Global Village :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For good-natured and mutually-respectful discussions of politics and current affairs. Soap-boxing and the promotion of extremist causes motivated by hate will not be tolerated by our moderators. 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Hi EL

You bring up some interesting points and yes it could have been worse. It does appear more a warning attack. But there are other things which don't add up because although the Yemen war is a problem for Iran, its not the problem which is crippling its economy. That is the problem of sanctions and ending the war in Yemen won't end them. Also the Saudi's can't end the sanctions just the US.

I think what I'm missing is were in the midst of a policy shift regarding the ME and the even bigger battle for the Geo Political Center? Trump is obviously adverse into going into a full scale war over this confrontation and is putting the responsibility of retaliation on the Saudi's or its anti Iranian allies. At the same time he is making it clear attacking Saudi Arabia won't result in the sanctions being lifted, it will actually do the opposite. So the US may support the Saudi's in a retaliation or war with Iran but not become involved in the actual fighting?

This may make the chance of war more likely since I believe the US has been instrumental in controlling the actions of some anti Iranian states such as Saudi Arabia,UAE,Israel and Egypt. If these nations ally against Iran it would be a formidable force and Iran would not prevail. It could also be a much dirtier,costlier and longer war with higher casualties?

thank you,Dane

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
War with Iran? 795 adequatedane 15-Sep-19 02:41
Re: War with Iran? 107 adequatedane 15-Sep-19 12:30
Re: War with Iran? 109 Eddie Larry 15-Sep-19 18:31
Re: War with Iran? 89 ldennyjr 15-Sep-19 22:45
Re: War with Iran? 85 Eddie Larry 15-Sep-19 22:53
Re: War with Iran? 87 ldennyjr 16-Sep-19 14:12
Re: War with Iran? 61 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 14:24
Re: War with Iran? 71 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 20:48
Re: War with Iran? 76 ldennyjr 17-Sep-19 15:31
Re: War with Iran? 59 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 17:09
Re: War with Iran? 90 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 01:16
Re: War with Iran? 84 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 03:55
Re: War with Iran? 71 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 10:58
Re: War with Iran? 64 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 14:30
Re: War with Iran? 64 Warwick 16-Sep-19 18:20
Re: War with Iran? 60 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 19:32
Re: War with Iran? 67 Warwick 17-Sep-19 19:31
Re: War with Iran? 60 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-19 21:09
Re: War with Iran? 65 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 21:04
Re: War with Iran? 57 Warwick 17-Sep-19 19:37
Re: War with Iran? 55 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 20:54
Re: War with Iran? 53 Warwick 17-Sep-19 21:10
Re: War with Iran? 79 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 22:52
Re: War with Iran? 66 Warwick 18-Sep-19 16:54
Re: War with Iran? 60 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 20:43
Re: War with Iran? 68 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 21:06
Re: War with Iran? 69 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 13:48
Re: War with Iran? 78 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-19 19:17
Re: War with Iran? 57 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 20:58
Re: War with Iran? 89 Archaic 16-Sep-19 08:14
Re: War with Iran? 83 adequatedane 16-Sep-19 10:12
Maybe it was the Houthis 76 Eddie Larry 16-Sep-19 23:34
An Act of War 95 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 02:04
Re: An Act of War 72 Brian Patterson 17-Sep-19 03:14
Re: An Act of War 69 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 14:53
The timing shows planning. 61 Warwick 17-Sep-19 19:45
Re: The timing shows planning. 60 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 22:21
Ron Paul on the situation 76 Eddie Larry 17-Sep-19 21:08
Re: Ron Paul on the situation 65 adequatedane 17-Sep-19 22:40
Kudos to Donald 75 drrayeye 18-Sep-19 01:37
Re: Kudos to Donald 69 adequatedane 18-Sep-19 14:37
Re: Kudos to Donald 70 muppedo 19-Sep-19 21:00
Re: Kudos to Donald 53 muppedo 21-Sep-19 21:55
What's Happening 59 adequatedane 18-Sep-19 13:58
Re: What's Happening 68 Eddie Larry 18-Sep-19 14:14
Re: What's Happening 71 Archaic 18-Sep-19 22:07
Re: What's Happening 61 adequatedane 18-Sep-19 23:37
Re: What's Happening 69 Archaic 19-Sep-19 03:15
Re: What's Happening 58 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 13:30
Re: What's Happening 67 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-19 03:50
Re: What's Happening 59 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 13:25
Re: What's Happening 62 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-19 13:41
Re: What's Happening 58 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 14:32
This Isn't Over 60 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 17:10
Re: This Isn't Over 70 Eddie Larry 19-Sep-19 17:46
Re: This Isn't Over 54 adequatedane 19-Sep-19 23:14
One Has To Wonder 67 adequatedane 20-Sep-19 15:13
Re: One Has To Wonder 62 Eddie Larry 20-Sep-19 15:54
Re: One Has To Wonder 61 adequatedane 21-Sep-19 18:32
Re: One Has To Wonder 60 Eddie Larry 21-Sep-19 20:06
Re: One Has To Wonder 55 adequatedane 21-Sep-19 23:20
Re: One Has To Wonder 58 Eddie Larry 22-Sep-19 00:34
Re: One Has To Wonder 51 adequatedane 22-Sep-19 12:35
Re: One Has To Wonder 97 Eddie Larry 22-Sep-19 12:46
Re: War with Iran? 59 adequatedane 21-Sep-19 15:01


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.