Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister

Mike B</a> wrote:

_snip>

>The second picture shows nothing of value to this
>discussion,

<img src=" [www.geology.ohio-state.edu] ">
<img src=" [www.viewzone.com] ">

Take a closer look at the sandstone unit in the center of the 1st image (i.e. above the shale), do you not see the joint bounded concentric erosion morphology present there? Other than the size difference these two photos appear somewhat similar to me in their general morphology, and I would think that that should show something of value to this discussion. The 1st photo is an example of spheriodal weathering of a cliff face and it appears to be producing concentric separation bands bounded by joint planes.

>but I am very intrigued by the bottom picture.
>This does indeed show a natural formation that shows
>concentric rings in the rock. You asked whether I think this
>is spherical weathering and I have to say no. I think what
>we are looking at here is something else, but that isn't
>important.

If it is not spheriodal weathering than what is it, what geologic mechanism is producing it?

>What is important is the fact that you have shown
>a precedent for the concentric formations. This is obviously
>not manmade, so whether it is spherical weathering is really
>arbitrary. No matter what process caused the formation they
>found we know that there are completely natural examples, so
>unless they can come up with some kind of evidence of
>habitation there appears to be nothing manmade about the
>structure.

>One final comment I have is: take a close look at the
>details of your first and third picture and tell me what
>differences stick out. There are a couple of them that imply
>that these formations may not be entirely similar.

I am sure there is... no two outcrops ever are the same especially when they are different rock types potentially exposed to different erosion mechanisms.

>In the top picture look at how the tops of those rings have
>sharp edges as opposed to the smooth ones in the bottom pic.

So... they show varying degrees of weathering along the concentric fractures of separation due to erosion...

>Also as you state, the weathering of the "furnace" is still
>controlled by jointing. This will only hold true for a while
>and then the erosion will eat through the side and bottom
>joints as well.

That has not happened yet in the "Phoenician Furnaces" site. just as it has not happened in the sandstone outcrop in the first photo above.

>Both of these facts signify to me that this
>formation became exposed to weathering at a relatively recent
>date. Would you agree or disagree with that?

Yes most of the weathering and erosion appear to be recent in a geological sense.

> You must admit
>that the erosion is not very extensive so far. This also
>eliminates spheroidal weathering as the cause of the rings.

Which ring... the coloured ones or the separations? The coloured ones are the Liesgang rings. The concentric separations would be the spheriodal weathering.

>Keep in mind that I believe it is natural, I just think we
>are looking at a different process.

You will need to present a weathering mechanism that produces concentric separations of the host rock bounded by joint planes.

>> Mike B

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 216 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 01:58
what am I doing wrong??? 123 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 01:59
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 112 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 02:04
I give up 141 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 02:05
Re: I give up 159 Don Holeman 22-Apr-02 02:26
Thanks Don 137 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 03:04
Re: I give up 148 drak1 22-Apr-02 02:32
Re: I give up 134 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 02:49
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 148 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 03:05
Jaimi - HTML Problem 200 Tripp 22-Apr-02 07:09
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 126 Richard Essame 22-Apr-02 04:19
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 136 Aristarchus 22-Apr-02 10:35
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 153 Mike B 22-Apr-02 18:44
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 112 Aristarchus 23-Apr-02 20:23
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 119 mephisto 22-Apr-02 05:24
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 115 Archae Solenhofen 22-Apr-02 07:19
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 157 mephisto 22-Apr-02 17:31
well said 123 konuzion 22-Apr-02 21:09
Why Phoenician's? 151 Mike B 22-Apr-02 22:50
Re: Why Phoenician's? 112 konuzion 22-Apr-02 23:36
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 128 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 03:16
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 105 mephisto 23-Apr-02 03:55
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 139 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 05:54
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 177 Mike B 23-Apr-02 17:56
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 159 Mike B 23-Apr-02 19:20
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 177 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 21:10
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 154 Mike B 24-Apr-02 23:59
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 158 KatDawg 22-Apr-02 17:32
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 121 Mike B 22-Apr-02 19:27
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 142 mephisto 22-Apr-02 21:05
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 157 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 02:42
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 152 Mike B 23-Apr-02 17:31
I agree with Mike, Archae 183 Jaimi 23-Apr-02 17:55
Re: I agree with Mike, Archae 149 Mike B 23-Apr-02 18:19
Re: I agree with Mike, Archae 159 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 22:20
Re: I agree with Mike, Archae 118 Jaimi 24-Apr-02 03:18
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 145 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 22:10
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 121 Mike B 24-Apr-02 18:53
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 131 Archae Solenhofen 24-Apr-02 19:24
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 128 Anomalies 24-Apr-02 20:29
I don't agree... 150 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 19:46
close but no cigar 124 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 19:48
Entirely natural 110 konuzion 23-Apr-02 21:02
Re: Entirely natural 150 David Campbell 25-Apr-02 21:55
Re: Entirely natural 129 konuzion 26-Apr-02 00:05
Re: Entirely natural 121 David Campbell 26-Apr-02 03:11


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.