Why would finding an aprw (not phyle) name Xnmw xwfw smrw be the “kiss of death” to anything, other than on the assumption that the Egyptians stuck to just one royal name in crew names of the smrw form in a given context?
(I note in passing that crew names of the smrw form are known for several pharaohs. Are they all forgeries by Vyse?)
If the rule is assumed, why is Robert not allowed to base an inference on it?
Post Edited (22-Jul-14 20:38)