Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Merrel

Just a point on this line, "Pinchbeck not only ignores recognized Maya scholars, but repeatedly implies that there is validity to remarks by authors such as Hancock, Arguelles, Calleman, and Jenkins. He also relies upon a trademark literary device of pseudoscientists: The provocative question. An example (p. 245) is his use and followup of a quote from Jenkins:

"'We may propose a complex Maya science of shamanically invoking a 'wormhole' in local space-time, an opening to the transdimensional realm that ultimately gets its power from the Black Hole within the Galactic Center, and traveling through it to other worlds,' Jenkins notes, 'Is such a scenario just a fanciful fairy tale, or could it have involved the actual activities of Maya kings and shamans?' And if they practiced such techniques, can they be relearned by us?""

In my readings of Jenkins work, I come away feeling that JMJ was very careful to temper such speculation. There is no problem with suggesting such possibilities, so long as the delivery is measured. That was one of JMJ's trademark signatures. He was very careful to separate himself from the Partay 2012 crowd, and all of the insinuations that the world was going to end on December 21, 2012 or anything of such drama, for that matter. Not sure why the author includes Hancock in this, I certainly wouldn't lump JMJ in a group that includes Arguelles and Calleman.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 694 Graham Hancock 05-Sep-19 14:24
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 87 greengirl5 06-Sep-19 04:25
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 100 Merrell 06-Sep-19 17:58
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 87 Poster Boy 06-Sep-19 18:17
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 71 DanielPinchbeck 06-Sep-19 21:46
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 87 greengirl5 06-Sep-19 22:20
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 61 DanielPinchbeck 06-Sep-19 21:22
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 62 greengirl5 06-Sep-19 22:16
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 62 DanielPinchbeck 09-Sep-19 11:45
Re: Welcome to Daniel Pinchbeck our Author of the Month for September 2019 78 greengirl5 09-Sep-19 21:59
Thanks, Daniel 39 drrayeye 01-Oct-19 05:39


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.