Mysteries :  The Official GrahamHancock.com forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Mike B wrote:

>Is that supposed to be some kind of joke. Do you know what
>spheroidal weathering is even?

This is what the original poster actually said "classic examples of spheroidal weathering
and Liesgang rings"... you left out the Liesgang rings. Here is the geological definitions of spheroidal weathering and Liesgang rings:

Liesegang rings Secondary, nested rings or bands caused by rhythmic precipitation within a fluid-saturated rock.

spheroidal weathering A form of chemical weathering in which concentric shells of decayed rock (ranging in diameter from 2 cm to 2 m) are successively loosened and separated from a block of rock by water penetrating the bounding joints or other fractures and attacking the block from all sides. It is similar to the larger-scale exfoliation produced usually by mechanical weathering. Syn: onionskin weathering; concentric weathering; spherical weathering.

Bates, R.L., and Jackson J.A., (1984) Dictionary of Geological Terms:3rd Edition Doubleday New York, 392p

>It does not mean that
>concentric rings will form in the rock as you suggest.

Are there no separations of concentric shells of weathering visible in this photo?

<img src=" [www.viewzone.com];

The variation in colour in this image are Liesegang rings representing alteration minerlization from groundwater.

> It
>simply means that the corners of the rock are attacked first
>because they have the most surface area. Since the corners
>are attacked first the rock will try to get to a sphere shape
>for its entire life. Eventually it will just be another
>small round pebble.

It depends on what stage the weathering is... here is a website that illustrates the process:

<a href="[www.geo.wvu.edu] "> [www.geo.wvu.edu] </a>

The rock in the above "Phoenician Furnaces" photo is still jointed and the erosion morphology is still controlled by that fact. Here for example we see a in Pennsivianian sandstone outcrop, which exhibits spheriodal weathering along joint planes.

<img src="[www.geology.ohio-state.edu];

An example of spheriodal weathering in granite:

<img src="[www.schweich.com] ">

Do you notice any similarity between this image and the ones provided in the "Phoenician Furnaces" website? If the above images are not spherical weathering then what geological mechanism is creating them... do you have a geologic term for it?

>I would really love to see the picture that you refer to in
>"Modern Physical Geography." I will be looking for a copy of
>it I assure you. The type of concentric shells you refer to
>are an indication of deposition, not erosion.

In spheroidal weathering? I don't think so... Here is the definition of weathering:

weathering: The destructive processes by which rocks are changed on exposure to atmospheric agents at or near the earth's surface, with little or no transport of the loosened or altered material; specifically: the physical disintegration and chemical decomposition of rock that produce an in-situ mantle of waste and prepares sediments for transportation.

I do not see anything in the definition of weathering or spheriodal weathering that indicates it forms directly as a result of deposition.

Archae Solenhofen (solenhofen@hotmail.com)

_snip>

Options: ReplyQuote


Subject Views Written By Posted
Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 168 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 01:58
what am I doing wrong??? 83 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 01:59
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 73 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 02:04
I give up 100 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 02:05
Re: I give up 116 Don Holeman 22-Apr-02 02:26
Thanks Don 97 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 03:04
Re: I give up 107 drak1 22-Apr-02 02:32
Re: I give up 94 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 02:49
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 100 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 03:05
Jaimi - HTML Problem 143 Tripp 22-Apr-02 07:09
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 82 Richard Essame 22-Apr-02 04:19
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 95 Aristarchus 22-Apr-02 10:35
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 112 Mike B 22-Apr-02 18:44
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 69 Aristarchus 23-Apr-02 20:23
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 73 mephisto 22-Apr-02 05:24
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 72 Archae Solenhofen 22-Apr-02 07:19
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 115 mephisto 22-Apr-02 17:31
well said 78 konuzion 22-Apr-02 21:09
Why Phoenician's? 109 Mike B 22-Apr-02 22:50
Re: Why Phoenician's? 73 konuzion 22-Apr-02 23:36
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 83 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 03:16
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 66 mephisto 23-Apr-02 03:55
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 95 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 05:54
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 136 Mike B 23-Apr-02 17:56
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 115 Mike B 23-Apr-02 19:20
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 126 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 21:10
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 109 Mike B 24-Apr-02 23:59
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 105 KatDawg 22-Apr-02 17:32
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 84 Mike B 22-Apr-02 19:27
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 102 mephisto 22-Apr-02 21:05
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 114 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 02:42
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 112 Mike B 23-Apr-02 17:31
I agree with Mike, Archae 137 Jaimi 23-Apr-02 17:55
Re: I agree with Mike, Archae 111 Mike B 23-Apr-02 18:19
Re: I agree with Mike, Archae 116 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 22:20
Re: I agree with Mike, Archae 77 Jaimi 24-Apr-02 03:18
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 101 Archae Solenhofen 23-Apr-02 22:10
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 81 Mike B 24-Apr-02 18:53
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 87 Archae Solenhofen 24-Apr-02 19:24
Re: Has anyone ever seen rock formations like this? 88 Anomalies 24-Apr-02 20:29
I don't agree... 109 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 19:46
close but no cigar 83 Jaimi 22-Apr-02 19:48
Entirely natural 70 konuzion 23-Apr-02 21:02
Re: Entirely natural 108 David Campbell 25-Apr-02 21:55
Re: Entirely natural 84 konuzion 26-Apr-02 00:05
Re: Entirely natural 78 David Campbell 26-Apr-02 03:11


Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.