Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Merrell Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> As has been commented before elsewhere: if there
> was compromising material in his field-notes,
> why on earth keep them? Why on earth not
> dispose of the journal - or, at least, those parts
> dealing with Giza - in a fireplace at Stoke?
>
> Why?

A question which loses none of its cogency when we are told that Vyse would not have allowed his secret source or “secret cache” to survive:

http://grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?1,324467,324986

http://grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?1,324467,324990

http://www.abovetopsecret.com/forum/thread1024757/pg3#pid18234803

http://grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?1,336962,337104

https://www.unexplained-mysteries.com/forum/topic/270485-gp-hoax-new-evidence-of-vyse-forgery/ . . .

M.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 2171 Thanos5150 27-Feb-19 05:44
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 475 Morten 27-Feb-19 06:22
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 390 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 11:52
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 388 Morten 27-Feb-19 12:31
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 334 LonelyAngel 27-Feb-19 14:06
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 363 Morten 27-Feb-19 14:26
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 341 LonelyAngel 27-Feb-19 16:35
Re: The Strange Journey of Humphries Brewer (2 Book Series) 354 Morten 27-Feb-19 16:44
Ignore list?? 359 LonelyAngel 27-Feb-19 16:48
I'm so proud 384 LonelyAngel 27-Feb-19 11:21
Re: I'm so proud 333 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 11:49
Re: I'm so proud 306 LonelyAngel 27-Feb-19 12:20
Re: I'm so proud 303 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 12:48
Re: I'm so proud 310 LonelyAngel 27-Feb-19 13:11
Re: I'm so proud 329 Corpuscles 27-Feb-19 22:51
Why Can't Martin Stower Read Vyse Journal? 516 Scott Creighton 27-Feb-19 18:21
Why Can’t Creighton Tell the Truth? 510 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 20:07
Mod Note > Duplicate Topic Merged 275 Dr. Troglodyte 27-Feb-19 20:28
Why Truncate? 362 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 21:38
Re: Why Truncate? 287 Corpuscles 27-Feb-19 23:14
Re: Why Truncate? 300 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 23:26
Re: Why Truncate? 342 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 15:13
Walter Allen's Logbook 272 Merrell 05-Mar-19 23:47
Re: Why Truncate? 281 Corpuscles 06-Mar-19 00:05
Re: Why Truncate? 275 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 02:00
Why Can’t Creighton Read Vyse’s Journal? 425 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 23:00
Re: Why Can't Martin Stower Read Vyse Journal? 287 R Avry Wilson 28-Feb-19 02:01
Re: Why Can't Martin Stower Read Vyse Journal? 289 LonelyAngel 28-Feb-19 09:37
Re: Why Can't Martin Stower Read Vyse Journal? 313 Merrell 28-Feb-19 14:18
Re: Why Can't Martin Stower Read Vyse Journal? 294 LonelyAngel 28-Feb-19 14:54
The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 371 Scott Creighton 27-Feb-19 22:49
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 313 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 23:19
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 306 Scott Creighton 27-Feb-19 23:23
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 330 Martin Stower 27-Feb-19 23:41
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 327 Morten 28-Feb-19 00:00
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 281 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 00:07
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 291 Corpuscles 28-Feb-19 00:43
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 288 Corpuscles 28-Feb-19 01:03
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 266 Corpuscles 28-Feb-19 01:14
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 285 Warwick 28-Feb-19 06:08
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 279 LonelyAngel 28-Feb-19 09:06
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 262 Warwick 28-Feb-19 18:08
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 265 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 10:22
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 282 LonelyAngel 28-Feb-19 11:41
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 250 Warwick 28-Feb-19 18:01
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 272 Merrell 28-Feb-19 10:51
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 250 Warwick 28-Feb-19 18:18
Re: The Silent Quarry Marks in Campbell's Chamber 273 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 10:08
Creighton comes a cropper! 299 eyeofhorus33 28-Feb-19 17:48
Mod Caution > Triplicate Topic Merged 272 Dr. Troglodyte 27-Feb-19 23:30
We Have Seen It Already 312 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 00:48
Re: We Have Seen It Already 315 Martin Stower 02-Mar-19 10:49
Re: We Have Seen It Already 261 Warwick 02-Mar-19 15:38
Checkmate! 445 Scott Creighton 28-Feb-19 10:31
Re: Checkmate! 329 Scott Creighton 28-Feb-19 11:13
Adjudication 419 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 12:06
Re: Checkmate! 326 R Avry Wilson 28-Feb-19 21:22
Re: Checkmate! 347 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 08:34
Creighton’s First Sight of a Transcript 530 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 11:33
Re: Creighton’s First Sight of a Transcript 304 LonelyAngel 28-Feb-19 11:51
Re: Creighton’s First Sight of a Transcript 285 Warwick 28-Feb-19 18:24
Re: Creighton’s First Sight of a Transcript 277 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 08:58
Re: Creighton’s First Sight of a Transcript 266 Warwick 01-Mar-19 18:19
Re: Checkmate! 308 Merrell 28-Feb-19 12:15
That Subtle Aroma . . . 329 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 12:58
Creighton’s Plonking Pronouncements 343 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 14:36
Vyse’s Execrable Pages 317 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 19:33
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 273 Warwick 28-Feb-19 20:50
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 278 Corpuscles 28-Feb-19 21:37
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 298 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 09:12
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 251 Warwick 01-Mar-19 18:32
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 269 Corpuscles 01-Mar-19 22:23
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 275 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 11:39
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 260 Corpuscles 02-Mar-19 01:01
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 303 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 21:52
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 293 R Avry Wilson 28-Feb-19 22:12
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 308 Martin Stower 28-Feb-19 23:10
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 273 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 09:08
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 287 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 10:10
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 265 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 11:58
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 273 WonderWho 01-Mar-19 12:12
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 296 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 12:36
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 271 Warwick 01-Mar-19 18:46
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 248 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 21:55
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 278 Warwick 01-Mar-19 22:08
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 266 LonelyAngel 02-Mar-19 12:53
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 246 Warwick 02-Mar-19 15:30
Re: Vyse’s Execrable Pages 290 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 12:33
Another Exhibit 434 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 15:40
Re: Another Exhibit 331 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 16:20
Re: Another Exhibit 360 Merrell 01-Mar-19 18:14
Re: Another Exhibit 307 LonelyAngel 01-Mar-19 21:53
Re: Another Exhibit 282 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 22:17
Re: Another Exhibit 281 LonelyAngel 02-Mar-19 15:20
Re: Another Exhibit 275 DUNE 02-Mar-19 15:28
Re: Another Exhibit 300 Merrell 02-Mar-19 16:23
Re: Another Exhibit 249 Warwick 02-Mar-19 16:42
Re: Another Exhibit 284 LonelyAngel 02-Mar-19 16:52
Re: Another Exhibit 251 Warwick 02-Mar-19 17:39
Re: Another Exhibit 266 LonelyAngel 02-Mar-19 18:06
Re: Another Exhibit 269 Martin Stower 02-Mar-19 18:14
Re: Another Exhibit 260 LonelyAngel 02-Mar-19 18:49
Re: Another Exhibit 285 Martin Stower 02-Mar-19 19:35
Re: Another Exhibit 278 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 17:08
Re: Another Exhibit 287 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 18:28
Re: Another Exhibit 266 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 21:31
Re: Another Exhibit 271 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 21:46
Re: Another Exhibit 249 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 22:23
grovelling? 251 Warwick 05-Mar-19 18:58
Re: Another Exhibit 247 Corpuscles 05-Mar-19 21:09
Re: Another Exhibit 269 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 21:30
Re: Another Exhibit 277 Corpuscles 05-Mar-19 22:13
Re: Another Exhibit 271 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 22:37
Re: Another Exhibit 266 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 11:08
Re: Another Exhibit 261 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 11:45
Re: Another Exhibit 261 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 13:09
Re: Another Exhibit 261 Warwick 06-Mar-19 17:50
Re: Another Exhibit 238 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 18:09
Re: Another Exhibit 275 Warwick 06-Mar-19 20:36
Re: Another Exhibit 275 Corpuscles 06-Mar-19 21:30
Re: Another Exhibit 250 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 21:44
Re: Another Exhibit 241 sfbey 06-Mar-19 22:53
Re: Another Exhibit 276 Corpuscles 07-Mar-19 01:44
Re: Another Exhibit 259 LonelyAngel 07-Mar-19 11:01
Re: Another Exhibit 278 Corpuscles 07-Mar-19 12:24
Re: Another Exhibit 232 LonelyAngel 07-Mar-19 19:15
Re: Another Exhibit 235 Warwick 07-Mar-19 19:31
Re: Another Exhibit 256 Merrell 06-Mar-19 15:16
Re: Another Exhibit 247 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 15:41
Re: Another Exhibit 240 Warwick 02-Mar-19 18:18
Re: Another Exhibit 255 LonelyAngel 02-Mar-19 18:35
Re: Another Exhibit 243 Warwick 03-Mar-19 17:01
Re: Another Exhibit 261 Martin Stower 02-Mar-19 18:03
Re: Another Exhibit 274 Martin Stower 02-Mar-19 22:21
Re: Another Exhibit 293 Martin Stower 03-Mar-19 10:28
Re: Another Exhibit 266 Corpuscles 02-Mar-19 19:43
Re: Another Exhibit 326 Morten 01-Mar-19 16:55
Re: Another Exhibit 273 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 22:59
Compare and Contrast 280 Martin Stower 01-Mar-19 23:41
Opposing claims 272 Merrell 02-Mar-19 09:52
Re: Compare and Contrast 283 Warwick 02-Mar-19 15:35
Where is Scott Creighton? 319 Martin Stower 03-Mar-19 15:32
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? 258 cloister 03-Mar-19 16:03
talking nonsense about 'hieroglyphics' 279 eyeofhorus33 03-Mar-19 16:03
and FTR 268 Warwick 03-Mar-19 17:04
Re: talking nonsense about 'hieroglyphics' 279 Martin Stower 03-Mar-19 17:35
Re: talking nonsense about 'hieroglyphics' 268 Warwick 03-Mar-19 18:13
Re: talking nonsense about 'hieroglyphics'- with tongue in cheek? 273 Corpuscles 04-Mar-19 06:04
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? 296 Corpuscles 03-Mar-19 22:09
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? 252 Warwick 04-Mar-19 19:11
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? 248 Corpuscles 04-Mar-19 22:48
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 268 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 17:02
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 247 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 18:29
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 248 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 18:46
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 258 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 18:51
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 267 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 19:00
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 258 Warwick 05-Mar-19 19:06
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 239 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 19:45
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 232 Warwick 05-Mar-19 19:53
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 235 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 21:05
claridication please 262 Warwick 05-Mar-19 21:11
Re: claridication please 236 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 21:18
Re: claridication please 244 Warwick 05-Mar-19 21:20
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 254 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 21:25
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 235 Hanslune 05-Mar-19 20:42
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 274 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 19:18
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 244 Corpuscles 05-Mar-19 20:44
Re: Where is Scott Creighton? Here's a guess... 258 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 20:52
Knocking it for 6 248 Warwick 05-Mar-19 18:48
Groundhog Day 253 Warwick 05-Mar-19 19:34
Re: Groundhog Day 266 LonelyAngel 05-Mar-19 20:55
Re: Groundhog Day 271 Warwick 05-Mar-19 21:02
Elsewhere? 264 Hanslune 05-Mar-19 00:52
You were saying? 381 Martin Stower 03-Mar-19 21:32
This is where we came in . . . 284 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 11:51
The only thing worse than a sore loser.. 329 Morten 05-Mar-19 01:56
Re: The only thing worse than a sore loser.. 272 Martin Stower 05-Mar-19 20:55
The Deception Continues 534 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 15:11
Ah... a free advertisement for Abovetopsecret.com? 307 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 15:25
Re: Ah... a free advertisement for Abovetopsecret.com? 272 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 15:57
Re: Ah... a free advertisement for Abovetopsecret.com? 273 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 16:27
A suggestion - a meeting place 260 Hanslune 06-Mar-19 23:44
Mod Note > Duplicate Topic Merged 261 Dr. Troglodyte 06-Mar-19 17:03
??? 280 Warwick 06-Mar-19 18:09
Planet Desperation 285 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 19:18
Re: Planet Desperation 277 Martin Stower 06-Mar-19 20:03
Re: Planet Desperation 240 Warwick 06-Mar-19 20:25
Re: Planet Desperation 274 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 21:16
Re: Planet Desperation 234 Warwick 06-Mar-19 21:49
Re: Planet Desperation 237 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 22:04
Re: Planet Desperation 239 Warwick 07-Mar-19 18:04
Re: Planet Desperation 255 Warwick 07-Mar-19 18:30
A friendly fireplace ... 282 Merrell 06-Mar-19 21:35
Re: A friendly fireplace ... 262 Warwick 06-Mar-19 21:55
Re: A friendly fireplace ... 276 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 21:08
Re: Planet Desperation 290 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 13:37
Re: Planet Desperation 246 LonelyAngel 07-Mar-19 13:39
Re: Planet Desperation 261 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 13:49
Re: Planet Desperation 251 LonelyAngel 07-Mar-19 14:32
Re: Planet Desperation 294 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 15:13
Re: Planet Desperation 265 Jon Ellison 07-Mar-19 13:49
Re: Planet Desperation 260 Jon Ellison 07-Mar-19 13:58
Re: Planet Desperation 254 Jon Ellison 07-Mar-19 14:08
Re: Planet Desperation 256 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 14:23
Re: Planet Desperation 251 Jon Ellison 07-Mar-19 14:58
Re: Planet Desperation 248 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 15:35
Re: Planet Desperation 258 Jon Ellison 07-Mar-19 15:38
Re: Planet Desperation 253 Martin Stower 07-Mar-19 15:53
Re: Planet Desperation 263 Jon Ellison 07-Mar-19 16:21
Re: Planet Desperation 262 Corpuscles 07-Mar-19 20:06
Re: Planet Desperation 253 LonelyAngel 07-Mar-19 21:02
Re: Planet Desperation 230 Corpuscles 08-Mar-19 00:58
Re: Planet Desperation 276 LonelyAngel 08-Mar-19 10:37
Re: Planet Desperation 264 Martin Stower 08-Mar-19 12:03
Only a question... 267 LonelyAngel 08-Mar-19 13:55
Re: Only a question... 272 Martin Stower 08-Mar-19 23:07
Re: Only a question... 234 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 00:26
Re: Only a question... 282 Martin Stower 09-Mar-19 00:52
Thoughts of a simple man... 258 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 10:17
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 238 Merrell 09-Mar-19 11:30
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 253 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 12:39
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 249 Merrell 09-Mar-19 12:57
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 225 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 15:32
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 247 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 15:46
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 275 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 16:10
Evidence for posterity 246 Merrell 09-Mar-19 16:16
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 259 Martin Stower 09-Mar-19 21:11
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 246 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 15:53
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 240 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 16:17
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 237 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 16:46
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 251 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 16:58
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 243 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 17:11
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 254 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 18:45
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 278 Martin Stower 09-Mar-19 21:15
Strange Journey? 267 R Avry Wilson 10-Mar-19 10:46
Re: Strange Journey? 243 Corpuscles 10-Mar-19 11:48
Re: Strange Journey? 267 Merrell 10-Mar-19 12:11
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 280 Corpuscles 09-Mar-19 19:59
Re: Thoughts of a simple man... 291 Martin Stower 09-Mar-19 20:51
Re: Planet Desperation 270 Jon Ellison 08-Mar-19 12:25
Re: Planet Desperation 270 Martin Stower 08-Mar-19 12:37
Re: Planet Desperation 251 Jon Ellison 08-Mar-19 12:49
Re: Planet Desperation 326 Corpuscles 08-Mar-19 18:49
Re: Planet Desperation 238 Warwick 08-Mar-19 19:29
Re: Planet Desperation 231 LonelyAngel 09-Mar-19 16:24
Re: Planet Desperation 243 Jon Ellison 08-Mar-19 00:05
Re: Planet Desperation 255 Corpuscles 08-Mar-19 01:06
Re: Planet Desperation 268 Jon Ellison 08-Mar-19 08:23
Re: Planet Desperation 263 Corpuscles 08-Mar-19 08:51
Re: Planet Desperation 272 Jon Ellison 08-Mar-19 09:11
Re: ??? 282 LonelyAngel 06-Mar-19 20:03
Re: ??? 284 Warwick 06-Mar-19 20:18
Mod Note > Topic Closed 300 Dr. Troglodyte 10-Mar-19 14:05


Sorry, you can't reply to this topic. It has been closed.