Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Quote

Quite a long reply indeed, Susan. I wasn't assuming anything in my question, I was just enquiring.
Yes, I understand that, but in fact the very fact that you talk of a shamanic experience indicates that you believe there is such a thing, distinct from any other experience. Of course, different connotations are given to what is believed to be a shamanic experience rather than some other meditative or self-hypnotic or any other kind of experience the brain comes up with. If the person having the experience labels it a ‘shamanic experience’, then that person is consciously or subconsciously assuming much as well, because using the word shamanic implies having heard of it.And its associations.
Quote

You put this all down to imagination, as though that is somehow lesser that your experience of reality.
That is an incorrect interpretation of what I think and of what I have written. I would classify people’s descriptions and labels of their experiences under different headings, but at no time would I say that one experience is ‘lesser’ than another. Why should I? That is up to the person experiencing to decide.
How would you define what you call ‘my’ reality?!
Quote

How would you know which is more "real" if you haven't experienced both, and how do you know your world is the real one?
I could ask you the same question! I think I am on firmer ground here – if I researched an account of someone’s experience and found that it was well supported by objective evidence, then I would think it as different – but not lesser or more anything – from that totally lacking in independent verification.
Quote

A Shamanic experience would give you a wider view of the mysteries of existence.
How do you know? That is a huge assumption. What factors woulde need to be in place to classify it as a shamanic experience rather than any other kind of emotional, ecstatic, deeply joyful, deeply saddening, etc?
Quote

An experience that could only be guessed at otherwise.
And that applies to all experiences. Anyone who has not carried and had a baby can only guess at the actual feelings involved.
Quote

Without it all you can do is presume to know whats going on, with it you can actually know a little more than before, just like any new experience.
Exactly!!
Quote

I know you have trouble with your sight Susan, so this should resonate with you. Could you know, if you had been born blind and had never experienced it, what water is from a description. Would it really be adequate?
Yes. The only things that a totally blind from birth person could not actually experience are the colour and distance involved.
The same applies to sighted people – unless you have been to the Himalayas or the Antarctic, you can only imagine what it would be like in reality,.
Susan

Sorry - can't get rid of the x in Antarctic
18.1.19 Have now managed to edit that.



Edited 2 time(s). Last edit at 18-Jan-19 12:40 by Susan Doris.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 3131 Susan Doris 08-Jan-19 16:21
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 344 EvelynRysdyk 10-Jan-19 17:27
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 277 Susan Doris 10-Jan-19 19:45
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 277 cloister 10-Jan-19 20:11
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 258 Susan Doris 11-Jan-19 14:56
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 266 cloister 11-Jan-19 16:09
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 247 Susan Doris 11-Jan-19 19:35
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 260 cloister 11-Jan-19 19:56
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 277 EvelynRysdyk 11-Jan-19 00:40
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 289 greengirl5 11-Jan-19 08:59
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 265 Susan Doris 11-Jan-19 13:02
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 256 Susan Doris 11-Jan-19 13:27
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 273 EvelynRysdyk 11-Jan-19 20:33
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 233 Susan Doris 18-Jan-19 14:06
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 265 greengirl5 11-Jan-19 23:16
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 250 Susan Doris 12-Jan-19 06:15
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 245 greengirl5 12-Jan-19 12:24
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 254 Susan Doris 12-Jan-19 13:07
Please explain the word ASPECT in your quote. 244 Itatw70s 17-Jan-19 20:39
Re: Please explain the word ASPECT in your quote. 244 Susan Doris 18-Jan-19 14:48
Re: Please explain the word ASPECT in your quote. 228 Itatw70s 21-Jan-19 02:17
Re: Please explain the word ASPECT in your quote. 223 Susan Doris 21-Jan-19 06:26
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 256 Susan Doris 12-Jan-19 13:19
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 262 EvelynRysdyk 12-Jan-19 17:04
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 303 Susan Doris 12-Jan-19 18:36
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 244 Susan Doris 18-Jan-19 15:01
Red Herrings 250 drrayeye 17-Jan-19 19:05
Re: Red Herrings 253 Itatw70s 17-Jan-19 23:47
Re: Red Herrings 250 Susan Doris 18-Jan-19 09:00
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 246 Susan Doris 19-Jan-19 12:42
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 242 EvelynRysdyk 19-Jan-19 17:23
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 234 Susan Doris 20-Jan-19 10:27
Spirit 234 greengirl5 20-Jan-19 20:57
Re: Spirit 237 Susan Doris 21-Jan-19 07:11
Re: Spirit 223 greengirl5 21-Jan-19 11:31
Re: Spirit 228 Eddie Larry 21-Jan-19 16:32
Re: Spirit 226 Susan Doris 21-Jan-19 17:08
Re: Spirit 228 greengirl5 21-Jan-19 20:37
Re: Spirit 226 Susan Doris 22-Jan-19 06:24
Re: Spirit 224 greengirl5 22-Jan-19 07:23
Re: Spirit 221 Susan Doris 22-Jan-19 07:41
Re: Spirit 222 greengirl5 22-Jan-19 07:57
Re: Spirit 227 Susan Doris 22-Jan-19 08:19
Re: Spirit 224 greengirl5 22-Jan-19 09:47
Re: Spirit 233 Susan Doris 22-Jan-19 12:40
Re: Spirit 227 greengirl5 22-Jan-19 21:04
Re: Spirit 224 Susan Doris 23-Jan-19 10:25
Re: Spirit 440 greengirl5 23-Jan-19 12:10
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 245 Poster Boy 19-Jan-19 18:16
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 230 EvelynRysdyk 20-Jan-19 00:10
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 235 Poster Boy 20-Jan-19 00:39
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 231 Susan Doris 20-Jan-19 06:28
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 229 Susan Doris 20-Jan-19 06:19
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 232 greengirl5 20-Jan-19 09:31
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 232 Susan Doris 20-Jan-19 10:45
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 231 greengirl5 20-Jan-19 20:42
Re: the article by Evelyn rysdyk 235 Poster Boy 20-Jan-19 17:02
And the intellectual marathon continues, day after day, hour after hour, moment to moment.... 242 Itatw70s 22-Jan-19 02:04
Re: And the intellectual marathon continues, day after day, hour after hour, moment to moment.... 234 Susan Doris 22-Jan-19 06:08


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.