Paranormal & Supernatural :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions of everything that might be classed as ‘paranormal‘ - i.e. not currently accepted by our modern scientific paradigm. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Okay. 'Poltergeist' is from the german and means 'knocking spirit'. Now, let's look at some different ways of thinking about this.

First, fraud. Many, if not most, cases of poltergeists are really fraudulent. Let us ignore those.

Assuming a "legitimate" case, parapsychology generally does not think a spirit is involved, but rather some form of emotional "effect", typically caused by a teenager. In this situation, the teenager is currently living there or in the vicinity. However, the actual physical cause of the effect is not explained, therefore disregarding it as being caused by a spirit seems to me to merely be because parapsychology just wants desperately to be considered a "real" science. So -- it is possible that a spirit would be responding to the emotional effects of the teenager in such a case.

Now assume a "legitimate" case, where there is no living person who might be the cause. Then in this case, a spirit is involved. (Again, assuming this is a non-fraudulent case, and is not due to other normal physical world manifestations, like bad wiring causing lights to flicker as the house shifts in the wind or expands/contracts due to air pressure, and so forth.)

There is no need for the spirit in such a case to be a ghost, however, and plenty of reason for it not to be.

Now I make a simple assertion - I cannot prove this statement: There are many categories and kinds spirit beings, and many of them are hostile to humans.

So - the poltergeist may be a non-ghost spirit. Since ghosts in general have zip-nada-nothing in the way of causing physical manifestation, dramatic physical effects may in general be attributed to the non-ghost spirit category. I say "in general" due to the fact that ghosts generally cannot even move a paperclip. But I am not a ghost expert so I cannot say X percent etc.

The viewpoint of ghosts tends to be "romantic" probably due to the many Hollywood movies and fiction stories, where the ghosts have independent thought and an active post-death existance. That is not accurate. A ghost may be "reactive", but not "proactive". Plenty of spirits, including hostile ones that can perform limited physical world interaction, are proactive and capable of thought.

So the removal techniques that work for a ghost, which is really a form of echo or (alternatively) perhaps a "shell"; are not effective on a spirit which has the capacity of intent and at a low level, thought.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Do You Believe In Ghosts? 669 Brian Patterson 17-May-04 17:32
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 229 ArmchairObserver 17-May-04 18:22
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 206 Brian Patterson 17-May-04 21:29
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 204 Historyfreak 17-May-04 21:55
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 206 Brian Patterson 17-May-04 22:28
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 174 SunSword 17-May-04 22:26
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 205 ArmchairObserver 17-May-04 22:41
Of course... 167 David L 17-May-04 22:54
Re: Of course... 240 Historyfreak 18-May-04 04:41
Re: Of course... 207 Brian Patterson 18-May-04 16:06
Re: Of course... 235 David L 18-May-04 21:30
Re: Of course... 233 SunSword 18-May-04 19:59
Re: Of course... 250 Historyfreak 18-May-04 20:59
Countless fields of expertise 213 Kees 18-May-04 22:07
Re: Countless fields of expertise 224 SunSword 18-May-04 22:46
Re: Of course... 187 Richard Fusniak 18-May-04 22:23
Re: Of course... 206 David L 18-May-04 21:25
Lables 241 Richard Fusniak 18-May-04 22:01
Re: Lables 209 Historyfreak 19-May-04 02:32
Re: Lables 206 SunSword 19-May-04 14:03
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 217 Mercury Rapids 19-May-04 08:53
It's peaceful down there ... ? 254 Thirdwave 19-May-04 10:23
Re: It's peaceful down there ... ? 196 Mercury Rapids 19-May-04 13:13
Placidus Gilletteus ?? 213 Thirdwave 19-May-04 23:18
Re: Placidus Gilletteus ?? 213 Mercury Rapids 20-May-04 09:33
Re: Placidus Gilletteus ?? 220 Kees 20-May-04 10:14
Re: Placidus Gilletteus ?? 205 Mercury Rapids 20-May-04 10:42
Re: BB's 224 Sharon West 23-May-04 04:43
Re: BB's 203 Brian Patterson 23-May-04 20:21
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 229 Delta 24-May-04 01:42
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 212 Brian Patterson 24-May-04 16:10
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 244 Sharon West 24-May-04 19:15
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 226 Delta 24-May-04 22:43
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 240 Citizen Attorney 30-May-04 05:30
Re: Do You Believe In Ghosts? 198 Delta 30-May-04 07:57
Not sure if I'd call this a ghost 221 Katherine 02-Jun-04 22:03
Re: Not sure if I'd call this a ghost 410 David L 03-Jun-04 00:00


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.