I agree with you and Eddie. Science has no emotion of itself. To see your comments pounced on and treated like infant school homework is both pointless and boring. An inability to actually discuss and introduce original thought, and ask related questions leads to pushing a personal agenda for no purpose for others whatsoever.
I read that Haplogroup studies MUST be done in isolation or it can turn into making the 'evidence fit the crime' of the other fields of study like archaeology and the origins of Mankind in general.