Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hello Madeleine.

MDaines Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Easy research on internet shows that it wasn’t
> only Thoth linked to this tool. I have no
> specialist knowledge of ancient Egyptian imagery,
> and haven’t gone into the subject to any depth.
> Perhaps the above hypothesis has already been put
> forward and rejected thanks to substantiated
> arguments unknown to me. But I would be
> interested to know. Thanks.

Djet, 1st Dynasty:


Helwan, 1st Dynasty:


2nd Dynasty:


Middle Kingdom:


New Kingdom:


Late Period:


To my knowledge the earliest depiction of the Was sceptre was in the 1st Dynasty. What is interesting to me is that it all but disappears from 3rd Dynasty through Old Kingdom iconography where at some point in the Middle Kingdom and onward becomes part and parcel of AE symbolism seemingly twisted into a different form, namely with an animal head. There is a staff depicted in the 3rd-OK, which kind of sorta looks like it, but to me not really especially considering there was no confusion from the MK onward. Saqqra, 3rd Dynasty. 4th symbol over from top left:

Large.

This may be conflated with a version of the Was sceptre but I think it's a stretch.

Regardless, if you look at the archaic depictions, I do not believe the top "t" is meant to be at an angle on the same plane as the the "prong" at the bottom, but rather is depicted in forced perspective. Meaning in reality the "t" is on a horizontal and parallel plane to the prong. Imagine this: T : with the open prong facing us on the bottom.

Regarding the depictions of the Was sceptre from the MK on, I do not believe they understood what it originally was, its meaning ancient and lost in their time, and warped not only its meaning but its physical form having based their depictions on literal observation unaware it was actually shown in forced perspective.

Of further interest is that while the Was sceptre, ankh, djed pillar are all found in the 1st Dynasty, you will not find them depicted on any of the palettes or tokens associated with the first kings implying whatever the Was scepter was that was so important to Djet was not shared by those before him. Again:


I'm not sure what this disconnect means, but it means something.

My opinion, for whatever it's worth, is that the Was sceptre was originally a tool related to either astronomy and/or surveying and the meaning it had to later AE from the MK onward had little or nothing to do with its original purpose. I think further evidence of this is that as far as I can tell the iconography of the Was sceptre was all but abandoned from the 3rd Dynasty-OK which makes for quite a leap of dormancy in understanding.

As far as any relation to weaving, I know of none in any period and unless we have completely missed the supreme monumental importance of weaving in 3,000yrs of AE culture, it stands to reason it would not be prominently displayed as a symbol of power for the pharaohs, gods, and apparently mysticism in general.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 22-Oct-17 23:22 by Thanos5150.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 3027 MDaines 22-Oct-17 11:00
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 858 cladking 22-Oct-17 13:32
Egyptian Thoth gave technology around the world 955 Howard West 22-Oct-17 15:04
Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 873 MDaines 22-Oct-17 15:30
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 801 Howard West 23-Oct-17 00:58
Djet's Comb 830 MDaines 22-Oct-17 15:39
Re: Djet's Comb 796 MDaines 26-Oct-17 18:20
Re: Djet's Comb 843 Manu 26-Oct-17 20:41
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 846 cladking 22-Oct-17 15:54
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 766 MDaines 22-Oct-17 16:50
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 816 cladking 22-Oct-17 18:52
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 747 MDaines 22-Oct-17 19:39
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 931 Thanos5150 22-Oct-17 23:21
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 804 MDaines 23-Oct-17 08:32
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 1133 Thanos5150 23-Oct-17 22:03
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 768 R Avry Wilson 23-Oct-17 19:54
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 795 Thanos5150 23-Oct-17 22:29
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 752 R Avry Wilson 23-Oct-17 23:30
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 803 Manu 24-Oct-17 01:36
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 774 Thanos5150 24-Oct-17 02:06
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 774 R Avry Wilson 24-Oct-17 02:59
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 836 eyeofhorus33 24-Oct-17 09:46
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 759 Thanos5150 24-Oct-17 16:00
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 745 Manu 23-Oct-17 01:45
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 766 MDaines 23-Oct-17 13:31
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 802 Manu 23-Oct-17 15:00
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 781 MDaines 23-Oct-17 15:39
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 761 Manu 23-Oct-17 16:35
The Ankh, the Djed, and the Spinnekrok 1165 MDaines 24-Oct-17 11:21
Re: The Ankh, the Djed, and the Spinnekrok 748 Manu 24-Oct-17 15:34
Re: The Ankh, the Djed, and the Spinnekrok 749 MDaines 25-Oct-17 08:37
Re: The Ankh, the Djed, and the Spinnekrok 851 Manu 25-Oct-17 14:44
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 713 Reagent 23-Oct-17 01:57
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 731 cladking 23-Oct-17 02:40
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 768 Reagent 23-Oct-17 03:58
Tayet 764 R Avry Wilson 23-Oct-17 04:37
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 800 R Avry Wilson 23-Oct-17 04:27
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 737 MDaines 23-Oct-17 13:49
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 750 R Avry Wilson 23-Oct-17 19:50
Isler’s Gnomon Progression 995 Dr. Troglodyte 23-Oct-17 22:25
Re: Isler’s Gnomon Progression 712 MDaines 25-Oct-17 08:33
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 895 Manu 23-Oct-17 21:12
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 699 MDaines 25-Oct-17 15:36
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 777 Manu 25-Oct-17 19:08
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 679 Thanos5150 26-Oct-17 02:37
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 724 Manu 26-Oct-17 04:14
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 727 R Avry Wilson 26-Oct-17 05:08
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 707 Manu 26-Oct-17 06:05
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 730 Thanos5150 26-Oct-17 05:41
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 789 Manu 26-Oct-17 06:07
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 722 cladking 26-Oct-17 13:45
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 853 Manu 26-Oct-17 14:43
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 849 Broker 31-Oct-17 01:43
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 762 MDaines 31-Oct-17 11:26
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 833 Broker 31-Oct-17 19:33
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 925 Broker 31-Oct-17 23:45
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 799 MDaines 01-Nov-17 13:52
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 752 Broker 02-Nov-17 00:13
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 698 MDaines 02-Nov-17 11:19
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 714 Broker 03-Nov-17 02:31
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 818 Broker 03-Nov-17 18:31
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 892 Thanos5150 02-Nov-17 06:08
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 705 MDaines 02-Nov-17 12:05
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 713 Thanos5150 02-Nov-17 16:25
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 806 Thanos5150 02-Nov-17 16:43
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 714 Broker 03-Nov-17 03:44
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 699 Thanos5150 03-Nov-17 03:55
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 697 Broker 03-Nov-17 04:32
Re: Was Egyptian Thoth the Great Weaver? 748 Broker 03-Nov-17 04:36
Why is it important? 788 MDaines 04-Nov-17 10:57
Perhaps it was Isis! 973 Eddie Larry 04-Nov-17 15:59
Re: Perhaps it was Isis! 688 MDaines 05-Nov-17 17:57
Re: Perhaps it was Isis! 818 Eddie Larry 05-Nov-17 18:17


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.