Global Village :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For good-natured and mutually-respectful discussions of politics and current affairs. Soap-boxing and the promotion of extremist causes motivated by hate will not be tolerated by our moderators. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hi All

What I've heard is the Saudi's may have reason to be cautious about stating the attacks originated in Iran. The U.S. reported activity in Iran but not sure it was beyond normal activity? No missile launches were reported as far as I know? One would think if we detected missiles or drones headed to Saudi Arabia from Iran we would have contacted them or taken some action? According to the Saudi reports some of the parts in the missiles weren't believed to be Iranian and they have no conclusive evidence of the direction of attack. Which raise the question could the attack have originated from the sea or southern Iraq by either a proxy or secret Iranian force?

I present this idea since its not reported that Iran has been trying to establish Shiite religion into Sunni areas of Iraq and a two way road between Lebanon and Iran. Iraq has allowed Iran to transport troops and equipment through Iraq from Syria and some opposite but not military or heavy equipment. It was reported a few months ago that some of the troops and equipment which left Syria didn't cross into Iran. The rumors are the troops were Quds forces and the equipment was special. There are also rumors Hezbollah has moved forces into Iraq which are aiding the Shiite militias. Which raise the questions of how far have they moved into Iraq, how many and what is their purpose?.

I understand Sunni converts to Shiite are offered $200,a new ID card which allows them unrestricted movement and actions, free education and other benefits. The majority of conversions are supposedly along the Syrian Iraq border and the roadway from Syria to Iran. These converts would ensure Shiite control over the roadway.

Iran is challenging the balance of power in the ME and from certain vantage points is being successful.

So maybe the attack didn't originate in Iran?

Thank you,Dane

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
War with Iran? 831 adequatedane 15-Sep-19 02:41
Re: War with Iran? 122 adequatedane 15-Sep-19 12:30
Re: War with Iran? 131 Eddie Larry 15-Sep-19 18:31
Re: War with Iran? 102 ldennyjr 15-Sep-19 22:45
Re: War with Iran? 96 Eddie Larry 15-Sep-19 22:53
Re: War with Iran? 100 ldennyjr 16-Sep-19 14:12
Re: War with Iran? 70 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 14:24
Re: War with Iran? 84 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 20:48
Re: War with Iran? 89 ldennyjr 17-Sep-19 15:31
Re: War with Iran? 71 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 17:09
Re: War with Iran? 103 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 01:16
Re: War with Iran? 115 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 03:55
Re: War with Iran? 82 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 10:58
Re: War with Iran? 76 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 14:30
Re: War with Iran? 77 Warwick 16-Sep-19 18:20
Re: War with Iran? 69 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 19:32
Re: War with Iran? 89 Warwick 17-Sep-19 19:31
Re: War with Iran? 74 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-19 21:09
Re: War with Iran? 75 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 21:04
Re: War with Iran? 74 Warwick 17-Sep-19 19:37
Re: War with Iran? 68 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 20:54
Re: War with Iran? 64 Warwick 17-Sep-19 21:10
Re: War with Iran? 95 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 22:52
Re: War with Iran? 78 Warwick 18-Sep-19 16:54
Re: War with Iran? 73 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 20:43
Re: War with Iran? 81 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 21:06
Re: War with Iran? 82 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 13:48
Re: War with Iran? 91 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-19 19:17
Re: War with Iran? 68 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 20:58
Re: War with Iran? 104 Archaic 16-Sep-19 08:14
Re: War with Iran? 95 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 10:12
Maybe it was the Houthis 91 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 23:34
An Act of War 114 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 02:04
Re: An Act of War 82 Brian Patterson 17-Sep-19 03:14
Re: An Act of War 80 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 14:53
The timing shows planning. 75 Warwick 17-Sep-19 19:45
Re: The timing shows planning. 71 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 22:21
Ron Paul on the situation 88 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-19 21:08
Re: Ron Paul on the situation 77 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 22:40
Kudos to Donald 89 drrayeye 18-Sep-19 01:37
Re: Kudos to Donald 82 adequatedane 18-Sep-19 14:37
Re: Kudos to Donald 87 muppedo 19-Sep-19 21:00
Re: Kudos to Donald 69 muppedo 21-Sep-19 21:55
What's Happening 79 adequatedane 18-Sep-19 13:58
Re: What's Happening 83 Eddie Larry 18-Sep-19 14:14
Re: What's Happening 83 Archaic 18-Sep-19 22:07
Re: What's Happening 75 adequatedane 18-Sep-19 23:37
Re: What's Happening 81 Archaic 19-Sep-19 03:15
Re: What's Happening 81 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 13:30
Re: What's Happening 82 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-19 03:50
Re: What's Happening 75 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 13:25
Re: What's Happening 80 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-19 13:41
Re: What's Happening 77 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 14:32
This Isn't Over 77 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 17:10
Re: This Isn't Over 95 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-19 17:46
Re: This Isn't Over 74 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 23:14
One Has To Wonder 87 adequatedane 20-Sep-19 15:13
Re: One Has To Wonder 76 Eddie Larry 20-Sep-19 15:54
Re: One Has To Wonder 79 adequatedane 21-Sep-19 18:32
Re: One Has To Wonder 82 Eddie Larry 21-Sep-19 20:06
Re: One Has To Wonder 70 adequatedane 21-Sep-19 23:20
Re: One Has To Wonder 70 Eddie Larry 22-Sep-19 00:34
Re: One Has To Wonder 72 adequatedane 22-Sep-19 12:35
Re: One Has To Wonder 116 Eddie Larry 22-Sep-19 12:46
Re: War with Iran? 83 adequatedane 21-Sep-19 15:01


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.