Mysteries :  The Official forums
For serious discussion of the controversies, approaches and enigmas surrounding the origins and development of the human species and of human civilization. (NB: for more ‘out there’ posts we point you in the direction of the ‘Paranormal & Supernatural’ Message Board). 
Welcome! Log InRegister
Let me begin by saying that evidence that exists for orthodox or the unorthodox researchers in Egyptology is not sufficient to establish the truth beyond doubt. What exists is necessary but not sufficient.

Peer review, agreement even among the scientific community may not mean much. Let me state an historic example from the field of Physics (where hypothesis can be tested lot more easily than Egyptology through experiments and observable physical phenomena):

End of 19th century a very well respected physicist made a famous observation that physics can explain all phenomena except two: one of them being Photo electric effect. This was also the knowledgeable opinion held by the majority of the physicists at the time. One Einstein made a break through and physics has not been the same again. His theories of relativity could not be proved immediately. That did not make him a quack or a spinmaster as some thought since subsequent observations and experiments prove his theories to be correct.

Opinion held by the majority of the scientific community is not the truth. Only alternative thinking broke the barriers for Physics (such as assuming the speed of light to be a constant). The same is true for any discipline and Egyptology does not have the luxury of experimentation or observable phenomena. Alternative theories will only help.



Options: ReplyQuote

Subject Views Written By Posted
Spence and Precession 372 Andy 16-Nov-00 17:53
RE: Spence and Precession 148 Sharif 16-Nov-00 18:23
RE: Spence and Precession 163 Andy 16-Nov-00 19:16
RE: Spence and Precession 162 Sharif 16-Nov-00 22:15
RE: Spence and Precession 184 Andy 16-Nov-00 19:22
RE: Spence and Precession 153 Sharif 17-Nov-00 00:06
RE: Spence and Precession 175 Andy 17-Nov-00 01:19
RE: Spence and Precession 171 Dr Winston O'Boogie 17-Nov-00 11:27
RE: Spence and Precession 331 Graham Hancock 17-Nov-00 11:51
RE: Spence and Precession 144 Dr Winston O'Boogie 17-Nov-00 12:20
RE: Spence and Precession 232 Graham Hancock 17-Nov-00 14:29
RE: Spence and Precession 178 Sharif 17-Nov-00 12:02
RE: Spence and Precession 149 Dr Winston O'Boogie 17-Nov-00 12:29
RE: Spence and Precession 184 John Lennon 22-Nov-00 15:32
RE: Spence and Precession 144 jameske 17-Nov-00 12:34
RE: Spence and Precession 173 Sri Kowta 17-Nov-00 15:00

Sorry, only registered users may post in this forum.