Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Edmond,

"I have demonstrated in 2014 that the two large panels named Newspaper Rock, on in Monticello, both contain the much more complex, universally standard, subconscious ‘grammar’ of the visual expression of culture."

Are you sure you are not having an axial grind by your superimposition of a constellation grid upon every conceivable cultural artifact? In doing so you are as much engaged in mythopoeia as I am, so please do not try to dress yourself in the scientist's garb.

The Scottish word for poet is makar, "maker," and thus we as contemporary humans indeed make meaning. Here is my take on the Seven Caves from my book [www.amazon.com]

[www.dropbox.com]
Historia Tolteca-Chichimeca, 16th century.

Chicomoztoc, the Nahua’s primordial Seven Caves (or perhaps a single, seven-lobed cave) inside the bent hill Colhua, contained the original eight tribes. At the center we see the Chichimeca leader in a colloquy with Huitzilopochtli. At the far end of the cavern is the glyph 1 Flint, which symbolizes the North but also refers specifically to 1168 AD, the date on which the tribes departed from Aztlán to journey to their ultimate home in the Valley of Mexico, arriving around 1248. On top of the cave are the native cacti of this arid region. Xolotl is the dog-headed deity of fire, lightning, the underworld, and death.

[www.dropbox.com]

[www.dropbox.com]
Detail of the lower portion of a painting from Historia Tolteca-Chichimeca.
Note the black beards of the two figures on the right talking (see “speech-scrolls”) with the Chichimeca on the left. Also on the right: a bow-and-arrow, a bag of water breaking open (birth?), and a sacred bundle made of jaguar skin, known as a tlquimilolli.

"He [by the way, Schaafsma is female] implies a culture is unique enough to be “almost totally lost.” I have found that culture is self-sustaining, self-mutating, and never lost. Thus it is never “re-discovered”, but perpetually re-expressed." In the quarter century I have live in Arizona I have seen a great loss of the Hopi culture, both in ceremonial detail and legends. The heartbreak of this sort perhaps you have not seen there, but I would guess that the Khoisan at Platfontein is undergoing a similar degenerative process.

"Your source, and you, firmly believe that “the sacred dimension and certain related practices of the prehistoric period" were different at other times, and in other places." Of course they were different. E.g. the katsina cult did not take hold in the Southwest until the end of the 13th century AD. Before that other sacred dimensions were in play.

"Genetic culture’ is a common or garden belief formalised by Nazi Germany, colonial powers, and other oppressors. It is no longer articulated in anthropology, but remains part of the paradigm of the humanities."

Let's talk commonsense. Various cultural groups, or tribes, carrying specific mitochrondrial and Y-chromosome characteristics bring with them discrete cultures, which, as you say, they either impose on the conquered or they are assimilated by the conquered. (The latter, "going native.") The degree to which cultural influence works both ways cannot be determined. Historic cultural diffusion can BE MAPPED by the geographic spread of specific genetic makeups. For instance: [natgeoeducationblog.files.wordpress.com]



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 24-Apr-18 23:26 by gadavid.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 2672 gadavid 10-Apr-18 22:17
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 557 Edmond 14-Apr-18 09:47
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 504 gadavid 15-Apr-18 20:23
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 543 Edmond 16-Apr-18 12:53
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 501 gadavid 17-Apr-18 19:26
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 487 gadavid 17-Apr-18 23:34
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 498 Edmond 18-Apr-18 10:00
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 485 gadavid 18-Apr-18 22:18
Being hard wired 484 drrayeye 19-Apr-18 06:24
Re: Being hard wired 488 Edmond 19-Apr-18 08:54
Re: Being hard wired 461 Aine 19-Apr-18 12:34
The scientific literature 501 drrayeye 19-Apr-18 13:26
Re: Being hard wired 511 gadavid 19-Apr-18 22:54
Re: Being hard wired 478 gadavid 19-Apr-18 23:18
Re: Being hard wired 499 Edmond 20-Apr-18 07:32
If you want tobe taken seriously by scientists 490 drrayeye 20-Apr-18 15:22
Re: Being hard wired 470 Eddie Larry 20-Apr-18 16:58
Re: Being hard wired 473 gadavid 21-Apr-18 05:08
Re: Being hard wired 474 Edmond 21-Apr-18 14:53
Re: Being hard wired 458 Eddie Larry 21-Apr-18 17:27
Re: Being hard wired 455 gadavid 22-Apr-18 21:52
Re: Being hard wired 502 gadavid 22-Apr-18 22:01
Re: Being hard wired 471 Edmond 23-Apr-18 09:29
Re: Being hard wired 495 gadavid 23-Apr-18 22:21
Re: Being hard wired 452 Edmond 24-Apr-18 10:30
Re: Being hard wired 506 gadavid 24-Apr-18 23:23
Re: Being hard wired 545 Edmond 25-Apr-18 09:21
Re: Being a hard wired pain 473 MDaines 25-Apr-18 10:57
Re: Being hard wired 753 gadavid 25-Apr-18 19:38
Re: Being hard wired 485 Eddie Larry 19-Apr-18 18:31
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 535 PB Bytes 14-Apr-18 16:56
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 490 gadavid 16-Apr-18 00:15
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 516 drrayeye 17-Apr-18 21:56
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 473 gadavid 17-Apr-18 23:19
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 500 drrayeye 18-Apr-18 08:09
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 480 gadavid 18-Apr-18 22:30
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 477 drrayeye 19-Apr-18 05:26
To disprove a theory, all that is needed is a single true counter factual 460 Race Jackson 24-Apr-18 00:06
Re: To disprove a theory, all that is needed is a single true counter factual 463 Edmond 24-Apr-18 10:39


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.