Author of the Month :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
Join us at this forum every month for a discussion with famous popular authors from around the world. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Dear Woodward and Bernstein,

Sorry to intrude on your high-five's and back-slapping over ad hominem mistakes known in formal logic as fallacies of relevance.

You two are carrying on a despicable tradition of attacking Glenn Kimball’s credentials and scholarly research findings by falsely impugning him as a fraud. This effort was initially launched by orthodox critics who clung to mainstream ideas that Glenn challenged with prodigious research. They were quoted by others to the point that it created a faux groundswell of apparently universal derision. The small-minded mainstreamers even worked to delete his Wikipedia contributions, viz., [en.wikipedia.org]. Shades of TED!

I knew Glenn and knew how much such below-the-belt, small-minded stuff stunned and hurt him initially. And he eventually got over it.

Glenn Kimball eventually earned his Ph.D. from Southern Illinois University (after “finishing “ the dissertation for years). He delayed submission of his dissertation after completing formal classwork in the late 1970s or early 1980s when he taught as a graduate student TA for several years. This was because he unexpectedly became a single father of 3 kids when his dissertation was mostly done. He passionately took on the moral role of father -- always putting it as top priority with dissertation completion coming a distant second.

Glenn was also hampered progressively by health challenges. In 1985 he was diagnosed (at age 35) with a fatal organ disease and given 5 years “tops” to live — until 1990. The headlights of death switched to high-beam and began to shine brightly over his shoulder.

Glenn was panicked in that he felt an overwhelming sense of his “life mission” being incomplete. So he again made the dissertation lower priority as he frantically threw himself into his work. It became a virtual compulsion. Time seemed so short with so many 'rocks' to look under. Each one led to others.

Unexpectedly, Glenn lived 20 years beyond the death sentence date. At he urging of friends, he submitted a written dissertation to Southern Illinois University in the 1990s. It summarized his years of findings well but was logged in as received long after his faculty advisor and dissertation committee members had moved on. The University hemmed and hawed but ultimately made the compromise decision to recognize Glenn as having earned a doctoral degree in “Communications”—a Ph.D. program that did not even exist at the school. This had happened by 1999 when the Art Bell interview occurred. And SIU had promised in writing that the formality of degree “awarding” would occur at a to-be-determined future commencement. Yet there was a serious academic snag between the interviews with Art Bell and the one years later with Ian Punnett.

Apparently, some faculty infighting occurred after Glenn's appearances on the Art Bell show. And SIU informed Glenn that, although he had "fully earned" the Ph.D., some faculty had "voiced reasonable concerns" that formally awarding the degree might imply that he was proficient with respect to "current instructional standards". Simply auditing three years of coursework anew would be sufficient to "allay" those professors' objections. Glenn appropriately resisted this alteration of standards and SIU dug in its heels. (My suggestion was that he simply repeat science-related courses as these would be the only instructional content that would likely have changed. But I don't know if he ever did.) After a long delay and many communications, SIU dug in its heels even more -- insisting that Glenn re-take every single graduate course, at considerable expense, and pass all class exams once again.

Although SIU had verified in writing that Glenn's Ph.D. had been fully earned and his dissertation accepted, its formal awarding was a joke due IMO to the small-minded reactions of some envious faculty members who resented the Glenn's public profile. I believe Glenn's response was 'so what if I die --any month now-- having been formally awarded only a masters degree. What is important is the inspired and inspiring life's work that I've contributed.'

For my part, I took SIU at its written word and have always referred to Glenn as Dr. Kimball. But he was mortified by the university's game-playing and took care to explain thereafter that his Ph.D remained unfinished due to the need to repeat all graduate courses. I had no contact with him after 2008, when his life's work was done but his health was severely deteriorating. I learned that he finally died at 60 years of age in 2010 -- 20 years beyond his predicted demise in 1990 "at the outside".

Neither of you have has bothered to read Glenn’s work. You’ve focussed mainly on extraneous issues (e.g., typo’s) or ad hominem canards. And you have clearly demonstrated the dangers of superficial Internet research.

By the way, one of Glenn’s interviews was the most highly rated show in the entire history of the Art Bell radio program.

Lew



Dr. Lew Graham

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
The Creation Of Man 598 DrRita 28-Aug-13 13:00
Re: The Creation Of Man 222 Eddie Larry 28-Aug-13 23:52
Re: The Creation Of Man 291 Naveen 29-Aug-13 22:20
Re: The Creation Of Man 280 Dr. Lew Graham 29-Aug-13 23:13
Re: The Creation Of Man 303 Eddie Larry 30-Aug-13 03:25
Re: The Creation Of Man 308 Dr. Lew Graham 30-Aug-13 03:49
Re: The Creation Of Man 178 Eddie Larry 30-Aug-13 04:07
Re: The Creation Of Man 245 DrRita 31-Aug-13 13:20
Re: The Creation Of Man 267 Eddie Larry 31-Aug-13 14:10
Re: The Creation Of Man 130 MJT 01-Sep-13 23:31
96% is Dark Matter and Dark Energy 291 Dr. Lew Graham 02-Sep-13 05:04
Re: 96% is Dark Matter and Dark Energy 294 MJT 02-Sep-13 11:34
NASA Link 89 Dr. Lew Graham 02-Sep-13 23:38
Re: The Creation Of Man 356 michael seabrook 29-Aug-13 09:36
Re: The Creation Of Man 264 DrRita 29-Aug-13 13:14
My take 263 David L 29-Aug-13 23:20
Re: My take 178 DrRita 30-Aug-13 13:06
Re: My take 214 David L 30-Aug-13 19:01
Re: My take 255 DrRita 31-Aug-13 13:25
Re: My take 240 David L 31-Aug-13 21:24
My own take 161 Dr. Lew Graham 01-Sep-13 02:36
Re: My own take 218 David L 01-Sep-13 17:29
Believe What You Wish 321 Dr. Lew Graham 02-Sep-13 05:57
Re: Believe What You Wish 233 carolb 02-Sep-13 19:30
People's Prevailing, Common Beliefs 248 Dr. Lew Graham 03-Sep-13 00:15
Re: People's Prevailing, Common Beliefs 214 carolb 03-Sep-13 02:14
Summarizing 40+ Years of Wide-Ranging Research 244 Dr. Lew Graham 03-Sep-13 04:03
Re: Summarizing 40+ Years of Wide-Ranging Research 209 carolb 03-Sep-13 14:51
What? 210 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Sep-13 00:19
Re: What? 252 carolb 04-Sep-13 00:42
Clarity 251 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Sep-13 02:17
Re: Clarity 236 carolb 04-Sep-13 02:47
Reasonableness 298 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Sep-13 03:25
Re: Reasonableness 242 carolb 04-Sep-13 03:35
More of the Same 234 Dr. Lew Graham 04-Sep-13 03:59
Re: More of the Same 243 carolb 04-Sep-13 15:34
Research 241 Dr. Lew Graham 05-Sep-13 23:44
Re: Research 166 carolb 06-Sep-13 01:02
Thanks for Your Time 239 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 01:26
Re: Research 261 Sirius7237 08-Sep-13 21:54
Re: Research 152 carolb 09-Sep-13 01:26
Re: Research 245 Audrey 10-Sep-13 05:55
Re: Research 263 carolb 10-Sep-13 13:09
What Insult? 227 Dr. Lew Graham 10-Sep-13 20:03
I Apologize Unconditionally 269 Dr. Lew Graham 10-Sep-13 22:16
Addendum 246 carolb 07-Sep-13 16:05
Whaaaaaaaaat? 296 PB Bytes 05-Sep-13 05:27
Turning to 'literature' then ... 284 PB Bytes 05-Sep-13 06:29
Re: Turning to 'literature' then ... 232 Dr. Lew Graham 05-Sep-13 23:23
Re: Turning to 'literature' then ... 233 Aine 05-Sep-13 23:34
Re: Turning to 'literature' then ... 254 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 00:00
Re: Turning to 'literature' then ... 214 DrRita 06-Sep-13 00:46
Re: Turning to 'literature' then ... 232 Aine 06-Sep-13 13:51
Re: People's Prevailing, Common Beliefs 243 David L 03-Sep-13 03:19
The Roman Empire's Plots 216 Dr. Lew Graham 03-Sep-13 03:59
Re: The Roman Empire's Plots 200 David L 03-Sep-13 16:29
Glenn Kimball, Ph.D. Has been Deceased Since 2010 147 Dr. Lew Graham 03-Sep-13 23:42
Kimball was a fraudster with NO PhD 215 eyeofhorus33 07-Sep-13 09:14
Re: Kimball was a fraudster with NO PhD 232 carolb 07-Sep-13 18:54
Re: Kimball was a fraudster with NO PhD 283 eyeofhorus33 07-Sep-13 21:08
Re: Kimball was a fraudster with NO PhD 222 carolb 07-Sep-13 21:41
Re: Kimball was a fraudster with NO PhD 179 eyeofhorus33 07-Sep-13 21:44
Re: Kimball was a fraudster with NO PhD 523 carolb 07-Sep-13 22:17
Kimball on radio states he has no PhD 253 eyeofhorus33 07-Sep-13 21:58
This is Small-Minded Bollix 249 Dr. Lew Graham 09-Sep-13 01:03
Re: This is Small-Minded Bollix 275 Aine 09-Sep-13 15:15
Let me make sure I've got this straight 251 PB Bytes 09-Sep-13 18:06
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 301 eyeofhorus33 09-Sep-13 18:50
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 231 PB Bytes 09-Sep-13 19:01
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 275 cladking 10-Sep-13 00:28
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 303 carolb 10-Sep-13 01:09
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 197 cladking 10-Sep-13 01:20
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 237 DrRita 10-Sep-13 01:46
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 177 carolb 10-Sep-13 02:07
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 212 cladking 10-Sep-13 02:09
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 284 David Campbell 10-Sep-13 02:53
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 353 Aine 10-Sep-13 12:45
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 245 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 22:30
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 287 David Campbell 11-Sep-13 00:57
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 260 Aine 10-Sep-13 12:38
Glenn Kimball Told the Truth IMO 425 Dr. Lew Graham 10-Sep-13 20:48
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 247 Sirius7237 09-Sep-13 19:07
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 194 PB Bytes 09-Sep-13 19:28
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 219 Aine 09-Sep-13 19:37
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 285 David Campbell 09-Sep-13 21:55
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 236 Aine 10-Sep-13 12:42
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 206 David Campbell 10-Sep-13 17:21
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 291 Aine 10-Sep-13 18:56
Starchild . . . 227 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 19:20
Re: Starchild . . . 232 Aine 10-Sep-13 19:37
Re: Starchild . . . 306 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 19:44
Re: Starchild . . . 277 Aine 10-Sep-13 19:46
Re: Starchild . . . 273 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 20:00
Re: Starchild . . . 188 Aine 10-Sep-13 20:04
Re: Starchild . . . 233 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 20:13
Re: Starchild . . . 186 Aine 10-Sep-13 20:17
Re: Starchild . . . 210 David Campbell 10-Sep-13 22:03
Re: Starchild . . . 296 David Campbell 10-Sep-13 21:53
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 296 David Campbell 10-Sep-13 21:41
Re: Let me make sure I've got this straight 274 Aine 11-Sep-13 13:29
Coppens chimed in . . . 283 PB Bytes 09-Sep-13 21:16
Brian, see post below 202 PB Bytes 09-Sep-13 21:50
Re: Brian, see post below 270 Sirius7237 09-Sep-13 22:47
Re: This is Small-Minded Bollix 271 eyeofhorus33 09-Sep-13 19:17
Finding Justifications for One's Position 211 Dr. Lew Graham 10-Sep-13 02:37
Re: Finding Justifications for One's Position 193 Audrey 10-Sep-13 06:02
Re: Finding Justifications for One's Position 258 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 16:46
Re: Finding Justifications for One's Position 232 Aine 10-Sep-13 19:22
Re: Finding Justifications for One's Position 245 carolb 10-Sep-13 19:24
Baiting Dr. Lew Graham 278 PB Bytes 16-Sep-13 23:58
Re: Baiting Dr. Lew Graham 236 carolb 17-Sep-13 01:08
'One Star' realities 205 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 21:47
Why Can't He Spell? 185 loveritas 10-Sep-13 23:06
Re: Why Can't He Spell? 256 PB Bytes 10-Sep-13 23:25
Re: Why Can't He Spell? 310 loveritas 11-Sep-13 02:30
Re: Why Can't He Spell? 226 PB Bytes 11-Sep-13 02:43
Re: 'One Star' realities 214 Aine 11-Sep-13 13:26
Re: 'One Star' realities 258 PB Bytes 16-Sep-13 23:28
Re: 'One Star' realities 266 Aine 17-Sep-13 12:27
In conclusion then...? 225 PB Bytes 18-Sep-13 00:40
Re: In conclusion then...? 281 Aine 18-Sep-13 19:18
Re: In conclusion then...? 212 PB Bytes 19-Sep-13 00:50
Re: In conclusion then...? 182 Aine 25-Sep-13 00:51
Re: 'One Star' realities 256 John Cross 18-Sep-13 20:55
Re: Finding Justifications for One's Position 128 Aine 10-Sep-13 13:12
Embarrassment 316 Dr. Lew Graham 10-Sep-13 20:20
Re: Embarrassment 183 Aine 10-Sep-13 20:33
Complex Story 263 Dr. Lew Graham 10-Sep-13 21:15
Re: My take 236 rangaram 03-Sep-13 09:35
Re: My take 283 Aine 03-Sep-13 14:29
Re: My take 296 DrRita 03-Sep-13 15:29
Re: My take 215 Aine 03-Sep-13 15:40
Re: The Creation Of Man 222 MJT 01-Sep-13 23:43
Re: The Creation Of Man 230 DrRita 02-Sep-13 14:24
Re: The Creation Of Man 285 MJT 03-Sep-13 19:05
Re: The Creation Of Man 218 DrRita 04-Sep-13 14:34
Re: The Creation Of Man 235 MJT 04-Sep-13 20:20
Re: The Creation Of Man 221 DrRita 05-Sep-13 13:34
Re: The Creation Of Man 136 MJT 05-Sep-13 16:41
An Apology is in Order 244 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 01:15
Re: An Apology is in Order - oh no it isn't . . . 228 MJT 06-Sep-13 01:59
Re: An Apology is in Order 232 DrRita 06-Sep-13 02:34
Nasty is as Nasty Does, Forrest! 298 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 02:48
Re: Nasty is as Nasty Does, Forrest! 310 DrRita 06-Sep-13 02:52
Reminds Me of An Old Joke 246 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 03:20
Re: Reminds Me of An Old Joke 237 DrRita 06-Sep-13 03:39
Old Joke 240 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 03:51
Re: Nasty is as Nasty Does, Forrest! 198 MJT 06-Sep-13 08:53
Re: An Apology is in Order 252 MJT 06-Sep-13 08:46
Re: An Apology is in Order 268 DrRita 06-Sep-13 15:05
Re: An Apology is in Order - oh no it isn't . . . 237 MJT 06-Sep-13 16:31
Re: An Apology is in Order - oh no it isn't . . . 214 cladking 06-Sep-13 17:06
Re: An Apology is in Order - oh no it isn't . . . 235 MJT 06-Sep-13 20:05
Question for MJT 210 PB Bytes 06-Sep-13 18:13
Re: Unanswerable Question for MJT 184 MJT 06-Sep-13 20:12
Answer to Unanswerable Question for MJT 170 PB Bytes 06-Sep-13 21:26
Re: Answer to Unanswerable Question for MJT 265 MJT 06-Sep-13 22:19
Conclusion to Unanswerable Question for MJT 278 PB Bytes 06-Sep-13 22:32
Re: Conclusion to Unanswerable Question for MJT 145 MJT 07-Sep-13 06:21
Re: Conclusion to Unanswerable Question for MJT 276 PB Bytes 07-Sep-13 17:53
Re: Conclusion to Unanswerable Question for MJT 276 MJT 07-Sep-13 18:57
Re: The Creation Of Man 219 Aine 03-Sep-13 14:46
Re: The Creation Of Man 246 cladking 03-Sep-13 19:40
Re: The Creation Of Man 276 Aine 03-Sep-13 19:49
Re: The Creation Of Man 228 cladking 03-Sep-13 23:45
Re: The Creation Of Man 240 Aine 04-Sep-13 13:40
Re: The Creation Of Man 245 cladking 05-Sep-13 00:34
Re: The Creation Of Man 217 Aine 05-Sep-13 13:33
Re: The Creation Of Man 228 cladking 05-Sep-13 18:15
Re: The Creation Of Man 232 Aine 05-Sep-13 19:05
Re: The Creation Of Man 273 cladking 05-Sep-13 20:35
Re: The Creation Of Man 289 Aine 05-Sep-13 23:47
Re: The Creation Of Man 160 cladking 06-Sep-13 00:13
Re: The Creation Of Man 206 Aine 06-Sep-13 13:05
Re: The Creation Of Man 276 cladking 06-Sep-13 16:21
Re: The Creation Of Man 209 carolb 06-Sep-13 16:43
Re: The Creation Of Man 216 cladking 06-Sep-13 16:59
Re: The Creation Of Man 238 carolb 06-Sep-13 17:01
Re: The Creation Of Man 166 cladking 06-Sep-13 22:38
Re: The Creation Of Man 227 Aine 06-Sep-13 17:06
Re: The Creation Of Man 228 DrRita 06-Sep-13 22:13
Re: The Creation Of Man 237 carolb 06-Sep-13 22:20
Re: The Creation Of Man 197 cladking 06-Sep-13 22:52
Re: The Creation Of Man 278 carolb 06-Sep-13 23:01
Re: The Creation Of Man 244 DrRita 07-Sep-13 04:00
Thank you for the Links 246 Dr. Lew Graham 07-Sep-13 05:56
Re: Thank you for the Links 281 DrRita 07-Sep-13 13:14
Re: The Creation Of Man 169 carolb 07-Sep-13 15:26
Re: The Creation Of Man 198 carolb 07-Sep-13 16:10
Re: The Creation Of Man 256 DrRita 07-Sep-13 16:47
Re: The Creation Of Man 223 carolb 07-Sep-13 18:38
Re: The Creation Of Man 196 DrRita 07-Sep-13 19:32
Reptilians 232 David L 08-Sep-13 03:08
Re: The Creation Of Man 176 cladking 06-Sep-13 22:42
Is "Gravity" Real? 262 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 02:00
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 227 Aine 06-Sep-13 12:50
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 230 cladking 06-Sep-13 15:46
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 253 Aine 06-Sep-13 15:50
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 225 cladking 06-Sep-13 16:29
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 235 Aine 06-Sep-13 16:49
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 277 cladking 06-Sep-13 16:55
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 245 Aine 06-Sep-13 17:11
Re: Is "Gravity" Real? 246 cladking 06-Sep-13 22:08
The Concept of "Gravity" 265 Dr. Lew Graham 06-Sep-13 16:39
Re: The Concept of "Gravity" 218 Aine 06-Sep-13 16:45
Re: The Creation Of Man 283 carolb 03-Sep-13 21:31
Re: The Creation Of Man 216 cladking 03-Sep-13 23:55
Re: The Creation Of Man 311 MJT 04-Sep-13 01:36
Re: The Creation Of Man 276 cladking 05-Sep-13 00:49
Re: The Creation Of Man 233 carolb 05-Sep-13 02:53
Re: The Creation Of Man 165 Aine 05-Sep-13 13:34
Re: The Creation Of Man 225 DrRita 05-Sep-13 13:37
Re: The Creation Of Man 202 cladking 05-Sep-13 18:16
Re: The Creation Of Man 287 carolb 05-Sep-13 19:39
Re: The Creation Of Man 208 DrRita 05-Sep-13 23:51
Re: The Creation Of Man 277 carolb 06-Sep-13 01:13
Re: The Creation Of Man 280 John Cross 08-Sep-13 15:08
Re: The Creation Of Man 280 DrRita 08-Sep-13 19:18


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.