Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Thanos5150 Wrote:
-------------------------------------------------------
> Sorry, I'm not sure what you are trying to say.
> The cartouche you show above is from the 19th
> Dynasty Abydos king list which all the pharaohs
> names prior to the 4th Dynasty are written in a
> cartouche.
> [url=https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abydos_King_Lis
> t]HERE.[/url]
>
> I think you got tricked by your List of Pharoahs
> wiki link.

Maybe! and I know you have precious time but I [u]doubt that you read (in scholarly manner)[/u] the article and the references ?

I am aware by your own acknowledgement that previously you have updated/contributed to wiki so maybe that is a project for you to look more thoroughly into?

You seem to get great pleasure from improving knowledge and searching for factual truth.

Your da man!

The mere appearance of a similiar cartouche in 19th D, in various contradictory lists, is clearly not definitive. There is lots of discussion of archaelogical finds mentioned which associate with the claim ( that nasty pesky Reisner amongst them ...ROFL! ;-) that supports the contention that it was 2nd dynasty.

>
> Have I proved my case?

What that I am a inarticulate , incoherent nutcase! Maybe!?

>
> So what are you trying to say my friend?

Are Senedj or Peribsen 2nd dynasty kings OR NOT?
Why would a 2nd dynasty king have a cartouche on deemed 2nd dynasty tombs?

And if nothing else.... at least you post interesting informative stuff, worthy of an attempt to repay by some attention and reply! ;-)

kind regards friend

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 5304 Thanos5150 07-Jun-16 01:34
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 794 Thanos5150 07-Jun-16 02:53
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 790 Warwick 07-Jun-16 15:44
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 736 Graham Chase 07-Jun-16 19:14
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 806 Thanos5150 07-Jun-16 21:04
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 668 Warwick 16-Jun-16 18:34
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 787 Thanos5150 16-Jun-16 20:52
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 723 charly 17-Jun-16 17:55
Re: Additional Thought regarding Abydos Royal Enclosures 1193 Thanos5150 17-Jun-16 21:36
Re: Decoration in pyramids and mastabas 817 charly 02-Jan-17 18:48
Re: Decoration in pyramids and mastabas 1492 Thanos5150 02-Jan-17 22:56
Re: Djoser Blue Faience Tiles 897 Thunderbird 03-Jan-17 01:53
Abydos Royal Enclosures possibly are cenotaphs 703 DScribr 16-Jun-16 00:46
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 708 Graham Chase 07-Jun-16 13:21
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 873 Thanos5150 07-Jun-16 21:47
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 741 Graham Chase 08-Jun-16 09:48
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 737 Thanos5150 08-Jun-16 16:01
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 780 Thunderbird 09-Jun-16 02:44
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 2124 Thanos5150 09-Jun-16 19:33
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 750 Thunderbird 09-Jun-16 22:41
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 721 loveritas 10-Jun-16 01:11
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 829 Thunderbird 10-Jun-16 02:14
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 933 Thanos5150 10-Jun-16 18:45
Re: Property marks 707 Thunderbird 10-Jun-16 21:22
Re: Property marks 807 Thanos5150 11-Jun-16 04:26
Re: ZAG SAKH ....Serekh? 864 Thunderbird 11-Jun-16 15:08
Re: ZAG SAKH ....Serekh? 1201 Thanos5150 11-Jun-16 19:59
Re: ZAG SAKH ....Serekh? 749 Thunderbird 11-Jun-16 20:25
Re: ZAG SAKH ....Serekh? 719 Thanos5150 11-Jun-16 20:46
Re: The Sickle 752 Thunderbird 11-Jun-16 21:21
Re: The Sickle 663 Eddie Larry 11-Jun-16 23:48
Re: The Sickle 693 Thunderbird 12-Jun-16 01:59
Re: The Sickle 694 Eddie Larry 12-Jun-16 02:04
Re: Khemitology 780 Thunderbird 12-Jun-16 15:05
Re: The Sickle 841 Thanos5150 12-Jun-16 03:30
Re: The Sickle 640 Eddie Larry 12-Jun-16 04:00
Re: The Sickle 676 Thanos5150 12-Jun-16 04:09
Re: The Sickle 622 Eddie Larry 12-Jun-16 04:16
Re: The Sickle 736 Thanos5150 12-Jun-16 05:07
Re: Ethnicity 993 Thanos5150 16-Jun-16 16:14
Senedj & Seth-Peribsen 757 Corpuscles 14-Jun-16 00:40
Re: Senedj & Seth-Peribsen 796 Thanos5150 14-Jun-16 01:14
Re: Senedj & Seth-Peribsen 717 Corpuscles 14-Jun-16 02:58
Re: Senedj & Seth-Peribsen 975 Thanos5150 14-Jun-16 04:59
Re: The Sickle 701 Warwick 16-Jun-16 19:26
Re: The Sickle 750 Thanos5150 12-Jun-16 01:20
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 698 Graham Chase 10-Jun-16 08:32
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 752 Eddie Larry 10-Jun-16 14:08
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 657 Warwick 12-Jun-16 17:32
Re: Dynasty 1 cut and dressed 638 Eddie Larry 12-Jun-16 20:35
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 615 Warwick 07-Jun-16 15:13
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 663 Thanos5150 07-Jun-16 20:19
Books 812 Warwick 07-Jun-16 20:36
Re: Books 678 Thanos5150 07-Jun-16 21:15
Re: Books 734 Warwick 07-Jun-16 21:23
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 789 Thunderbird 07-Jun-16 21:59
Re: Foreign Spiritual Influence 672 Thunderbird 07-Jun-16 22:54
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 656 Thanos5150 08-Jun-16 04:02
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 781 Thunderbird 08-Jun-16 06:48
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 671 Audrey 08-Jun-16 16:37
Re: Ancient Symbols 851 Thunderbird 08-Jun-16 17:21
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 779 Thanos5150 08-Jun-16 17:30
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 721 Thunderbird 08-Jun-16 21:38
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 762 DScribr 16-Jun-16 01:01
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 668 Thanos5150 16-Jun-16 17:21
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 674 DScribr 17-Jun-16 00:58
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 677 Thanos5150 17-Jun-16 03:10
Re: Troubles with the 2nd Dynasty. 671 DScribr 17-Jun-16 17:45


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.