Global Village :  The Official forums
For good-natured and mutually-respectful discussions of politics and current affairs. Soap-boxing and the promotion of extremist causes motivated by hate will not be tolerated by our moderators. 
Welcome! Log InRegister

With all respect Ash, but you can not possibly compare the Greatest Book of the 20th Century with a stolen space story. They are being faithful to the book and that is good. (really die-hard fans like me would regard it as sacrilege if PJ had altered too much) PJ has done an excellent job in trying to keep the atmosphere of the book. Of course the book is ten times better. Of course imagination goes above images presented by a movie. Of course the dialogues, the mysticism, the grandeur is very hard to come even close to. Filming LOTR is quasi-impossible but PJ sure has done an excellent job.

BTW: Have you read the book? If not, you definitely should and not only because it is the best book ever.



Options: ReplyQuote

Subject Views Written By Posted
Film of LOTR 224 Harry 03-Jan-02 17:49
Re: Film of LOTR 86 Anomalies 03-Jan-02 17:54
Re: Film of LOTR 82 Mercury Rapids 03-Jan-02 18:17
Re: Film of LOTR 71 Harry 04-Jan-02 17:37
Re: Film of LOTR 75 Doug T 03-Jan-02 21:22
Re: Film of LOTR 81 Harry 04-Jan-02 17:36
Re: Film of LOTR 78 AshH 07-Jan-02 10:19
Re: Film of LOTR 64 Harry 07-Jan-02 17:55

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.