Inner Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions on all matters relating to personal development, religion, philosophy, psychology and so on. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
There is an inherent problem in judging all three of them. We have no writings of Socrates, only second/third hand stories by Plato (and a few others such as Xenophon). We can only assess his thought through the accounts of others. Not very reliable.

For Plato we have plenty of published work. But hardly a trace of his private/personal papers. Certainly no notes about the sources and writing of the dialogues. Just a few reputed letters (these are usually included in a volume of the collected dialogues) that we can't really prove are genuine.

For Aristotle, ironically, all we have is the private notes. Though he published a fair number of dialogues similar to Plato's, and these are highly praised in the surviving literature from that time, we do not have the actual dialogues. They are all lost. Everything called "The Works of Aristotle" is a bunch of notes for giving lectures, or possibly notes from his lectures written down by someone else. We don't really know for certain what in "The Works of Aristotle" is by Aristotle himself rather than just someone in his school.

This makes our knowledge of all three of them very incomplete. If only someone could discover "The Dialogues of Aristotle" in some archeological site!

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Books by Plato 1080 markgalioto69 16-Aug-19 17:56
Re: Books by Plato 98 Itatw70s 16-Aug-19 19:50
Re: Books by Plato 103 Nolondil 16-Aug-19 20:12
Re: Books by Plato 97 markgalioto69 17-Aug-19 00:27
Re: Books by Plato 89 Itatw70s 17-Aug-19 21:02
Re: Books by Plato 103 Nolondil 17-Aug-19 21:24
Re: Books by Plato 89 Itatw70s 17-Aug-19 21:51
Re: Books by Platoo 91 Eddie Larry 17-Aug-19 22:36
Re: Books by Platoo 107 Nolondil 17-Aug-19 23:56
Re: Books by Platoo 90 Eddie Larry 18-Aug-19 04:49
Re: Books by Platoo 85 Itatw70s 18-Aug-19 13:15
Re: Books by Plato 86 Eddie Larry 18-Aug-19 18:44
Re: Books by Plato 147 Itatw70s 18-Aug-19 19:53


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.