Sam, would not know anything about that, unless he read what an Egyptologist has openly written and said about it.

The criticises Egyptology as a whole, which without that profession he would know absolutely zero and he pretends in insane unique delusions he knows better than all (everyone).

Sam, relies entirely on the translated works of the Pyramid Texts by Egyptologists to fabricate his own fantasies. If they were not translated in the first place, reasonably accurately or close, then he would have nothing to base his guesses upon ,which he says comes to him via something called "metaphysics" . Special "metaphysics" which only he uniquely knows about.

He suggests the Pyramid texts are entirely translated and interpreted based on the Book of the Dead. There is some truth in correlation and development of concepts (particularly early on in the 19th century) but it is not the basis for the further development over two centuries of study an understanding of the language.

Then you swallow it and just parrot his inane claims.

I suspect you will continue to refuse to learn the facts because it does not suit your alien lost civilization woo beliefs.

You can either do you own research and learn and validate the facts or stay ignorant and stupid that is completely your prerogative.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
A question about Thoth 1252 coarvus 11-Mar-19 19:21
Re: A question about Thoth 362 cladking 11-Mar-19 19:51
Re: A question about Thoth 294 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 19:56
Re: A question about Thoth 304 cladking 11-Mar-19 20:18
Re: A question about Thoth 282 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 20:15
Re: A question about Thoth 266 coarvus 11-Mar-19 20:17
Re: A question about Thoth 210 coarvus 11-Mar-19 20:21
Re: A question about Thoth 247 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 21:11
Re: A question about Thoth 224 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:13
Re: A question about Thoth 243 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 21:58
Re: A question about Thoth 237 coarvus 11-Mar-19 22:01
Re: A question about Thoth 222 Thanos5150 11-Mar-19 22:11
Re: A question about Thoth 217 coarvus 11-Mar-19 22:13
Re: A question about Thoth 211 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:22
Re: A question about Thoth 236 eyeofhorus33 11-Mar-19 21:30
Re: A question about Thoth 219 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:58
Re: A question about Thoth 218 eyeofhorus33 12-Mar-19 17:32
Re: A question about Thoth 183 coarvus 13-Mar-19 04:44
Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 246 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 17:24
a rebuttal prediction 205 Warwick 13-Mar-19 19:11
Re: Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 186 coarvus 13-Mar-19 20:01
Re: Ooooh, the Annunaki .... 186 coarvus 13-Mar-19 20:01
Re: A question about Thoth 229 cladking 12-Mar-19 17:44
Re: A question about Integrity 224 eyeofhorus33 12-Mar-19 17:53
Re: A question about Integrity 207 cladking 12-Mar-19 18:53
Re: A question about Integrity 202 Warwick 12-Mar-19 19:11
Re: A question about Integrity 216 coarvus 13-Mar-19 04:51
Putting aside your profanities 226 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 17:13
Re: Putting aside your profanities 200 Warwick 13-Mar-19 19:16
Re: Putting aside your profanities 179 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:02
I notice you swerved my request 224 eyeofhorus33 15-Mar-19 07:03
Re: Putting aside your profanities 181 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:45
Re: Putting aside your profanities 274 cladking 13-Mar-19 20:02
Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 208 Corpuscles 13-Mar-19 21:31
More Than Is Being Said? 233 Barbelo 13-Mar-19 22:05
Here's what they said to me .... 212 eyeofhorus33 13-Mar-19 22:32
Re: Here's what they said to me .... 178 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:03
Re: Here's what they said to me .... 205 eyeofhorus33 15-Mar-19 06:56
The Book Of The Dead Is Dead 200 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 20:19
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 207 cladking 14-Mar-19 00:23
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 230 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 01:33
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 224 cladking 14-Mar-19 02:06
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 223 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 02:46
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 205 cladking 14-Mar-19 03:18
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 187 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 03:54
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 178 cladking 14-Mar-19 04:01
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 202 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 04:40
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 187 coarvus 14-Mar-19 06:23
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 255 cladking 14-Mar-19 13:25
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 209 coarvus 14-Mar-19 13:50
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 177 cladking 14-Mar-19 14:20
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 174 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:07
FTR 216 Warwick 14-Mar-19 19:58
Re: FTR 179 coarvus 14-Mar-19 20:54
Re: FTR 182 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:54
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 196 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 14:29
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 180 coarvus 14-Mar-19 21:10
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 178 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 22:01
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 172 coarvus 14-Mar-19 23:02
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 189 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 01:19
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 180 cladking 15-Mar-19 01:45
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 180 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 02:53
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 192 coarvus 15-Mar-19 03:32
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 185 cladking 15-Mar-19 03:49
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 191 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 04:25
I suggest they both Google Search this...... 183 Warwick 15-Mar-19 17:07
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 200 cladking 14-Mar-19 13:14
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 183 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 14:21
No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 192 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 20:02
Re: No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 196 Corpuscles 15-Mar-19 04:38
Re: No Cure: Rinse & Repeat 186 Warwick 15-Mar-19 16:58
Perhaps you should join DA 197 Warwick 14-Mar-19 20:05
Re: Perhaps you should join DA 185 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 14:53
Been tried before Corpuscles 189 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 14:45
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 194 Thanos5150 17-Mar-19 16:06
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 196 Hanslune 17-Mar-19 18:26
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 206 Corpuscles 17-Mar-19 23:12
Re: Been tried before Corpuscles 213 Thanos5150 18-Mar-19 02:24
The secret reason 210 Hanslune 21-Mar-19 04:51
Re: The secret reason 234 Corpuscles 21-Mar-19 06:22
Question 189 Warwick 21-Mar-19 17:05
Re: Question 205 Corpuscles 21-Mar-19 23:04
re VAGUE 166 Warwick 27-Mar-19 19:41
Re: re VAGUE 188 cladking 27-Mar-19 20:52
Re: re VAGUE 178 Thanos5150 28-Mar-19 02:15
Re: re VAGUE 177 cladking 28-Mar-19 02:34
Re: re VAGUE 177 Thanos5150 28-Mar-19 03:01
Re: re VAGUE 191 cladking 28-Mar-19 04:05
Bovine Scatology 227 Warwick 28-Mar-19 06:24
Re: re VAGUE 156 Warwick 28-Mar-19 06:18
Re: The secret reason 216 Hanslune 28-Mar-19 00:00
Re: The secret reason 215 Thanos5150 22-Mar-19 01:29
Thanos 177 Hanslune 28-Mar-19 00:10
10,000 posts Cladking 189 Hanslune 14-Mar-19 05:28
Bait & Bizarro World 193 Barbelo 14-Mar-19 02:51
Re: Bait & Bizarro World 189 Corpuscles 14-Mar-19 03:48
Re: Complete (contradictory) Ignorance - & sadly total insanity 176 coarvus 15-Mar-19 03:37
I can't resist 224 Warwick 15-Mar-19 17:11
Re: A question about Thoth 249 Broker 11-Mar-19 21:30
Re: A question about Thoth 209 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:34
Re: A question about Thoth 233 engbren 12-Mar-19 10:39
Re: A question about Thoth 235 engbren 16-Mar-19 13:28
Re: A question about Thoth 250 eyeofhorus33 16-Mar-19 14:59
Re: A question about Thoth 190 Warwick 16-Mar-19 15:59
Re: A question about Thoth 185 engbren 16-Mar-19 23:51
G. Patrick Flanagan 216 Dr. Troglodyte 11-Mar-19 21:57
Re: G. Patrick Flanagan 217 coarvus 11-Mar-19 21:59
Re: A question about Thoth 202 Corpuscles 13-Mar-19 21:46
He Spent a Night In The King's Chamber 245 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 03:27
Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 191 eyeofhorus33 18-Mar-19 18:50
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 196 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 20:00
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 217 Martin Stower 18-Mar-19 20:43
Re: Shades of Sodom and Gomorrah 217 Barbelo 18-Mar-19 23:43


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.