Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Aloha Robert,

Kristin's comment was prescient, yet again.

And I would trace the original roots of the Western mental construct of presumed 'reality' back to Ptolemy, the Roman born in Egypt nearly 2000 years ago. His followers gave ever-more-complicated explanations for new observations while clinging to their core assumption that Earth was the center of the entire universe. Their 'reality' was based upon Ptolemy's ‘scientific’ view of the cosmos—published around 150 CE.

It is apparent that ancient wisdom was already lost, or had gone deeply underground, by that point. And the Egyptians' Royal Library of Alexandria may well have been largely destroyed by fire before Ptolemy’s life even began. In that context, the articulate scholar created his model of an Earth-centered universe. It became a core Christian dogma to which the Church would cling tenaciously for more than a millennium.

In one sense, though, Ptolemy was a forerunner of some modern scientists. He insisted that observation was paramount. Yet he started with a mental theory of the cosmos to which he and his followers then fitted their ongoing observations. A medieval woodcut printing that displayed their strange ideas appears below.



Each new Ptolemaic interpretation was based on a mental assumption that had been flawed from the start. The theory grew more complex over time, but it was enforced by central authorities for 1,500+ years.

Ptolemy also argued for adopting an artificial musical scale. It was based on a monochord that was multiplied or divided by two to create octaves along with filler notes, known as tetrachords. But apparently, all this was rooted arbitrarily in Ptolemy’s personal preference for the use of certain standardized numbers to produce orderly sound. And he dismissed the mystical scale that Pythagoras had propounded, which was the basis of the Music of the Spheres and had come from mathematical patterns in creation (as well as ancient knowledge of the Earth and solar system).

Eventually, the long-term result was the diatonic scale of musical chords we have today. It is a product of the intellectual mind, with no basis in sacred numbers or natural patterns.

Lew



Dr. Lew Graham

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Welcome to Robert Tindall Author of the Month for October 2013 377 Graham Hancock 01-Oct-13 04:34
Re: Welcome to Robert Tindall Author of the Month for October 2013 81 Robert Tindall 01-Oct-13 06:12
Re: Welcome to Robert Tindall Author of the Month for October 2013 121 spitfire888 01-Oct-13 06:52
Re: Welcome to Robert Tindall Author of the Month for October 2013 81 Robert Tindall 02-Oct-13 22:35
A Distasteful Topic 180 Dr. Lew Graham 31-Oct-13 22:09
Re: A Distasteful Topic 128 Robert Tindall 31-Oct-13 22:45
Crossing the Indigo Bridge 198 Dr. Lew Graham 31-Oct-13 22:52
Re: Crossing the Indigo Bridge 141 Robert Tindall 31-Oct-13 22:59
Roaming the Mind Blog 150 Dr. Lew Graham 01-Nov-13 02:56
a constant parallel universe 131 michael seabrook 02-Oct-13 22:16
Re: a constant parallel universe 110 Robert Tindall 02-Oct-13 22:31
Great summary of living universe perceptions 176 Dr. Lew Graham 02-Oct-13 23:05
Re: Great summary of living universe perceptions 123 Robert Tindall 02-Oct-13 23:18
Re: a constant parallel universe 121 Aine 03-Oct-13 13:15
Re: a constant parallel universe 137 Robert Tindall 03-Oct-13 15:47
Modern Western "Reality" as a Recent Construct 174 Dr. Lew Graham 03-Oct-13 22:42
Re: Modern Western "Reality" as a Recent Construct 109 Aine 04-Oct-13 13:51
Music 221 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Oct-13 18:06
More on the Sound of Music 183 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Oct-13 21:47
Re: a constant parallel universe 124 Aine 04-Oct-13 13:53
Re: a constant parallel universe 128 blackbeer 30-Oct-13 16:56
Re: a constant parallel universe 128 Robert Tindall 30-Oct-13 17:11
Re: a constant parallel universe 110 blackbeer 30-Oct-13 17:23
Re: a constant parallel universe 113 michael seabrook 03-Oct-13 21:27
Regarding the non-physical realms 137 David L 04-Oct-13 17:34


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.