> Why did he not leave a signed affidavit?
> Why is the evidence so weak?
It seems like you may be expecting a higher burden of proof from Humphries Brewer than you are from Howard Vyse.
Where is the solid proof that Vyse discovered that cartouche intact as we see it today?
Why didn't Vyse document the authenticity of his find publicly by having objective witnesses?
Did Vyse sign a legal affidavit attesting to the authenticity of his find?
Regarding Vyse's discovery, "Why is the evidence so weak?"...and yet still cherished so dearly among Egyptologists as being unquestionably authentic?