Inner Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions on all matters relating to personal development, religion, philosophy, psychology and so on. 
Welcome! Log InRegister

Comparison of the Jesus and Krishna Myths The Hindu Krishna Myth
The Christian Jesus Myth.

Krishna is the son of the Virgin Devaki. Jesus is the son of the Virgin Mary.
Krishna's birth occurs while his foster father, Nanda, is in his native city to pay taxes to the king, King Kansa. Jesus' birth occurs while his foster father, Joseph, is in his native city to pay taxes to the Governor.
King Kansa tried to kill Krishna by ordeing the slaughter of all males born on the same day as Krishna. King Herod ordered the slaughter of all infants born on the same day as Jesus.
Source: St. Matthew, 2:16.
The Virgin Devaki is told by an angel, "In thy delivery, O favored among women, all nations shall have cause to rejoice." The Virgin Mary is told by an angel, "Hail, thou that art highly favored, the Lord is with thee: blessed art thou among women. ... Fear not, Mary, for thou hast found favor with God. And, behold, thou shalt conceive in thy womb, and bring forth a son, and shalt call his name JESUS. He shall be great, and shall be called the Son of the Highest: and the Lord God shall give unto him the throne of his father David: And he shall reign over the house of Jacob forever; and of his kingdom there shall be no end."
Source: St. Luke 1:28-33.
The nativity of Krishna is heralded by a star. The nativity of Jesus is heralded by a star.
Krishna is born in a cave.
The cave story is an indication of lower-class birthplace. Jesus is born in a cave.
Source: The Apocryphal Gospel entitled Protevangelion, supposedly written by James, the brother of Jesus.
The manger story (wherein Jesus was born in a stable) is an indication of a low-class birthplace.
Krishna is visited in the cave by three wise men bearing gifts. Jesus is visited in the stable/cave by three wise men bearing gifts.
The cave was mysteriously illuminated. The cave was illuminated so brightly Joseph and Mary's midwife could not tolerate the light.
Source: The Apocryphal Gospel Protevangelion.
Nanda is warned by an angel to flee from King Kansa by crossing the Jumna River with the infant Krishna. Joseph is warned in a dream to flee from King Herod into Egypt with the infant Jesus and the Virgin Mary.
The baby Krishna began speaking to his mother shortly after birth. The baby Jesus began speaking to the Virgin Mary shortly after his birth, saying, "Mary, I am Jesus, the Son of God, that WORD which thou didst bring forth according to the declaration of the Angel Gabriel to thee, and my Father hath sent me for the salvation of the world."
Source: The Apocryphal Gospel, The First Gospel of the Infancy.
Krishna performs miracles in Mathura. Jesus performs miracles in the town of Materea in Egypt.
Krishna is the second person of the Hindu Trinity: (1) Brahma, (2) Vishnu, (3) Siva. Krishna is the incarnation of Vishnu. Jesus is the second person of the Christian Trinity: (1) God, the Father, (2) Jesus the Son, (3) the Holy Ghost.
Krishna was crucified. Jesus was crucified.
During the crucifixion, Krishna was wounded by an arrow. During the crucifixion, Jesus was wounded by a spear.
At noon on the day of Krishna's crucifixion, the sun darkened. From the sixth hour to the ninth hour on the day of Jesus' crucifixion, the sun darkened.
Krishna descended into Hell.
He raised the dead.
He brought back two boys from Hell. Jesus descended into Hell.
He raised the dead.
He brought back from Hell two boys, the sons of the high priest.
Source: The Apocryphal Gospel of Nicodemus.

Sources:
John G. Jackson, Christianity Before Christ
The crucifixion of Krishna: Thomas Inman, M.D.,
Ancient Faiths Ancient Faiths, Vol. I, p. 411, cited by Thomas William Doane in Bible Myths and Their Parallels in Other Religions
Christianity Before Christ, American Atheist Press


Sorry I couldn't leave this alone...

Sunbeam

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 486 gene douglas 13-Feb-04 13:33
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 129 Milo 13-Feb-04 20:28
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 159 sunbeam 13-Feb-04 22:28
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 166 Milo 13-Feb-04 23:12
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 143 gene douglas 14-Feb-04 01:15
The planet Pleiades 151 Richard Fusniak 14-Feb-04 19:41
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 199 sunbeam 13-Feb-04 22:49
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 119 Milo 14-Feb-04 00:09
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 118 gene douglas 14-Feb-04 03:20
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 116 Milo 14-Feb-04 04:44
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 169 gene douglas 14-Feb-04 05:40
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 144 Milo 14-Feb-04 06:40
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 175 gene douglas 14-Feb-04 12:12
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 117 Milo 14-Feb-04 16:18
Rob. we have now reached Impasse! 194 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 02:35
Re: Rob. we have now reached Impasse! 144 Milo 15-Feb-04 05:24
Re: Rob. we have now reached Impasse! 130 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 09:19
Re: Rob. we have now reached Impasse! 119 Milo 15-Feb-04 13:27
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 117 adequatedane 14-Feb-04 16:32
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 176 Milo 14-Feb-04 16:39
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 114 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 02:44
Mod remark 165 Kees 15-Feb-04 14:24
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 113 Kees 15-Feb-04 14:34
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 117 Milo 15-Feb-04 15:07
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 236 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 15:18
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 150 Milo 15-Feb-04 15:44
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 189 sunbeam 17-Feb-04 21:58
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 155 Elizabeth Newton 14-Feb-04 05:23
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 150 gene douglas 14-Feb-04 05:48
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 140 Milo 14-Feb-04 06:29
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 161 Prue 14-Feb-04 18:07
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 102 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 00:36
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 161 Prue 15-Feb-04 10:13
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 137 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 14:57
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 171 Prue 15-Feb-04 16:44
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 134 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 17:15
The Osiris template 147 Kees 15-Feb-04 14:39
Re: The Osiris template 122 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 15:30
Re: The Osiris template 153 Milo 15-Feb-04 15:49
Re: The Osiris template 154 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 16:23
Re: The Osiris template 118 Milo 15-Feb-04 17:07
Re: The Osiris template 148 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 17:33
Re: The Osiris template 147 Milo 15-Feb-04 17:50
Re: The Osiris template 159 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 18:32
Re: The Osiris template 128 Milo 15-Feb-04 18:43
Re: The Osiris template 156 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 19:03
Re: The Osiris template 115 Mark Staab 15-Feb-04 18:50
Re: The Osiris template 152 gene douglas 15-Feb-04 18:58
Re: The Osiris template 149 Mark Staab 15-Feb-04 20:08
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 165 jestahley3 15-Feb-04 05:27
Re: Similarities between lives of Jesus Christ and India's Iesus Krishna. 215 jestahley3 15-Feb-04 17:12


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.