Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Gary, if only “traits and disorders” go with genetic material, then culture is not genetic. Thus you have to separate migration from culture.
If Egyptians gave “symbology” to San then pity the poor backwaters that head office did not get around to.
I have read one of your books, and it did not define cultural diffusion in terms of who spread what recurrent behaviours, to where, when, why, and how.
Please explain why there are about sixteen kivas on Gobekli Tepe hill, including under-floor features, benches, iconography, very similar to Hopi kivas?
Abstracts are as natural as number and basic geometrics and species. No trance needed. Shapes do not diffuse, they are innate. A circle with a cross does not mean “street, town intersection' in Egyptian, nor San or Khoe or Indian iconography. Barry Fell again?

Dr Ray Eye, linguists are also in two camps. The innate school has a lot of evidence and a good theoretical model. “Chomsky's transformational grammar works so well because it creates [no, identifies] on organizational structure that ignores semantic structure (meaning).”
Yes, since the final layer of allocation is optional (not entirely, see Blasi et al). The structural layers are compulsory.
“How we obtain meaning from the world is not understood very well.”
Meaning is inherent in the world and in us. We arrogate several conscious roles. See my paper on semiotics in Expression.
“...understanding in very different directions as we develop.”? But Eskimos and Australians understand the same things.
“By the time a child is 5 years old (or so), he has differentiated sufficiently to belong to a culture which will be somewhat unique.”
So culture is all nurture, not nature? And yes local versions are only somewhat unique; in stylisation. Revlon BC 70 000 is an ochre stick, and abalone shell with a mixture of seal fat and ochre powder, and stirring or application stick, in Blombos shelter. With needles and beads. If it's human, it is not unique.
“So being hard-wired may not be that big a deal.”
I have found compulsive subconscious expression of natural structure in art and building sites, to contain about 100 options, in five distinct layers, of which about 60% of very specific options are always expressed, and always in very specific positions. Always.
This model explains and predicts artworks (see my paper about a recently found ice Age engraving at Berriruata in Spain, in the anthropology journal Expression), at the rate of about 60 features in each and every Ice Age cave artwork;
[mindprintart.wordpress.com]
and Gobekli Tepe artworks;
[stoneprintjournal.blog]
and miniature artworks;
[stoneprintjournal.wordpress.com]
Structuralist analysis of the Minoan Pylos Combat agate jewel miniature, incidentally responds to Mathison's article, which follows the same old common or garden or silent (unarticulated) arrogant conscious 'evolutionary' paradigm of diffusion.
If you want to study culture instead of migration, then isolating hard-wired aspects of behaviour, such as elements in art, myth, ritual, language and perception, is a big deal.



Edited 5 time(s). Last edit at 19-Apr-18 09:12 by Edmond.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 2465 gadavid 10-Apr-18 22:17
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 499 Edmond 14-Apr-18 09:47
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 455 gadavid 15-Apr-18 20:23
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 491 Edmond 16-Apr-18 12:53
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 451 gadavid 17-Apr-18 19:26
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 439 gadavid 17-Apr-18 23:34
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 447 Edmond 18-Apr-18 10:00
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 438 gadavid 18-Apr-18 22:18
Being hard wired 430 drrayeye 19-Apr-18 06:24
Re: Being hard wired 440 Edmond 19-Apr-18 08:54
Re: Being hard wired 415 Aine 19-Apr-18 12:34
The scientific literature 447 drrayeye 19-Apr-18 13:26
Re: Being hard wired 458 gadavid 19-Apr-18 22:54
Re: Being hard wired 427 gadavid 19-Apr-18 23:18
Re: Being hard wired 449 Edmond 20-Apr-18 07:32
If you want tobe taken seriously by scientists 438 drrayeye 20-Apr-18 15:22
Re: Being hard wired 422 Eddie Larry 20-Apr-18 16:58
Re: Being hard wired 422 gadavid 21-Apr-18 05:08
Re: Being hard wired 417 Edmond 21-Apr-18 14:53
Re: Being hard wired 411 Eddie Larry 21-Apr-18 17:27
Re: Being hard wired 401 gadavid 22-Apr-18 21:52
Re: Being hard wired 448 gadavid 22-Apr-18 22:01
Re: Being hard wired 414 Edmond 23-Apr-18 09:29
Re: Being hard wired 442 gadavid 23-Apr-18 22:21
Re: Being hard wired 399 Edmond 24-Apr-18 10:30
Re: Being hard wired 453 gadavid 24-Apr-18 23:23
Re: Being hard wired 494 Edmond 25-Apr-18 09:21
Re: Being a hard wired pain 421 MDaines 25-Apr-18 10:57
Re: Being hard wired 666 gadavid 25-Apr-18 19:38
Re: Being hard wired 439 Eddie Larry 19-Apr-18 18:31
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 486 Poster Boy 14-Apr-18 16:56
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 441 gadavid 16-Apr-18 00:15
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 466 drrayeye 17-Apr-18 21:56
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 423 gadavid 17-Apr-18 23:19
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 449 drrayeye 18-Apr-18 08:09
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 431 gadavid 18-Apr-18 22:30
Re: Cultural Diffusionism vs. Cultural Isolationism 429 drrayeye 19-Apr-18 05:26
To disprove a theory, all that is needed is a single true counter factual 406 Race Jackson 24-Apr-18 00:06
Re: To disprove a theory, all that is needed is a single true counter factual 416 Edmond 24-Apr-18 10:39


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.