Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Aine wrote:

> Bipedalism may well be a purely physiological mechanism. But
> what about language? IMO that's as instinctive as walking
> upright and may well date back just as long. (I have a really
> hard time believing no one spoke until 40,000 years ago. To me,
> the whole idea is ludicrous.)

I agree. It is pretty clear that vocal communication is not even restricted to humans though humans have evolved the brain capacity to take vocalization to the next level of abstraction and symbolization.

Imo, language is the merely the most sophisticated manifestation of communication used by many animals and most assuredly by our ancient ancestors.

Funny, my son's family used to have a little Maltese terrier/poodle cross with a real attitude. Once in a while he would get under foot and you would accidentally step on his paw.

He would respond with a pissed off sounding, sentence-length, "grww-arr-gruff-grrrror.........

You knew exactly what he was saying, lol. "Watch out where you're going you big, fat oaf...."

Or something to that effect.



"with the right kind of eyes you can almost see the high-water mark - that place where the wave finally broke and rolled back"

~Hunter S. Thompson

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 266 drrayeye 14-Nov-13 15:59
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 163 brucenyc1 14-Nov-13 17:13
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 132 drrayeye 14-Nov-13 17:26
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 174 brucenyc1 14-Nov-13 18:58
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 138 drrayeye 14-Nov-13 21:11
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 163 Aine 14-Nov-13 19:45
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 177 drrayeye 14-Nov-13 21:25
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 182 Aine 15-Nov-13 13:43
Science vs. wissenschaft 253 drrayeye 16-Nov-13 08:15
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 126 Eddie Larry 15-Nov-13 03:06
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 103 drrayeye 15-Nov-13 06:34
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 148 Eddie Larry 16-Nov-13 00:22
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 179 Titus Livius 16-Nov-13 18:02
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 152 drrayeye 17-Nov-13 01:06
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 146 eyeofhorus33 16-Nov-13 18:34
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 153 drrayeye 17-Nov-13 01:11
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 128 cladking 17-Nov-13 03:11
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 180 Sirius7237 18-Nov-13 04:26
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 198 Don Carroll 18-Nov-13 20:11
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 132 Sirius7237 18-Nov-13 22:34
Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 204 Dr. Lew Graham 19-Nov-13 03:44
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 121 Sirius7237 19-Nov-13 07:52
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 157 Aine 19-Nov-13 13:54
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 170 carolb 19-Nov-13 14:17
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 197 Aine 19-Nov-13 14:48
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 173 JonnyMcA 19-Nov-13 15:11
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 167 Sirius7237 19-Nov-13 16:54
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 134 Aine 19-Nov-13 17:37
Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 117 Sirius7237 20-Nov-13 03:15
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 178 Aine 20-Nov-13 18:28
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 159 Don Carroll 20-Nov-13 21:25
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 155 Sirfiroth 21-Nov-13 00:58
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 175 Don Carroll 22-Nov-13 22:33
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 183 cladking 23-Nov-13 01:11
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 146 Don Carroll 23-Nov-13 01:46
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 109 Sirius7237 21-Nov-13 18:50
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 232 Don Carroll 23-Nov-13 00:15
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 193 Sirius7237 21-Nov-13 05:48
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 164 Aine 22-Nov-13 14:20
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 162 Sirius7237 22-Nov-13 18:56
Re: Quantum evolution of entangled particles in neural nets and consciousness! 161 Aine 03-Dec-13 14:15
Great Australian News Link! 162 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Dec-13 07:03
Re: Great Australian News Link! 144 Aine 04-Dec-13 12:38
Re: Great Australian News Link! 123 Sirius7237 04-Dec-13 20:45
Re: Great Australian News Link! 158 Aine 05-Dec-13 12:45
Re: Great Australian News Link! 151 Sirius7237 05-Dec-13 17:53
Re: Great Australian News Link! 157 Aine 06-Dec-13 15:12
A "Mechanism"? 186 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Dec-13 22:01
Re: A "Mechanism"? 158 Aine 05-Dec-13 12:46
Re: Separated electron pairs remain "connected" with respect to opposite polarity 156 D-Archer 24-Nov-13 10:49
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 169 D-Archer 24-Nov-13 10:44
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 172 Eddie Larry 24-Nov-13 15:03
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 132 cladking 24-Nov-13 16:13
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 174 laughin 08-Dec-13 16:34
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 141 David Campbell 09-Dec-13 22:15
Re: Can one be both a scientist and a spiritualist? 145 cladking 10-Dec-13 03:21


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.