Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
If you remove the possibility of stone softening and gravity manipulation, and try to evaluate the capabilities of ancient Egyptians' ability to invent methods of construction using any means of levers, rollers, or any mechanical advantages possible within the know realm of physics as understood today, I'm quite certain we have sufficient evidence to prove that contemporary man has a vast advantage in solving any and all of those challenges in comparison.

Mechanical advantage and physics of this type is covered in first year Statics. Its considered the easiest of all area's of physics. Its a stepping stone to dynamics, flow vectors, fluid dynamics, optics, and a vast many other subjects who's material is far more abstract. If you compare the best of the best in terms of minds of present man and ancient Egyptians, even if you allow for them to be identical in their brain capacity and intelligence in visual spatial comprehension, its an unfair comparison.

To be able to develop a sense and an instinct in this field to the point where you can extrapolate brilliant concepts of mechanical advantage, you need to have the ability to observe as many scenarios as possible. With present day computer modeling where you can input any scenario of force, angle, friction, dynamic, mass, gravity, etc, even to the extent of complicated interconnected complex truss systems and analysis of any point in the structure, present day man has the ability to develop a vastly superior comprehension and intuitive sense of this kind of stuff compared to ancient Egyption man. That is presuming they lacked computers, monitors, or any kind of dynamic visualization simulators 4500 years ago.

You might think that over time and with generations of practice, unique methods evolved and were passed along and improved to a point of extremely high level effectiveness. And you might also construct a hypothetical that presumes ancient Egyptians focus remained mostly in the realm of stone structure without the distraction of evolved advancement of any other area's as a result of this odd myopic focus. But even then, if you were to graph the gains in technology to time in this area, it would be a rather steep curve who's gains would be negligible relatively soon, just as it has been for our contemporary gains, with the exception of a slight blip after advancements in computer modeling.

The ancient discovery of a specialized lubricant who's properties are perfectly matched to the friction, viscosity, and heat requirements of one particular application may have taken generations to develope, but today, a 1st year student can model a variety of friction variables, book a meeting with a material science professor that next day and solve that same problem.

Bottom line... if stinky footed bumpkins constructed pyramids with no help from any advanced civilizations, we would have solved how they did THAT hundreds of years ago and quite easily. Rest assured.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 22-Sep-16 16:15 by Open mind.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Lost Building Technology 1471 Steve Clayton 21-Sep-16 16:47
Re: Lost Building Technology 451 cladking 21-Sep-16 16:59
Re: Lost Building Technology 455 Steve Clayton 21-Sep-16 17:22
Re: Lost Building Technology 443 cladking 21-Sep-16 18:05
Re: Lost Building Technology 531 Steve Clayton 21-Sep-16 21:19
Re: Lost Building Technology 481 D-Archer 22-Sep-16 10:18
Re: Lost Building Technology 465 Steve Clayton 22-Sep-16 13:33
Re: Lost Building Technology 391 D-Archer 23-Sep-16 07:03
Re: Lost Building Technology 426 M. J. Thomas 22-Sep-16 14:11
Re: Lost Building Technology 391 Steve Clayton 22-Sep-16 14:33
Re: Lost Building Technology 417 M. J. Thomas 22-Sep-16 15:52
Re: Lost Building Technology 426 Steve Clayton 22-Sep-16 17:01
Re: Lost Building Technology 398 M. J. Thomas 22-Sep-16 23:22
Re: Lost Building Technology 443 Steve Clayton 23-Sep-16 10:17
Re: Lost Building Technology 343 M. J. Thomas 23-Sep-16 13:47
Re: Lost Building Technology 416 D-Archer 23-Sep-16 07:06
Re: Lost Building Technology 541 Open mind 22-Sep-16 15:29
Re: Lost Building Technology 361 Steve Clayton 22-Sep-16 17:26
Re: Lost Building Technology 432 cladking 22-Sep-16 19:29
Re: Lost Building Technology 416 Steve Clayton 22-Sep-16 23:23
Re: Lost Building Technology 432 cladking 23-Sep-16 01:11
Re: Lost Building Technology 448 OCaptain 23-Sep-16 12:11
Re: Lost Building Technology 372 Steve Clayton 23-Sep-16 12:49
Re: Lost Building Technology 436 cladking 23-Sep-16 14:27
Re: Lost Building Technology 430 Steve Clayton 23-Sep-16 14:41
Rediscovered Lost Building Technology we use today 661 Howard West 25-Sep-16 14:59
Re: Rediscovered Lost Building Technology we use today 403 Steve Clayton 25-Sep-16 15:37
Re: Rediscovered Lost Building Technology we use today 433 Howard West 25-Sep-16 16:32
Re: Rediscovered Lost Building Technology we use today 332 Steve Clayton 25-Sep-16 17:58
Re: Lost Building Technology 391 Harte 25-Sep-16 17:55
Re: Lost Building Technology 381 Steve Clayton 25-Sep-16 21:16
Re: Lost Building Technology 405 Howard West 25-Sep-16 22:35
Re: Lost Building Technology 442 Steve Clayton 26-Sep-16 00:39
Secret Solar Powered Lost Building Technology 781 Howard West 25-Sep-16 23:44
Re: Secret Solar Powered Lost Building Technology 329 Steve Clayton 26-Sep-16 15:06
Mod Note > Cut and Paste 437 Dr. Troglodyte 26-Sep-16 19:50
Re: Rope Lever 450 Steve Clayton 16-Oct-16 17:47
Re: Rope Lever 436 Dr. Troglodyte 16-Oct-16 18:13
What? 3 men to pull a 60 ton stone up G1's Grand Hall. 460 Steve Clayton 17-Oct-16 16:06
Re: Rope Lever 364 cladking 16-Oct-16 19:08


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.