Science & Space :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For all that is Scientifically related to Cosmology and Space. (NB: Please take discussions about UFOs, possible Alien contact, Crop-Circles, Alien Abductions, Planet-X and Niburu to the ‘Paranormal and Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hi Daniel,

You firmly accept the Electric Universe model of the universe, along with so called stellar metamorphosis, and you like to post upon and promote these topics.

So let me ask this question, which you can answer honestly. Are either of these topics accepted within the modern scientific paradigm? You would of course have to answer "no" to this, afterall the proponents of EU etc are often complaining that modern cosmology/astrophysics do not consider EU in their research. Indeed, from the reading of many EU sites, it is quite the bugbear with EU proponents that the apparent EU origin of phenomena are ignored in favour of the mainstream (and in the EU proponents eyes, flawed) interpretation.

So, having established that EU is not part of the current modern scientific paradigm, I direct you to the remit of this sites Paranormal and Supernatural board "For discussions of everything that might be classed as ‘paranormal‘ - i.e. not currently accepted by our modern scientific paradigm."

Therefore, by this definition, the discussion of EU and its ilk (not being part of the modern scientific paradigm, should be discussed upon the Paranormal board.

However, let me point you to the remit of the Science and Space board "For all that is Scientifically related to Cosmology and Space."

Since EU etc is concerned with cosmology and space, we allow it to remain upon the Science and Space board even though it is not part of the modern scientific paradigm.

Now if you must insist upon declaring that certain topics that are published within mainstream academic journals - and thus accepted by the mainstream scientific peerage to have a modicum of scientific integrity and interest - do not belong on the Science and Space board, then we must assume that topics pertaining to EU etc (which are not published in mainstream scientific journals), must be even less scientifically acceptable and so should not be on Science and Space.

Just because you do not accept the scientific validity of modern mainstream scientific research, does not give you the right to declare what should and should not be permitted for discussion on this board.

Jonny

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 1013 Eddie Larry 20-Mar-18 01:34
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 229 D-Archer 20-Mar-18 11:28
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 190 Archaic 20-Mar-18 14:02
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 182 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 14:17
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 180 Eddie Larry 21-Mar-18 14:41
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 185 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 16:21
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 180 Eddie Larry 21-Mar-18 20:34
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 173 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:13
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 165 Eddie Larry 22-Mar-18 13:47
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 165 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 14:58
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 179 Eddie Larry 22-Mar-18 16:24
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 165 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 11:13
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 161 Eddie Larry 23-Mar-18 13:51
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 163 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 14:45
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 180 carolb 21-Mar-18 22:03
Mod Note 266 JonnyMcA 20-Mar-18 15:47
Re: Mod Note 182 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 14:12
Re: Mod Note 177 carolb 21-Mar-18 14:56
Re: Mod Note 261 JonnyMcA 22-Mar-18 12:09
Re: Mod Note 165 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:17
Re: Mod Note 249 JonnyMcA 22-Mar-18 13:15
Re: Mod Note 162 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 15:03
Re: Mod Note 280 JonnyMcA 22-Mar-18 15:31
Re: Mod Note 165 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 11:26
Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 235 Vanya 21-Mar-18 15:46
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 184 D-Archer 21-Mar-18 16:31
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 173 drrayeye 22-Mar-18 05:20
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 171 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:18
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 188 Vanya 22-Mar-18 10:35
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 181 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 12:20
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 189 Vanya 22-Mar-18 13:40
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 176 D-Archer 22-Mar-18 15:13
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 201 Vanya 22-Mar-18 15:48
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 171 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 11:36
Re: Stephen Hawking: Proposes Way to Detect the 'Multiverse' 169 carolb 23-Mar-18 12:21
MODS!!!! 170 D-Archer 23-Mar-18 14:45
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 168 cladking 23-Mar-18 19:20
Re: Stephen Hawking's 'breathtaking' final multiverse theory... 368 Eddie Larry 23-Mar-18 19:41


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.