Paranormal & Supernatural :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions of everything that might be classed as ‘paranormal‘ - i.e. not currently accepted by our modern scientific paradigm. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Peter's problem is that he invokes an intellectual double standard. Here he SEEMS to be trying to ridicule we can explore inferences beyond what the most shallow arguments present. Rather than address that intelligently, he ducks the whole matter. I've seen that from him before, as I've seen it with other skeptics here. Not that the skeptics don't have good points, sometimes they do. But dumbed down comments like this bring nothing to the table, and in my opinion Petey really knows better.

He wrote a lovely piece to explain why it can be reasonably inferred that the pyramids were tombs for the pharoahs, when the evidence directly supporting this is so scant. In order to sustain his hypothesis, he has to ignore, completely, the fact that the GP was found to have a TOTALLY empty 'king's chamber' inside a pyramid that was sealed for millennia.

Peter did a very fine work showing how we can INFER, in spite of the outright lack of direct evidence, that the pyramids were used as tombs. My guess is that he does this for the sake of the politics surrounding the conversation, and that he doesn't want to risk being seen as sympathetic to those who might think other than the way he and his ortho gang does. If this is true, then I can only say 'too bad', because to my mind it would be so constricting having to look over your shoulder every time you are confronted with a new idea, to see if your equally insecure buddies might call you out, make fun of you, and so on.

So, in other words, this style of reasoning is, to Peter's mind, legitimate. Yet here he completely rejects that standard and tries to make fun of it when it comes to the serious research that is done on CCs, and what he **knows** is the flagrant poverty of the Doug and Dave boardstomping explanation.

Maybe I'm wrong, but I believe I detect peer pressure here. How safe it is to tow the party line when it comes to the absurd inferential assumptions regarding the pyramids in this case. Not saying the research isn't good, it seemed excellent, but when people are content to completely ignore glaring facts like the finding of an empty 'king's chamber', it does seem like something other than, and far less than, true intellectual rigor is in play.

Little wonder, if this is actually true, that somebody with as fine a discriminating mind as Peter's would duck this conversation entirely, totally overlooking the finer points of the discussion. How absurd that he uses precisely this line of thinking and presentation to support one position, the Egypt ortho one, while ridiculing it when it points in another direction. This is precisely the kind of paradoxical inconsistency one would expect from somebody playing a quiet game of politics, rather than the pursuit of truth, because in politics, shallowness and intellectual hypocrisy are fair game - as they are to the immature, that is, people who never really grow up.

Maybe I'm wrong here. I may well be. But I suspect he's part of some sort of Skeptic's Gang and is well enough aware that his peer group will follow his every word, and that that might have ramifications on his 'rep' in due course. It's all so middle school if you ask me. I can practically see the lot of them now, behind the school gym now, in their bomber jackets, plotting their next dastardly deed as they pose for the gals, trying to look cool..

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Why are most Crop Circles in England? 213 Deep1 02-Aug-09 08:51
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 149 SphinxGirl 02-Aug-09 12:13
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 107 Titus Livius 02-Aug-09 15:10
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 124 Jal Phoenix 02-Aug-09 16:16
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 130 gaylenb 02-Aug-09 16:21
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 114 K_Asp 02-Aug-09 17:20
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 132 Anomalies 03-Aug-09 14:45
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 134 equestrian 02-Aug-09 18:57
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 138 paxton 02-Aug-09 21:58
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 110 Jal Phoenix 03-Aug-09 05:32
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 145 paxton 03-Aug-09 08:46
I would say you haven't... 116 Anomalies 03-Aug-09 19:03
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 115 papalou 13-Aug-09 01:46
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 119 Richard Fusniak 13-Aug-09 13:33
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 137 R and M 13-Aug-09 13:55
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 130 Richard Fusniak 13-Aug-09 14:35
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 125 The Kwuda 13-Aug-09 14:44
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 104 R and M 14-Aug-09 03:30
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 99 papalou 15-Aug-09 19:00
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 141 Richard Fusniak 15-Aug-09 20:13
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 102 papalou 16-Aug-09 03:57
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 175 papalou 16-Aug-09 04:19
Moderator Caution 131 JonnyMcA 15-Aug-09 21:18
Re: Moderator Caution 120 papalou 16-Aug-09 03:59
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 123 Anomalies 17-Aug-09 17:43
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 138 Richard Fusniak 17-Aug-09 20:59
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 89 martinpescatore 13-Aug-09 07:07
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 154 papalou 15-Aug-09 19:05
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 120 Nebankh 03-Aug-09 00:12
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 139 R and M 03-Aug-09 04:31
WHAT? 124 Deep1 03-Aug-09 05:48
Re: WHAT? 130 R and M 04-Aug-09 04:31
Re: WHAT? 136 R and M 04-Aug-09 04:44
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 131 Me 04-Aug-09 01:23
Re: The Rense crop circle 120 Nebankh 04-Aug-09 01:29
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 116 equestrian 04-Aug-09 03:26
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 127 spitfire888 04-Aug-09 02:09
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 136 drone-note 04-Aug-09 14:52
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 109 Deep1 04-Aug-09 16:22
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 130 drone-note 04-Aug-09 16:39
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 138 dmatherly 04-Aug-09 18:09
They are all over the world 131 debraregypt 05-Aug-09 01:52
good point 139 equestrian 05-Aug-09 03:15
Re: good point 133 Anomalies 05-Aug-09 14:19
Re: They are all over the world 127 paxton 05-Aug-09 12:58
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 128 Pete Vanderzwet 05-Aug-09 07:15
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 113 R and M 05-Aug-09 10:02
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 135 Anomalies 05-Aug-09 14:07
sooo shallow 135 equestrian 05-Aug-09 15:51
Re: sooo shallow 140 Pete Vanderzwet 05-Aug-09 19:04
Re: sooo shallow 133 gaylenb 05-Aug-09 20:26
Yellow Card to Eq 101 equestrian 06-Aug-09 03:30
Re: Yellow Card to Eq 138 Pete Vanderzwet 06-Aug-09 08:07
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 131 poster72 05-Aug-09 16:31
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 130 equestrian 05-Aug-09 16:42
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 135 gaylenb 05-Aug-09 16:50
The Skeptic's Gang... 129 equestrian 05-Aug-09 17:18
For the Skeptic's Gang... 133 Anomalies 05-Aug-09 18:16
Re: For the Skeptic's Gang... 101 poster72 06-Aug-09 20:18
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 138 poster72 05-Aug-09 17:40
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 124 Anomalies 05-Aug-09 19:07
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 141 paxton 05-Aug-09 16:52
Like this,poster72? 126 hut 05-Aug-09 18:06
Re: Like this,poster72? 101 Pete Vanderzwet 05-Aug-09 19:59
Re: Like this,poster72? 105 gaylenb 05-Aug-09 20:30
Re: Like this,poster72? 109 Pete Vanderzwet 05-Aug-09 20:35
Re: Like this,poster72? 132 R and M 06-Aug-09 04:45
Re: Like this,poster72? 110 gaylenb 05-Aug-09 20:28
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 90 R and M 06-Aug-09 04:20
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 115 Anomalies 05-Aug-09 17:12
concentration 126 lukehancock 05-Aug-09 19:44
History 169 s-d.adrain 13-Aug-09 07:28
Interesting Youtube video on crop circles Milo and Deep1 133 spitfire888 13-Aug-09 07:13
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 141 iroquois warrior 15-Aug-09 21:41
A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 138 Deep1 17-Aug-09 18:20
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 125 paxton 17-Aug-09 19:27
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 122 Deep1 17-Aug-09 19:42
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 119 spitfire888 17-Aug-09 20:34
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 143 paxton 18-Aug-09 15:48
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 132 Richard Fusniak 18-Aug-09 16:53
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 141 paxton 18-Aug-09 19:43
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 114 Richard Fusniak 18-Aug-09 19:51
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 114 paxton 18-Aug-09 21:05
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 122 Richard Fusniak 18-Aug-09 22:19
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 140 paxton 18-Aug-09 23:18
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 132 Richard Fusniak 19-Aug-09 06:30
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 136 R and M 19-Aug-09 07:59
Re: A Rational, Bottom-Up Analysis 96 Richard Fusniak 19-Aug-09 08:59
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 129 spitfire888 16-Aug-09 19:31
Re: Why are most Crop Circles in England? 127 Anomalies 17-Aug-09 17:49


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.