Inner Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For discussions on all matters relating to personal development, religion, philosophy, psychology and so on. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Quote
Susan opined
it is as clear as can be I think that ancient people decided that there were forces which did things because of human behaviour , thus leading to the invention of gods. This is, and has been ever since, the alternative superstition, but people who are believers do not like the idea that such beliefs can easily be labelled superstitions. Because of the increasing scientific understanding of the natural world and the universe, those who command the loyalty of billions for their religions must invent less and less credible falsehoods to explain. Such as, 'god is beyond time and space'

Actually Susan, I think that what ancient people decided was that there were forces of Nature that did NOT do what people wanted. Like volcanoes, storms, earthquakes etc. We call them, even today, forces of nature. They can still destroy us and our plans. I suggest that what was superstitious was thinking people could do things which avert these natural processes.

So I take it now that “alternative superstition “ simply means ancient superstitions or Susan’s interpretation of ancient superstitions.

In terms of your last two sentences, I think that modern religions have already handled the issues of ancient or original superstitions quite well. God for modern religions is really tied to the concept of good or goodness. Especially, a lifestyle based on love of life and reciprocity towards one’s neighbors.

Now the notion that ‘god is beyond space and time’ was a later notion based on the idea that the machinery that drove the world was just past the pearl blue sky. Was it Albrect Durer who did the famous painting of man peering into the clockwork just beyond what we see?

You know Susan, god does not have to be interpreted as a “supernatural existent” and , if so, then you don’t have an argument at all. I can only suggest being careful with the argument of supernatural reality. It works both ways. IMO, of course.

My definition is simple, god is the word people use to name the meaning they find in life. Not “supernatural “ at all.

Hope this helps!

Edited for typos.



Edited 1 time(s). Last edit at 10-Nov-18 00:01 by Eddie Larry.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Free will or not? 1246 greengirl5 04-Nov-18 21:54
Re: Free will or not? 263 Itatw70s 04-Nov-18 22:51
Re: Free will or not? 226 Eddie Larry 05-Nov-18 00:02
Re: Free will or not? 203 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 03:19
Re: Free will or not? 196 Eddie Larry 05-Nov-18 04:01
Re: Free will or not? 193 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 05:01
Re: Free will or not? 194 Eddie Larry 05-Nov-18 05:10
Re: Free will or not? 188 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 05:25
Re: Free will or not? 199 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 06:18
The chocolate made me do it 176 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 07:35
Re: The chocolate made me do it 185 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 08:00
Re: The chocolate made me do it 201 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 09:18
Re: The chocolate made me do it 210 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 10:00
Re: The chocolate made me do it 197 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 12:18
Re: The chocolate made me do it 172 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 12:57
Re: The chocolate made me do it, but did not make me think! 187 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 22:25
Re: The chocolate made me do it 209 Eddie Larry 05-Nov-18 15:05
Security and randomness 187 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 08:19
Re: Security and randomness 176 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 12:51
Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 180 drrayeye 05-Nov-18 11:40
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 181 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 12:22
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 185 Itatw70s 05-Nov-18 12:48
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 186 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 22:35
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 180 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 13:04
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 175 drrayeye 05-Nov-18 15:28
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 174 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 19:57
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 191 drrayeye 05-Nov-18 20:39
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 169 Susan Doris 06-Nov-18 06:21
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 201 drrayeye 06-Nov-18 09:19
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 180 Susan Doris 06-Nov-18 10:37
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 174 drrayeye 06-Nov-18 14:09
Re: Cognitive processes allowing or not allowing free will 191 Susan Doris 06-Nov-18 14:23
scientific vs. clinical perspective on consciousness 176 drrayeye 06-Nov-18 19:01
Various states of consciousness 177 greengirl5 06-Nov-18 21:32
Re: Various states of consciousness 183 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 00:37
Re: Various states of consciousness 185 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 01:11
Re: Various states of consciousness 178 Susan Doris 07-Nov-18 06:11
Re: Various states of consciousness 191 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 07:28
Re: Various states of consciousness 187 Susan Doris 07-Nov-18 08:28
you're totally lost here 183 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 08:55
Re: you're totally lost here 182 Susan Doris 07-Nov-18 09:52
Re: you're totally lost here 184 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 12:02
Re: you're totally lost here 184 Susan Doris 07-Nov-18 16:03
Keep the science out 214 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 18:25
Re: Various states of consciousness 192 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 08:58
Re: Various states of consciousness 192 Susan Doris 07-Nov-18 10:14
Re: Various states of consciousness 184 Eddie Larry 07-Nov-18 19:04
Re: Various states of consciousness 181 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 21:18
Was Einstein a scientist? 181 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 21:55
Not a materialist 186 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 22:14
Re: Not a materialist 171 Susan Doris 08-Nov-18 01:16
Butting in 178 drrayeye 08-Nov-18 06:24
Re: Not a materialist 182 greengirl5 08-Nov-18 02:30
Re: Not a materialist 177 Susan Doris 08-Nov-18 05:58
Re: Not a materialist 163 greengirl5 08-Nov-18 07:19
Re: Various states of consciousness 191 Susan Doris 08-Nov-18 01:13
Re: Various states of consciousness 176 Susan Doris 08-Nov-18 01:08
Re: Various states of consciousness 178 greengirl5 08-Nov-18 02:17
Re: Various states of consciousness 188 Susan Doris 08-Nov-18 06:07
Interpretations 188 greengirl5 08-Nov-18 07:23
Re: Various states of consciousness 214 Susan Doris 08-Nov-18 07:32
Re: Various states of consciousness 212 Eddie Larry 08-Nov-18 18:26
Re: Various states of consciousness 172 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 06:16
Re: Various states of consciousness 174 Eddie Larry 09-Nov-18 23:57
May the force be with you! 193 greengirl5 10-Nov-18 01:57
Re: May the force be with you! 182 Eddie Larry 10-Nov-18 02:20
Re: May the force be with you! 182 greengirl5 10-Nov-18 04:10
Re: May the force be with you! 186 Eddie Larry 10-Nov-18 14:10
Re: May the force be with you! 175 greengirl5 10-Nov-18 20:26
Re: Various states of consciousness 199 Susan Doris 10-Nov-18 08:15
Religious leaders and others 177 greengirl5 10-Nov-18 09:55
Re: Religious leaders and others 200 Susan Doris 10-Nov-18 12:04
Pathological disbeliever 191 greengirl5 10-Nov-18 20:32
Re: Pathological disbeliever 188 Susan Doris 11-Nov-18 06:01
Re: Various states of consciousness 180 Eddie Larry 10-Nov-18 14:27
Whose fault? 174 greengirl5 10-Nov-18 21:00
Re: Whose fault? 191 Eddie Larry 10-Nov-18 21:12
Re: Whose fault? 178 Susan Doris 11-Nov-18 06:05
Re: Whose fault? 191 greengirl5 11-Nov-18 06:38
Re: Whose fault? 191 Susan Doris 11-Nov-18 07:14
Susan's sociological theory of religions 173 drrayeye 10-Nov-18 19:10
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 198 Susan Doris 10-Nov-18 20:14
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 170 drrayeye 11-Nov-18 02:16
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 180 Susan Doris 11-Nov-18 06:14
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 176 Susan Doris 11-Nov-18 12:46
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 167 drrayeye 13-Nov-18 03:54
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 167 Susan Doris 13-Nov-18 06:14
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 164 drrayeye 13-Nov-18 04:11
Re: Susan's sociological theory of religions 187 Susan Doris 13-Nov-18 06:29
Maybe a cheer leader for science 175 drrayeye 13-Nov-18 08:34
"T of E" vs. "t of e"? 168 drrayeye 13-Nov-18 08:41
N R F 173 greengirl5 13-Nov-18 09:28
Re: "T of E" vs. "t of e"? 180 Susan Doris 13-Nov-18 17:59
Re: "T of E" vs. "t of e"? 166 drrayeye 13-Nov-18 20:16
Re: "T of E" vs. "t of e"? 315 Susan Doris 14-Nov-18 02:16
Superstitious behavior 183 drrayeye 08-Nov-18 20:40
Re: Superstitious behavior 165 greengirl5 08-Nov-18 20:53
Re: Superstitious behavior 188 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 06:30
another day--another rant. 172 drrayeye 09-Nov-18 09:15
Re: another day--another rant. 186 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 11:11
Free will 166 drrayeye 10-Nov-18 08:20
Superstitions 146 greengirl5 09-Nov-18 20:48
Re: Various states of consciousness 159 greengirl5 08-Nov-18 20:49
Re: Various states of consciousness 164 Eddie Larry 08-Nov-18 04:08
You're not following 187 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 08:47
Re: Free will or not? 182 Jock 06-Nov-18 17:00
Re: Free will or not? 201 Susan Doris 06-Nov-18 18:04
Re: Free will or not? 190 Jock 08-Nov-18 21:38
Re: Free will or not? 190 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 06:41
Re: Free will or not? 162 greengirl5 09-Nov-18 07:32
Re: Free will or not? 177 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 07:48
Completely off the wall 166 drrayeye 09-Nov-18 13:01
Re: Completely off the wall 201 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 13:56
Re: Completely off the wall 170 drrayeye 09-Nov-18 18:00
Re: Completely off the wall 179 Susan Doris 09-Nov-18 18:31
Re: Completely off the wall 193 Jock 09-Nov-18 20:11
Contumelious 165 greengirl5 09-Nov-18 21:29
Re: Completely off the wall 166 Susan Doris 10-Nov-18 08:25
Re: Completely off the wall 178 greengirl5 09-Nov-18 21:17
Re-education 183 greengirl5 09-Nov-18 21:08
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 220 M. J. Thomas 05-Nov-18 14:45
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 209 drrayeye 05-Nov-18 15:46
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 206 M. J. Thomas 06-Nov-18 10:43
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 177 drrayeye 06-Nov-18 14:13
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 194 Susan Doris 06-Nov-18 14:28
So what is God to you? 177 greengirl5 06-Nov-18 21:47
Re: So what is God to you? 193 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 00:48
Re: So what is God to you? 172 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 01:21
Re: So what is God to you? 186 drrayeye 07-Nov-18 01:38
Re: So what is God to you? 177 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 02:07
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 202 Susan Doris 05-Nov-18 20:04
Re: Evolution is intelligent. 187 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 22:51
Me too! 193 greengirl5 05-Nov-18 22:47
No-Name freedom.... 188 Itatw70s 06-Nov-18 01:12
The way 190 greengirl5 06-Nov-18 02:19
Re: Free will or not? 196 Itatw70s 06-Nov-18 12:25
Re: Free will or not? 198 Eddie Larry 06-Nov-18 14:34
Re: Free will or not? 188 Itatw70s 06-Nov-18 16:42
Way to go! 188 greengirl5 06-Nov-18 21:52
The letter kills, but the Spirit gives life. 191 Itatw70s 07-Nov-18 00:41
Re: The letter kills, but the Spirit gives life. 217 greengirl5 07-Nov-18 01:24
Re: The letter kills, but the Spirit gives life. 216 Itatw70s 07-Nov-18 12:40
Re: The letter kills, but the Spirit gives life. 203 Enigcom 07-Nov-18 16:15
Re: Free will or not? 208 Itatw70s 07-Nov-18 20:55
Re: Free will or not? 174 Enigcom 11-Nov-18 22:10
Re: Free will or not? 183 wilpsy3 10-Nov-18 21:39


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.