Science & Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For all that is Scientifically related to Cosmology and Space. (NB: Please take discussions about UFOs, possible Alien contact, Crop-Circles, Alien Abductions, Planet-X and Niburu to the ‘Paranormal and Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Feralkiwi wrote:

"The impact I use is the one described in Otto Mucks
book Secretes of Atlantis. He places it in the Atlantic
ridge with "splatter" in Charleston USA."

Unfortunately, the alleged craters of Otto Muck suffer from the same problems that Andres’ hypothesized craters. First, the circular features, which Muck identified as "impact craters" are nothing more then artifacts of the way that sparse data points were mapped. With the collection of additional data and ocean mapping using Satellite Altimetry, both of these circular features have completely disappeared. Second, the Deep Sea and Ocean Drilling projects and other marine research projects have recovered deepsea cores from the ocean floor near these alleged craters. None of these cores have found to contain a single shred of evidence, i.e. thick beds of impact ejecta, for the massive impacts proposed by Muck that should exist had they happened. Third, the effects of impacts creating 320 to 480 km (200 to 300 miles) in maximum diameter would have created tsunamis and other effects that would have, at the least, wiped out a good part of eastern North America and large parts of western Europe, which did not happen. Finally, the large magnetic and gravity anomalies that such impacts would have created are also completely lacking. There is simply a complete lack of any evidence for such large impacts where Muck claims they happened. It should be noted that the Carolina Bays all point towards the Great Lakes region not the Atlantic Ocean.

Go look at:

Tucholke, B. E., 1986, depth to basement in the western North Atlantic Ocean.
in P. R. Vogt and B. E. Tucholke, eds., plate 5. The Western North Atlantic
Region. The Geology of North America. vol. M. Geological Society of
America, Boulder, Colorado.

Tucholke, B. E., L A. Raymond, And P. R. Vogt, 1986, Bathymetry of the North
Atlantic Ocean. in P. R. Vogt and B. E. Tucholke, eds., plate 2. The Western
North Atlantic Region. The Western North Atlantic Region. The Geology of
North America. vol. M. Geological Society of America, Boulder, Colorado.

Voight, P. R., B. E. Tucholke, eds., The Geology of the North Atlantic, Vol. M.
The Western North Atlantic Region. DNAG, Geological Society of America,
Boulder, Colorado.

In addition, the two "parallel clefts" / "submarine cliffs" / "abysses submarines" found near Puerto Rico are now known to be an oceanic trench that are the submarine expression of the Lesser Antilles subduction zone and unrelated to any prehistoric impact. It is where oceanic crust of the North America Plate is being subducted under oceanic crust of the Caribbean Plate. Some web pages are:

Lesser Antilles Subduction Zone - [www.ig.utexas.edu]

Caribbean Plate - [en.wikipedia.org]

Burke, K., C. Cooper, J. F. Dewey, P. Mann, and J. L. Pindell, 1984, Caribbean
tectonics and relative plate motions, Geological Society of America. Memoir
no. 162, pp. 31-63.

Burke, K. 1988, Tectonic evolution of the Caribbean. Annual Review of Earth
and Planetary Sciences. vol. 16, pp. 210-230.

When looking for impact craters, a person needs to keep in mind what stated on a "Impact Database v. 2009.2" web page at [impacts.rajmon.cz]. At that web page, it is stated:

"Do not get hung up on a single idea of an impact. Human mind
sees what it wants to see. Once you start looking for patterns
(being it circles or triangles) you will see circles and triangles
everywhere. This article illustrates the issue nicely:

Bond C. E., Gibbs A. D., Shipton Z. K. and Jones S.
(2007) What do you think this is? "Conceptual uncertainty"
in geoscience interpretation. GSA Today 17(11):4-10.
[dx.doi.org];

Also there is "Criteria for impact crater identification - How can you tell if it is an impact crater?" at <[www.unb.ca];.

By the way, the PDF file of "The Secret of Atlantis", by Otto Muck can be found at [www.scribd.com].

Yours,

David


Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
I found something big..... 406 andre.chaisson 14-Jan-10 23:05
Re: I found something big..... 269 Ahatmose 15-Jan-10 00:14
Re: I found something big..... 258 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 00:57
Off topic for Ahatmose 289 Absinthujone 15-Jan-10 04:38
Re: I found something big..... 249 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 00:52
Re: I found something big..... 226 obsolete 15-Jan-10 01:31
Re: I found something big..... 246 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 01:59
Take it easy, Andre... 262 Absinthujone 15-Jan-10 03:53
Re: Take it easy, Andre... 277 Absinthujone 15-Jan-10 04:16
Re: I found something big..... 313 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 12:43
Re: I found something big..... 322 Absinthujone 15-Jan-10 13:45
Re: I found something big..... 187 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 14:05
Re: I found something big..... 282 NetWorkAngel 15-Jan-10 15:02
Re: I found something big..... 244 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 20:36
Re: I found something big..... 241 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 20:44
Re: I found something big..... 227 andre.chaisson 15-Jan-10 21:14
The Core Samples Already Exist and Hace Been Described and Published 255 Xebec 10-Feb-10 04:37
Re: I found something big..... 301 JonnyMcA 16-Jan-10 14:17
Re: I found something big..... 223 andre.chaisson 16-Jan-10 18:26
Re: I found something big..... 210 JonnyMcA 16-Jan-10 19:41
Re: I found something big..... 297 richarddullum 27-Jan-10 03:30
Re: I found something big..... 246 Essan 27-Jan-10 14:48
Re: I found something big..... 218 Green Ruby 01-Feb-10 00:30
Re: I found something big..... 228 Ahatmose 01-Feb-10 03:48
Re: I found something big..... 211 Feralkiwi 01-Feb-10 02:32
Otto Muck's Atlantic "Craters" 1747 Xebec 11-Feb-10 02:02
Re: I found something big.....Yeah: GOOD MUSIC!! 283 Avatar 01-Feb-10 15:05
Re: I found something big.....Yeah: GOOD MUSIC!! 260 andre.chaisson 01-Feb-10 21:06
Need Some Hard Data 328 Xebec 10-Feb-10 04:26
Re: Need Some Hard Data 256 Ahatmose 10-Feb-10 20:30


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.