Global Village :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For good-natured and mutually-respectful discussions of politics and current affairs. Soap-boxing and the promotion of extremist causes motivated by hate will not be tolerated by our moderators. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
When I was called up for Military Service in Italy, I visited a couple of barracks - one in Catania and one in Messina in Sicily. They were both right in the heart of the city. Behind the base at Catania was the markets, and around it were shops. Above the shops were apartments. Messina was much the same, and I think many other Italian cities had bases in the city.

In Australia, the bases are either on the outskirts of the city or in the country areas. I imagine US and British bases and other military assets are stored away from the city (for space and real estate reasons I suppose). Thus it may seem odd for a American or British person to see a bomb hit a residential district.

I no way do I agree with or condone the bombing of civilian areas, but if the bases in Kabul are like some of the bases in Italy, if the bomb missed by 20 metres then a market place or apartment would be hit with many lives guaranteed to be lost. Even hitting the base could cause "collateral" damage.

I dont know why anyone would have military assets in a built up area, but it could be a "village walls mentality".

The "apology" by the Defence Dept is very 'weak' and serves more to inflame further anti-US sentiment.

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
An apologee makes it OK ???? 471 Don Barone 14-Oct-01 12:29
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 134 RandyK 14-Oct-01 13:05
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 123 Rivz33 14-Oct-01 17:26
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 145 penny 14-Oct-01 21:40
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 138 Bent 14-Oct-01 17:38
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 140 John Carlo 14-Oct-01 19:34
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 133 John Carlo 14-Oct-01 19:34
Red Herring ? 157 Don Barone 14-Oct-01 20:54
Re: Red Herring ? 158 John Carlo 14-Oct-01 21:04
Understood !!!!! (N/T) 136 Red Herring 14-Oct-01 21:27
Re: Red Herring ? 148 Bent 15-Oct-01 01:18
Re: Neutral observer 169 Geoff 15-Oct-01 02:46
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 144 John Carlo 14-Oct-01 19:26
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 142 Marc Ellis 14-Oct-01 22:09
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 128 John Carlo 14-Oct-01 23:30
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 145 Marc Ellis 15-Oct-01 00:45
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 165 Geoff 15-Oct-01 03:04
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 152 lydia 14-Oct-01 20:37
Re: Red Herring ? 193 Red Herring 15-Oct-01 02:31
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 155 jules 15-Oct-01 04:47
Re: The art of war.... 145 Skynet 15-Oct-01 07:22
Re: An apologee makes it OK ???? 138 Pat 15-Oct-01 07:44
"re: propaganda war" 323 jules 15-Oct-01 08:57


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.