Inner Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions on all matters relating to personal development, religion, philosophy, psychology and so on. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
[www.tomharpur.com]

Hi Steve,

You mentioned....." Interestingly enough, the first article I ever read that questioned the historicity of Jesus was by a Canadian church minister. (haven't been able to find it since."

Wouldn't happen to have been Tom Harpur would it? He writes a weekly article for the Toronto Star which can be read by clicking on 'Articles' at the above link. He use to have an Archive where one could read all his past articles, however recently changed and one must now subscribe to the Star to access the past articles. :(

He also wrote the Pagan Christ.

Sincerely,
Pati

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Jesus: Myth or Real? 309 jackfoxy 02-Jul-05 04:59
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 204 Jal Phoenix 02-Jul-05 06:51
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 122 IanG 02-Jul-05 10:35
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 174 Milo 02-Jul-05 14:07
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 181 Shesemba 02-Jul-05 15:07
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 86 Milo 02-Jul-05 15:10
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 209 Shesemba 02-Jul-05 15:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 188 Milo 02-Jul-05 15:21
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 104 Shesemba 02-Jul-05 15:50
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 119 Milo 02-Jul-05 16:02
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 231 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 16:25
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 231 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 16:28
We need to look at the bigger picture... 191 Milo 02-Jul-05 16:35
Re: Organized religion 221 meridian1957 05-Jul-05 20:13
division among believers 228 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 21:19
Why are you replying to your own posts all the time Debra? 115 Milo 02-Jul-05 21:36
On trying to stir up division... 117 Milo 02-Jul-05 16:31
20th Century Killers 213 SunSword 05-Jul-05 19:20
Re: 20th Century Killers 102 debraregypt 06-Jul-05 02:22
Re: 20th Century Killers 219 Farseeker 07-Jul-05 15:56
Re: 20th Century Killers 69 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 17:57
Re: 20th Century Killers 147 Farseeker 07-Jul-05 19:11
Re: 20th Century Killers 225 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 21:56
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 150 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 15:46
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 71 Milo 02-Jul-05 15:49
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 159 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 15:01
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 113 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 14:59
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 205 Milo 02-Jul-05 15:09
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 155 Halbared 02-Jul-05 15:40
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 167 Milo 02-Jul-05 15:46
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 87 Halbared 02-Jul-05 15:58
amendment 110 Halbared 02-Jul-05 15:59
Re: amendment 189 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 16:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 69 Milo 02-Jul-05 16:04
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 101 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 21:13
Some new thoughts on this Debra... 208 Milo 02-Jul-05 21:31
First Lady: Myth or Real? 82 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 21:47
I'm not certain about the first lady but... 97 Milo 02-Jul-05 22:14
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 190 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 16:09
The label: "Christian" 157 Milo 02-Jul-05 16:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 160 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 16:43
The subject of this thread... 115 Milo 02-Jul-05 16:47
Jesus IMO is myth 221 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 17:06
Re: Jesus IMO is myth 102 Milo 02-Jul-05 17:09
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 160 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 17:27
egads...sorry for the repeats 208 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 17:34
Josephus is irrelevant... 117 Milo 02-Jul-05 17:36
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 148 Cesar 02-Jul-05 19:06
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 171 Milo 02-Jul-05 19:19
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 139 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 19:31
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 112 Milo 02-Jul-05 19:39
Jesus Hearsay 234 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 20:06
The Reason Why Jesus Existed 175 Milo 02-Jul-05 20:21
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 117 Lee McGiffen 04-Jul-05 12:11
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 170 Milo 04-Jul-05 12:18
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 207 Lee McGiffen 04-Jul-05 13:38
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 69 Milo 04-Jul-05 20:51
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 159 debraregypt 04-Jul-05 23:30
Re: Josephus is irrelevant... 124 Milo 04-Jul-05 23:45
Read; Edgar Cayce's Story of Jesus 103 Raja 02-Jul-05 17:37
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 168 Nobody 02-Jul-05 17:47
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 182 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 18:25
lol... they moved it as I was posting...lol 105 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 18:27
Why does it matter? 242 ananda 02-Jul-05 18:33
Re: Why does it matter? 102 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 18:46
Re: Why does it matter? 241 Nobody 03-Jul-05 23:02
Re: Why does it matter? 96 debraregypt 03-Jul-05 23:19
Re: Why does it matter? 106 Nobody 05-Jul-05 06:53
Re: Why does it matter? 122 debraregypt 05-Jul-05 14:09
Re: Why does it matter? 107 Nobody 05-Jul-05 21:49
Re: Why does it matter? 90 debraregypt 06-Jul-05 02:21
Re: Why does it matter? 114 Milo 07-Jul-05 13:53
What a stretch! 213 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 14:24
Re: What a stretch! 108 Milo 07-Jul-05 14:36
Re: What a stretch! 108 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 17:08
Re: What a stretch! 77 Milo 07-Jul-05 17:38
Re: What a stretch! 175 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 18:04
Re: What a stretch! 152 Milo 07-Jul-05 18:44
Re: What a stretch! 202 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 21:57
Re: Why does it matter? 192 music 02-Jul-05 18:57
"If you had faith as 205 Raja 02-Jul-05 23:25
Re: Why does it matter? 69 jackfoxy 05-Jul-05 12:44
One reality meeting with another 114 Milo 05-Jul-05 13:28
Re: One reality meeting with another 106 jackfoxy 05-Jul-05 14:51
Re: One reality meeting with another 131 debraregypt 05-Jul-05 15:14
Re: One reality meeting with another 103 Milo 05-Jul-05 17:40
The Matrix is the world that has been pulled over your eyes 71 Milo 05-Jul-05 17:41
Matrix great movie 123 debraregypt 05-Jul-05 18:03
Re: Matrix great movie 122 Milo 05-Jul-05 18:10
Re: Matrix great movie 242 debraregypt 05-Jul-05 18:23
Re: The Matrix is the world that has been pulled over your eyes 101 jackfoxy 06-Jul-05 11:08
Re: The Matrix is the world that has been pulled over your eyes 148 Milo 06-Jul-05 12:06
Is Isis real or myth 113 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 19:20
Re: Is Isis real or myth 230 Milo 02-Jul-05 19:24
Re: Is Isis real or myth 72 music 02-Jul-05 19:26
Isis is a good compairison 197 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 19:36
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 168 debraregypt 02-Jul-05 20:18
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 207 jackfoxy 03-Jul-05 10:58
Why Jesus Existed 182 Milo 03-Jul-05 14:04
Why Jesus came to earth. 107 Raja 03-Jul-05 14:58
Re: Why Jesus came to earth. 192 Milo 03-Jul-05 15:01
Re: Why Jesus Existed 251 jackfoxy 04-Jul-05 12:39
Re: Why Jesus Existed 126 debraregypt 04-Jul-05 14:25
You can't walk the walk Debra 213 Milo 04-Jul-05 22:34
Re: Why Jesus Existed 233 Milo 04-Jul-05 22:16
Re: Why Jesus Existed 99 jackfoxy 05-Jul-05 01:04
Re: Why Jesus Existed 75 debraregypt 05-Jul-05 01:35
out of a boot 149 debraregypt 05-Jul-05 01:39
Re: out of a boot 98 Milo 05-Jul-05 01:42
Re: Why Jesus Existed 227 Nolondil 05-Jul-05 01:48
Re: Why Jesus Existed 187 Milo 05-Jul-05 02:03
Re: Why Jesus Existed 191 Milo 05-Jul-05 01:56
Re: Why Jesus Existed 109 jackfoxy 05-Jul-05 06:51
Myth... Jesus/Isis 168 debraregypt 03-Jul-05 15:58
Isis resurection myth argument not much different to male resurection myths 227 Milo 03-Jul-05 16:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 206 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 17:25
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 162 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 17:37
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 116 debraregypt 03-Jul-05 17:59
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 163 jackfoxy 04-Jul-05 06:32
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 200 Milo 04-Jul-05 12:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 214 jackfoxy 04-Jul-05 14:04
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 195 debraregypt 04-Jul-05 14:34
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 177 Milo 04-Jul-05 22:57
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? rather Christ myth or real ! 76 Milo 04-Jul-05 22:53
There is a contradiction in your post Claude 180 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:03
no contradiction at all Milo 201 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 18:06
Christ Consciousness 114 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:19
Re: Christ Consciousness 77 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 18:27
Re: Christ Consciousness 109 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:34
Re: Christ Consciousness 163 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 18:38
Re: Christ Consciousness 137 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:49
I didn't see any contradiction 251 debraregypt 03-Jul-05 18:23
Debra, hold your horses... 234 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:25
Re: Debra, hold your horses... 140 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 18:35
Re: Debra, hold your horses... 184 debraregypt 03-Jul-05 18:42
Re: Debra, hold your horses... 157 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:43
Claude... Horses comment? 88 debraregypt 03-Jul-05 18:36
oops sorry Deb I inadvertantly post to you under Milo thread 215 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 18:44
forgot 109 Joyeuse 03-Jul-05 18:19
Good thing you brought this up! lol 111 Milo 03-Jul-05 18:23
Re: Why can't he be both? 158 meridian1957 05-Jul-05 20:25
Re: Why can't he be both? 103 jackfoxy 06-Jul-05 11:29
Re: Why can't he be both? 107 Milo 06-Jul-05 12:09
Re: Why can't he be both? 165 jackfoxy 06-Jul-05 12:25
Re: Why can't he be both? 70 Milo 06-Jul-05 12:39
The historical record 103 SunSword 06-Jul-05 14:15
Re: The historical record 167 debraregypt 06-Jul-05 14:47
Re: The historical record 172 SunSword 06-Jul-05 15:58
Re: The historical record 153 music 06-Jul-05 16:55
Re: The historical record 130 debraregypt 06-Jul-05 17:24
Re: The historical record 223 music 06-Jul-05 17:47
Re: The historical record 128 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 03:23
Re: The historical record 102 Milo 07-Jul-05 03:27
Re: The historical record 207 music 07-Jul-05 07:22
Re: The historical record 117 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 13:40
Re: The historical record 105 Milo 07-Jul-05 13:46
oops 228 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 13:50
Re: The historical record 67 music 07-Jul-05 17:51
Re: The historical record 84 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 18:11
Re: The historical record 220 debraregypt 06-Jul-05 17:22
Re: The historical record 182 jackfoxy 07-Jul-05 01:35
Re: The historical record 189 Cesar 07-Jul-05 03:08
Re: The historical record 56 jackfoxy 07-Jul-05 10:30
Re: The historical record 210 Milo 07-Jul-05 11:31
Re: The historical record 192 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 13:48
Re: The historical record 87 Milo 07-Jul-05 14:16
Re: The historical record 199 jackfoxy 08-Jul-05 15:09
Re: The historical record 93 Milo 08-Jul-05 19:56
Re: The historical record 174 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 06:09
Re: The historical record 108 Milo 10-Jul-05 06:15
Re: The historical record 93 SunSword 07-Jul-05 14:05
Re: The historical record 108 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 14:19
Re: The historical record 92 SunSword 07-Jul-05 17:10
Re: The historical record 129 Cesar 07-Jul-05 17:34
Re: The historical record 136 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 18:15
Re: The historical record 147 Cesar 07-Jul-05 22:08
Re: The historical record 122 debraregypt 07-Jul-05 22:17
Re: The historical record 201 Cesar 09-Jul-05 00:38
Re: The historical record 81 jackfoxy 08-Jul-05 00:11
Records 115 SunSword 08-Jul-05 14:56
Re: Records 86 jackfoxy 08-Jul-05 15:51
Re: Records 97 SunSword 08-Jul-05 19:05
Re: Records 109 debraregypt 08-Jul-05 21:41
Re: Records 90 jackfoxy 09-Jul-05 01:01
Re: Records 79 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 02:10
Standards of Proof -- Ghengis Khan Never Existed Either 194 SunSword 11-Jul-05 15:26
Re: Standards of Proof -- Ghengis Khan Never Existed Either 86 jackfoxy 11-Jul-05 23:01
Re: Standards of Proof -- Ghengis Khan Never Existed Either 118 Milo 12-Jul-05 14:04
Re: Standards of Proof -- Ghengis Khan Never Existed Either 126 jackfoxy 12-Jul-05 14:13
Re: Standards of Proof -- Ghengis Khan Never Existed Either 57 Milo 12-Jul-05 14:21
Acceptance of Evidence 141 SunSword 12-Jul-05 15:17
Ghengis Khan and the Christ 53 SunSword 12-Jul-05 14:52
Re: Ghengikhanity 152 jackfoxy 12-Jul-05 15:53
Re: Ghengikhanity 85 Milo 12-Jul-05 15:57
The jackfoxy Standard 100 SunSword 12-Jul-05 16:38
Re: The jackfoxy Standard 64 jackfoxy 12-Jul-05 17:55
Re: The jackfoxy Standard 150 SunSword 12-Jul-05 21:20
Re: The historical record 122 Cesar 07-Jul-05 16:39
Re: The historical record 144 jackfoxy 08-Jul-05 14:31
Re: The historical record 163 Cesar 09-Jul-05 00:42
Re: The historical record 150 jackfoxy 09-Jul-05 02:31
Re: The historical record 97 Cesar 09-Jul-05 10:11
Re: The historical record 105 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 01:01
Re: The historical record 133 Milo 10-Jul-05 05:01
Re: The historical record 201 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 05:56
Re: The historical record 93 Milo 10-Jul-05 06:12
Re: Canadian church minister 250 Astikapati 07-Jul-05 06:12
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 140 Kattmanndoo 08-Jul-05 05:41
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 246 Nobody 08-Jul-05 07:13
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 144 jackfoxy 08-Jul-05 13:36
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 145 debraregypt 08-Jul-05 14:15
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 78 jackfoxy 08-Jul-05 14:50
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 70 Kattmanndoo 08-Jul-05 09:12
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 181 Nobody 08-Jul-05 11:26
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 84 debraregypt 08-Jul-05 14:24
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 142 Nobody 08-Jul-05 21:54
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 86 Milo 08-Jul-05 21:57
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 66 Nobody 08-Jul-05 22:13
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 186 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 00:25
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 85 Milo 09-Jul-05 00:49
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 67 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 02:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 191 Milo 09-Jul-05 03:50
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 73 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:28
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 180 Milo 09-Jul-05 14:47
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 85 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 15:12
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 208 Milo 09-Jul-05 15:18
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 110 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 15:30
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 98 Milo 09-Jul-05 15:59
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 116 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 16:22
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 82 Milo 09-Jul-05 16:26
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 192 Milo 09-Jul-05 16:32
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 163 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 16:42
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 56 Milo 09-Jul-05 16:49
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 183 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 17:41
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 170 Milo 09-Jul-05 17:53
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 63 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 18:50
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 88 Milo 09-Jul-05 19:24
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 94 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 19:50
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 214 Milo 09-Jul-05 19:57
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 141 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:01
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 115 Milo 09-Jul-05 20:15
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 165 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:24
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 84 Milo 09-Jul-05 20:36
word of warning/ mod had a request 84 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:43
It's got nothing to do with politics 117 Milo 09-Jul-05 20:51
mods....a question? please review 110 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:58
global village is a term for reality 135 Milo 09-Jul-05 21:04
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 99 Cesar 09-Jul-05 19:42
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 87 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 19:56
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 139 Cesar 09-Jul-05 23:13
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 91 debraregypt 10-Jul-05 01:12
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 99 Cesar 10-Jul-05 04:29
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 143 debraregypt 10-Jul-05 04:49
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 183 Cesar 10-Jul-05 05:02
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 70 debraregypt 10-Jul-05 01:15
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 67 Milo 10-Jul-05 05:08
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 72 Cesar 09-Jul-05 19:14
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 67 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:07
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 93 Milo 09-Jul-05 20:17
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 133 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:27
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 61 Milo 09-Jul-05 20:38
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 80 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 20:44
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 157 Milo 09-Jul-05 20:54
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 87 Cesar 09-Jul-05 22:31
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 63 debraregypt 10-Jul-05 01:18
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 143 Cesar 09-Jul-05 10:27
the name.....Yeshua/Jesus 115 debraregypt 08-Jul-05 21:16
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 198 Kattmanndoo 09-Jul-05 02:54
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 161 Kattmanndoo 09-Jul-05 03:08
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 154 Jaimi2 09-Jul-05 04:00
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 169 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:30
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 103 Milo 09-Jul-05 04:02
Re: 211 Astikapati 09-Jul-05 05:20
Oh.... two pat's 124 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:34
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 135 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:32
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 80 Milo 09-Jul-05 04:09
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 153 Kattmanndoo 09-Jul-05 08:46
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 99 Nobody 09-Jul-05 11:46
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 194 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:38
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 211 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 13:02
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 187 Milo 09-Jul-05 14:53
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 165 Milo 09-Jul-05 15:00
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 85 Porta 09-Jul-05 09:48
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 88 jackfoxy 09-Jul-05 10:59
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 100 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:46
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 82 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 12:44
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 191 Kattmanndoo 09-Jul-05 17:56
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 91 Milo 09-Jul-05 18:19
Re: Jesus: Myth or Real? 98 debraregypt 09-Jul-05 19:01
An interesting case of forgery... 96 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 13:22
Re: An interesting case of forgery... 94 debraregypt 10-Jul-05 13:37
Re: An interesting case of forgery... 110 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 14:26
ossuary/real..inscription/fake 159 debraregypt 10-Jul-05 14:30
Re: ossuary/real..inscription/fake 120 Milo 10-Jul-05 14:59
Re: ossuary/real..inscription/fake 191 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 15:17
Re: ossuary/real..inscription/fake 127 Milo 10-Jul-05 15:24
Getting near the 300 mark! 82 jackfoxy 10-Jul-05 16:28
Re: Getting near the 300 mark! 143 Milo 10-Jul-05 17:32


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.